Earlier quoted context omitted.
Sorry, what's wrong with REI? I've never been asked to donate to charity at my local REI...
Haven't you been pushed about getting an REI membership? I think twice before asking any REI salesman for help, because I know they are going to push me to get a membership. They're doing their job since their incentives are tied to memberships to some degree, but it makes for a poor experience. /edit:I'd rather be asked about a membership once at the cashier's than by every sales staff I talk to during my visit.
FWIW the dividend is pretty nice. Combined with the sale I saved a pretty solid chunk of money on a nice cooler.