Live data from Hacker News

Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

espn.com

11–20 of 98 posts

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#11
post #7

He isn't smart enough to adjust his offensive game. His go to move is to lower his shoulder. The best defensive players and teams give way and then he is off balance and he tends to miss the shot. He has done that his entire career. See Durant and Iguodala's defense. Also his straight line drives are completely negated by a good shot blocker(s). See Tyson Chandler and the Mavericks. A more adaptable player would have…

This is nonsense. LeBron has greatly improved his 3 point shooting over his career and in Miami he was able to develop a low post game.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#12

His memory has always been laughably impressive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNVJFRl6f6s

Wow, this IS truly incredible.

This reminds me of how many chess grandmasters can easily recall and recite and visualize every move in a game from years past. I think James deserves a little more credit than just being on par with chess GMs: to memorize something so complex as a basketball game without even attempting to commit it to memory speaks to his extraordinary intelligence.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#13
First-off, I think this is interesting because athletes have hit the point of diminishing returns on physical abilities, and now the games are turning mental in every sport. The NBA has done a great job at turning strategy into a spectator sport. In the NFL, the possibly single worst athlete in the quarterback position is the best ever. They are changing too. I’m not sure MLB can adapt. I wonder whether this doesn’t just pave the way for eSports to take over.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#14

His memory has always been laughably impressive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNVJFRl6f6s

I’ve noticed a strong tendency toward eidetic memory in people that started in their professions without going to college. Very common in enlisted military, for instance. I think it might actually be quite natural. Education, I think, overloads a person with all of this useless stuff to make them ‘well-rounded’ and they lose their ability to focus on the details.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#15
post #7

He isn't smart enough to adjust his offensive game. His go to move is to lower his shoulder. The best defensive players and teams give way and then he is off balance and he tends to miss the shot. He has done that his entire career. See Durant and Iguodala's defense. Also his straight line drives are completely negated by a good shot blocker(s). See Tyson Chandler and the Mavericks. A more adaptable player would have…

In general, it's smart to lower your shoulder and go to the rim if you have any daylight at all. Most of the time the defense will be called for a block if there is any contact (offensive fouls are rarely called -- only when you are perfectly set do you usually get the charge call). This is why defensive players "give way" -- it's the best hope you have. IMO the greatest flaw in how basketball is officiated is the strict conditions refs require to call a charge -- offensive players should exploit it more.

Lebron is smart.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#16
post #7

He isn't smart enough to adjust his offensive game. His go to move is to lower his shoulder. The best defensive players and teams give way and then he is off balance and he tends to miss the shot. He has done that his entire career. See Durant and Iguodala's defense. Also his straight line drives are completely negated by a good shot blocker(s). See Tyson Chandler and the Mavericks. A more adaptable player would have…

Let it go, Skip.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#17
post #14

His memory has always been laughably impressive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNVJFRl6f6s

I’ve noticed a strong tendency toward eidetic memory in people that started in their professions without going to college. Very common in enlisted military, for instance. I think it might actually be quite natural. Education, I think, overloads a person with all of this useless stuff to make them ‘well-rounded’ and they lose their ability to focus on the details.

Learning makes people stupid is a very strange thesis with zero support. It seems more likely that you have no idea what the instance of eidetic memory in either population, that memory doesn't work like that at all, and that small handful of anecdotes is leading to a spurious connection.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#18

Sean McVay (NFL's LA Rams coach) has something similar going on: https://www.businessinsider.com/sean-mcvay-memory-hbo-real-s...

When Lane Kiffin was the offensive coordinator at Alabama in 2015, he interviewed a recent college grad who had done his undergraduate work at Florida and Kansas. Charlie Weis Jr., the son of the former Notre Dame and Kansas coach, sought an analyst job with the Crimson Tide, and Kiffin had been told the kid had a photographic memory.

So during the interview, Kiffin handed Weis his driver’s license and his credit card. You can have these for three minutes, Kiffin recalled telling Weis. Then I’ll take them back and start asking questions. After the allotted time ended, Kiffin took back the cards and started the test.

What street do I live on?

Weis answered correctly. He correctly recited various facts gleaned from the two cards. The next day, Kiffin decided to test the job candidate’s retention.

What’s the expiration date on my credit card?

Weis answered correctly. If he didn’t already have the job, that cinched it.

Weis and Kiffin spent two seasons together in Tuscaloosa. Well, most of two seasons. Kiffin jokes that they were 28–1 together and 0–1 apart. This year, they’re back together with different job titles. Kiffin is the second-year head coach at Florida Atlantic, leading a team that went 11–3 and won Conference USA last season. Weis, who turned 25 in April, is the offensive coordinator. “Sometimes it’s crazy to think about,” Weis said Sunday.

Weis doesn’t think about it too often, though. He’s too busy for introspection. A night earlier, Kiffin and Weis had led the FAU offense through its most important scrimmage of the preseason. They’re trying to winnow down a quarterback race that features three transfer quarterbacks competing to take the job abdicated by 2017 starter Jason Driskel, who opted to retire from football in January and who obtained a civil engineering degree in May. In less than two weeks, the Owls will open the season at Oklahoma. They haven’t trailed in a game since October, but they haven’t been challenged the way they will by the three-time defending Big 12 champ.

Whether former Sooner Chris Robison, former Florida State Seminole DeAndre Johnson or former Arkansas Razorback/SMU Mustang Rafe Peavey will win the job is a hot topic on campus, but an even more intriguing question is this: Which son of a famous football coach will call the plays? Will it be Kiffin—the son of legendary NFL defensive coordinator Monte—or Weis? Weis, asked what percentage of plays he called in Saturday’s scrimmage, deferred. “That’s up to coach Kiffin to talk about,” he said. “It’s not my place.” Kiffin didn’t give a direct answer either, and both men discussed a collaborative effort.

Their collaboration at Alabama worked beautifully for the Crimson Tide. Kiffin designed the game plans with help from Weis, whose memory and attention to detail allowed him to find vulnerabilities in defenses that Kiffin could exploit on gameday. If the Owls can now combine Kiffin’s ability to spot potential huge plays in-game with Weis’s thorough prep and instant recall, the offense should be as good or better than the one that put up 6.8 yards a play and 40.6 points a game last season. That recall, Kiffin believes, will give FAU the equivalent of the photos that we see NFL quarterbacks thumbing through on the sidelines during games. Such photos aren’t allowed in college football, but there is no rule against a coach taking one in his head. Kiffin had an idea Weis could do that when, during his Alabama interview, Weis rattled off all 11 jersey numbers for the starting defense of a team he’d scouted earlier. After working so closely with Weis in ’15 and ’16, Kiffin is sure of it.

https://www.si.com/college-football/2018/08/20/charlie-weis-...

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#19

His memory has always been laughably impressive: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eNVJFRl6f6s

I have heard the same about the top Formula One Drivers. After the race they can recall almost every turn of the race in detail with their engineers. It takes hours to get all the information across. It makes sense that a good memory is big asset for an athlete. It allows them to replay a situation and learn from it. When I did martial arts my memory of a fight was pretty vague so I couldn't analyze and learn much.

Re: Total Recall: LeBron's mighty mind (2014)

#20
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve noticed a strong tendency toward eidetic memory in people that started in their professions without going to college. Very common in enlisted military, for instance. I think it might actually be quite natural. Education, I think, overloads a person with all of this useless stuff to make them ‘well-rounded’ and they lose their ability to focus on the details.

Learning makes people stupid is a very strange thesis with zero support. It seems more likely that you have no idea what the instance of eidetic memory in either population, that memory doesn't work like that at all, and that small handful of anecdotes is leading to a spurious connection.

this seems overly hostile to what appears to be a hypothesis

the idea that what we're trained to notice changes what we perceive, doesn't strike me as strange thesis at all

I'm reminded of this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ahg6qcgoay4

Post reply on HN