Live data from Hacker News

Chargify New Pricing

chargify.com

151–160 of 167 posts

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#151

Full disclosure: I run Spreedly, an earlier to market but much less funded competitor to Chargify. Here's the dirty little secret that Spreedly discovered about 18 months ago, and that I'm sure Chargify - like Recurly before them - has now found out for themselves: there are plenty of people who want to start subscription businesses, and out of those, the vast majority will not succeed and will actually end up costin…

Not a fan of their phone support

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#152
Ironically, we just wrote a blog post (http://blog.quplo.com/2010/10/the-payment-provider-shortlist...) about Chargify as it was in our "shortlist" of 3 remaining (subscription) payment providers that don't give European businesses a hard time. Chargify got a pretty good end of the stick, short of a couple of weird things like charging for free users.

But with this pricing change, they're off the list. Sorry. So far it looks like Spreedly will be getting our money.

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#153
post #72

Some Chargify alternatives: http://cheddargetter.com http://www.spreedly.com http://recurly.com http://www.braintreepaymentsolutions.com

Just a note that Recurly did this exact same thing several months ago, though they've since changed their prices again. We were literally 1 day away from launching on Recurly when they changed prices. Spooked by the sudden price hike, we spent a good deal of time re-writing our ecommerce on Chargify. And now this. Maybe it's time to just bite the bullet and roll our own solution. Spreedly doesn't provide the same fun…

This is where I have to plug my alternative to rolling your own: http://railskits.com/saas

You can use it with Braintree and have complete control over how the billing runs.

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#154

Wow thats a real bummer, I was about to integrate it into an app, but I certainly don't want to blow $99/mo on something that may or may not earn me a small fraction of that Has anyone used Spreedly or CheddarGetter etc? Thoughts? Are there any robust open source self-hosted solutions? (For Django, Rails, PHP?) Considering its just a subscription management wrapper for Authorize.net, shouldn't be too hard to cut out…

Yes, self-hosted Rails solution here: http://railskits.com/saas

Shameless self-promotion, yes, but it's actually relevant. :)

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#155

Full disclosure: I run Spreedly, an earlier to market but much less funded competitor to Chargify. Here's the dirty little secret that Spreedly discovered about 18 months ago, and that I'm sure Chargify - like Recurly before them - has now found out for themselves: there are plenty of people who want to start subscription businesses, and out of those, the vast majority will not succeed and will actually end up costin…

Not a fan of their phone support

At Spreedly we rarely do any phone pre-sales or support, and that's a very intentional choice. As noted above, good phone support is expensive to provide, and one of the ways we've decided to keep costs down (at least for now) is by sticking to email. For those who want phone pre-sales and support, Chargify's offering looks like it could be a good option.

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#156
post #15

We have about 35 customers in Chargify, and growing steadily, but $99/month will eat almost half our monthly revenue. Really disappointed.

Really? Almost half your revenue is $99 off 35 customers? You charge your customers marginally more than $2.80 a month? Maybe I'm misunderstanding something here with the pricing, but this sounds more like you're getting hurt because you're trying to take micro payments which typically isn't a solved problem (yet).

>>Really? Almost half your revenue is $99 off 35 customers?

Not sure how you got that. I'm not taking micropayments via Chargify. I don't think you understood me.

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#157
post #15

We have about 35 customers in Chargify, and growing steadily, but $99/month will eat almost half our monthly revenue. Really disappointed.

Really? Almost half your revenue is $99 off 35 customers? You charge your customers marginally more than $2.80 a month? Maybe I'm misunderstanding something here with the pricing, but this sounds more like you're getting hurt because you're trying to take micro payments which typically isn't a solved problem (yet).

http://www.talentsoup.com/forum/topic/1023

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#158
post #53

Guys, if this upsets you, you are not in the target market. (Much love, but the real world spends real money on revenue drivers.)

Gotta remember that pricing is the hardest part of running a SAAS business. More often than not, you're going to get it wrong the first time, and maybe even the second time.

As much as Chargify's new prices are a turnoff, I understand their reasoning. I also understand the outrage. Any uptick in pricing is going to result in unhappy chatter on the Internets.

As someone working on a SAAS project, I'm doubly interested in this news.

1 - for keeping an eye on the competitive landscape for companies like Chargify and Spreedly.

2 - for looking at the side effects of pricing changes and the negative marketing impact

I have this feeling that when I finally release my product, I should price it slightly higher than my gut tells me to ensure that I reduce the risk of any price hike negativity resulting from unforeseen operating costs.

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not a fan of their phone support

At Spreedly we rarely do any phone pre-sales or support, and that's a very intentional choice. As noted above, good phone support is expensive to provide, and one of the ways we've decided to keep costs down (at least for now) is by sticking to email. For those who want phone pre-sales and support, Chargify's offering looks like it could be a good option.

Totally understand the reasons not to offer this, but we feel it is pretty important the ability to call your billing provider 24/7 and talk to someone as well as a NOC that is staffed 24/7 monitoring all systems. Collecting money is what makes a business work, sending an email that someone might get to the next day just is not good enough for us.

Re: Chargify New Pricing

#160

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have any experience with Braintree's subscription payment service? How does it compare?

The recurring payments capabilities of gateways, such as Braintree, Auth.net, etc. typically are not as robust as the recurring payments capabilities of the companies that specifically focused on that capability such as Chargify, Recurly, Zuora, etc. If you just need to charge the same customers exactly the same amount on exactly the same timeframe, then the capabilities of gateways such as Braintree may be ok for yo…

I just wanted to clarify that Braintree does has additional recurring billing features that are not mentioned here. You have the ability to set up multiple plans, modify individual subscriptions, created add-ons and discounts, create one time charges and more. For a more complete list of features you can check out our website: http://www.braintreepaymentsolutions.com/services/recurring-....

-Jen (Braintree)

Post reply on HN