Live data from Hacker News

Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

nytimes.com

81–90 of 134 posts

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#81
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, this is basically where we are at today. Apparently we are to hold every rich person to some esoteric standard because every wealthy person made their money by exploiting others; none of them were positive-sum contributors to society. And when someone donates a lot of money, we just say they are buying PR and have calculated the ROI like the terrible capitalist they are, with zero evidence at all this is the cas…

If it's a straight donation maybe it's PRless. The number of people like Trump's or Zuckerberg's who donate to family foundations that give them tax breaks and give them a way to funnel money to their family through jobs that are paid by the foundations, has seriously degraded trust in the concept of charities as organizations. It's like running a company nowadays and wondering why your employees have no loyalty. Yea…

Showing loyalty for the sake of loyalty as a worker has nothing to do with honor. It's... stupid. I do not expect my employees to show loyalty to me because they should. I expect them to remain employed with me because it is their best option, and I compete for their labor business with the other employers in the pool.

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're still donating. Are we seriously chastising people for giving money to causes of their own volition because we feel it isn't enough?

Uh, yes? I give a higher percentage of my income to charitable causes than any of these "philanthropists" and I manage to not waste an insane amount of money on a disgustingly wasteful life of luxury at the same time, but for some reason I don't have an army of sycophants defending my every action on the internet.

A higher percentage of your income does not magically feed more people, nor does a "flat tax" like you propose (merely substituting "donation" for the tax) scale economically for any number of reasons.

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#83
post #64

The reason Jack Ma is stepping down from Alibaba is that he was becoming too powerful and influencial in China. Jack is very smart and knows that you can build your wealth and power until you begin to threaten the party, then you either need to step down or you will be forcefully taken down.

Interesting thought. Can you provide any historical examples of this?

The Dictator's Handbook talks about this in good details. Recommended read, especially in today's world political climate.

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#84
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting thought. Can you provide any historical examples of this?

You can look at his existing behavior for clues to that being the case. When he took control of Ant Financial from Alibaba, spinning it off, he gave himself 2/3 of the business. That diluted position would still be worth around $80-$90 billion today. Instead of holding onto that, he proceeded to massively dilute his ownership and control of Ant. The reason he did that, is the same reason he was allowed to take it awa…

That process began long before Alibaba ran into problems with Xi's people (and it was a petty dispute with lowest tier retainer)

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#85
post #5

>Among China’s biggest companies, Alibaba is viewed as one of the firms with the deepest ranks of management talent. Claim going perpendicular to experience of every Alibaba employee I met. A person who was singlehandedly running both business development and operations for all of Aliexpress has left the company after 5 years without a promotion. The co has a reputation for squeezing work enthusiasm out from even mos…

I know someone who now works at Huawei, which is 1.5 hours by shuttle from where he lives in Beijing. Typically gets there 8am and leaves 7-8pm. He used to work at Alibaba which was 30 mins from his house. I asked why he changed and he said at Alibaba he didn't get home before midnight most days.

Of course overtime is not paid...

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#86
post #77
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Xiao Jianhua, Wang Jian (HNA) are recent examples. When Bo Xilai was purged, Xu Ming, a businessman with very close ties to him, were arrested for bribery, and later died mysteriously in prison. Given the turbulent political scene it could be a good move to distance himself from everything, at least for some time.

When one stands in front of the Many Faced God, all the money they had, even if it were trillions are literally useless. Many may have read about it for a while, but it was only these recent events that makes you truly understand. Why they are willing to paid millions for "services" to move their "millions" out of China and live outside. Fan Bingbing is another example, and countless others. And it proves that China,…

i don't know what kind of coverage you're expecting but in 2016 i've read about missing chinese billioniares on fortune [0] [1]. there are also other coverages: [2] [3] [4]

[0] http://fortune.com/2015/12/11/the-warren-buffett-of-china-di...

[1] http://fortune.com/2016/01/08/china-billionaire-missing/

[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2016/02/01/chinas-missing-ceos-and-bill...

[3] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/news/china-billi...

[4] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-08-24/asia-casi...

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#87
post #9

I hope he's able to make a positive impact on education!

with the intensity he speaks and the clarity he has in what he speaks and given the fact he was a teacher, I fully expect him to actually make a positive impact

I wish all geeks who want to reform (save) education also had Ma's classroom experience. It's easy to tell other people how to do their jobs. Hard to actually do the job.

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#88
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, this is basically where we are at today. Apparently we are to hold every rich person to some esoteric standard because every wealthy person made their money by exploiting others; none of them were positive-sum contributors to society. And when someone donates a lot of money, we just say they are buying PR and have calculated the ROI like the terrible capitalist they are, with zero evidence at all this is the cas…

It's disingenuous to frame the problems people have with the 1% as being due to them not positively contributing to society. Rather, the entire capitalist system, tax loopholes, and corrupt politicians have lead to increased disparity between the rich and poor. I'm fine with the claim that some people who create value and are net-positive, such as many of the rich people, absolutely should have significant wealth. Ho…

That the rich get richer is just math, not a value statement.

Preferential attachment in the absence of proactive redistribution leads to accelerating inequity.

As you know, too much inequity undermines democracy.

If we want a Liberal, democratic society, we need progressive policies. Some mechanisms to offset windfall profits, level the playing field. Debt jubilees, entitlements, UBI, Keynesianism, something.

While I'm (very) sympathetic to "late stage capitalism" rhetoric, I think it's besides the point. Inequity predates capitalism and won't be remedied by eliminating capitalism.

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#89
post #11

The brewing trade war can't make running the company easy for Ma, considering Alibaba does more volume than eBay and Amazon combined as a portal to Chinese manufacturers. Taking into account that the company's listed on a US stock exchange yet still has to answer to government regulation back in China, I can't imagine he's having a good time being caught in the middle.

Good points but probably not the reason why he is really retiring. Jack Ma cannot be more famous than their President.

Re: Jack Ma to Retire from Alibaba

#90

The reason Jack Ma is stepping down from Alibaba is that he was becoming too powerful and influencial in China. Jack is very smart and knows that you can build your wealth and power until you begin to threaten the party, then you either need to step down or you will be forcefully taken down.

Definitely influential...

I was with a 30-year-old Chinese lady last night. Entrepreneur... I asked who her role models are, and she said "Only one... Jack Ma".

Post reply on HN