Live data from Hacker News

OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

eejournal.com

31–40 of 49 posts

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#32
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are other pain points too. One I ran into lately is the business version of OneDrive uses a fixed folder name based off your company name and it's hard to change. For example: C:\Users\Rumpelstiltskin\OneDrive - Rumpelstiltskin's Gold Spinning Services Inc.\ Then you realize that Excel has a 218 character path limit on file names and things get ridiculous really fast.

subst X: C:\Users\Rumpelstiltskin\OneDrive - Rumpelstiltskin's Gold Spinning Services Inc.\ Annoying, but it does work.

Then you're married to mapped drives like that and anyone you share with has trouble syncing files unless they're using the same trick. I also managed to create path structures that crashed the OneDrive client when I was testing that.

Eventually I settled on abbreviating company names and putting OneDrive in C:\OD, so:

  C:\OD\OneDrive - RGSS\Shared Folder\
Not great, but better. Then when you share files and someone else syncs, they get:

  C:\OD\RGSS\Rumpelstiltskin - Shared Folder\
And it all goes to hell again. Lol. The base path length's are reasonably close though and seems to work ok.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#33
post #30

OneDrive is a classic example of how screwed MS management techniques still are: it started as a Windows-only service that was pretty good; then the focus switched to Mac and now it’s pretty good on Mac, but the Windows version got worse. Office apps kinda work with it (I don’t use Outlook...), but the Sharepoint integration is a shitshow. It all seems very haphazardly developed. For something that should be the rock…

SharePoint integration is a shit show? I've never seen a SharePoint setup that isn't a shitshow, the enterprise SaaS we work with even use it as their help desk it's comically disasterous.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How did Windows 10 ship? The thing constantly overrides user-set preferences: fonts, colors, and worst of all - default apps. Reports usage data to Microsoft with no way to turn it off. An update mechanism that lives its own dominating life, interrupting user workflow whenever it wants.

To be fair, it was replacing Windows 8.

In hindsight, Windows 8 wasn't that bad overall. The real disaster was the Metro UI, but the underlying OS was relatively unobtrusive and a bit more performant than Win7.

Once something like Classic Shell was installed, it was pretty slick and reliable.

My last Windows machine now runs 10 begrudgingly, and compared to my daily drivers MacOS and Ubuntu, it's a shockingly inconsistent operating system. I don't rely on it for "real work" thankfully.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#36
post #8

I may be wrong, but I suspect it is yet another case of "disconnection" between what the MS (in this case but I have seen the same phenomenon with other software) developers have (in terms of hardware, connection speed and bandwidth) and what your average Joe has or can afford. Since several years softwares seems to be designed by people that have top of the range resources (which is normal since their hardware and c…

Where I live, many businesses are stuck on 25Mbit/s down, 2Mbit/s up DSL connections. You're not wrong.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#37
post #19

I feel that OneDrive is a piece of $&!+. Not that it's bad, but that it's randomly inconsistent. We made the decision two years ago to run our company on OneDrive, and we've experienced almost everything covered in this article (except the .pst and one-note file issues because we don't use them). That being said, I don't really know of a good alternative. It mostly works. Until those really random days when it just c…

DropBox?

Dropbox doesn't contain the same feature set as OneDrive with Office.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#38

That was the greatest tragedy from the Windows 8 era. Somehow Dropbox can make cloud sync work, Box can make cloud sync work, Google can make cloud sync work, ... Microsoft can't. How is that?

Certainly on the business side, but I can't imagine the consumer side is much different, the whole thing is backed by SharePoint. That is what causes the file type issues. Dropbox and co. have built actual real backends for their products rather than trying to cram the feature set into another product.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, it was replacing Windows 8.

In hindsight, Windows 8 wasn't that bad overall. The real disaster was the Metro UI, but the underlying OS was relatively unobtrusive and a bit more performant than Win7. Once something like Classic Shell was installed, it was pretty slick and reliable. My last Windows machine now runs 10 begrudgingly, and compared to my daily drivers MacOS and Ubuntu, it's a shockingly inconsistent operating system. I don't rely on…

Classic Shell was great. Looking back, going from XP to 7 to 8 to 10, I can't think of any improvement, but the user experience got consistently worse.

This might be the Second Law of Thermodynamics at work, but seriously, I don't understand how these things got shipped.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#40
I think the main problem is that everywhere old, ugly SharePoint shines through. It's the same with Teams. It looks good when you start but then you quickly get into all these weird behaviors caused by SharePoint.
Post reply on HN