Live data from Hacker News

OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

eejournal.com

11–20 of 49 posts

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#11
>”Wait, what? OneDrive can’t handle Microsoft’s own file types? Sure enough, the official online help says you have to move the offending files to a different folder that OneDrive can’t see”

How does something like that ship? That’s going to affect virtually every Office user. Why not just filter out files that won’t sync and warn the user?

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#13
"To be fair, Microsoft accounts now support two-factor authentication, but it’s not enabled by default."

I agree that uploading is on the slow side and have encountered the OneNote errors the author refers to. However, suggesting that somehow in 2018 2FA in a mainstream online service should be on by default borders to insanity. I must spend 10 minutes to explain to a normal person what 2FA is, and almost everyone loses interest afterwards. His Windows Hello criticism is also irrelevant, since it is completely optional and easily ignored.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#15
post #11

>”Wait, what? OneDrive can’t handle Microsoft’s own file types? Sure enough, the official online help says you have to move the offending files to a different folder that OneDrive can’t see” How does something like that ship? That’s going to affect virtually every Office user. Why not just filter out files that won’t sync and warn the user?

Also, what makes those combinations of bytes unsupported by OneDrive? I get that OneDrive might have some special support and recognition for certain filetypes, but I assume it also supports unknown file types ... so why on earth would they make it specially recognize certain file types just to blacklist them?

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#16
Although I’m happy with Office 365, Microsoft’s policy of trying to obscure valid storage locations has a stink to it. That a cloud service even has a say about file type? Folder structure? Unthinkable.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#18
post #11

>”Wait, what? OneDrive can’t handle Microsoft’s own file types? Sure enough, the official online help says you have to move the offending files to a different folder that OneDrive can’t see” How does something like that ship? That’s going to affect virtually every Office user. Why not just filter out files that won’t sync and warn the user?

How did Windows 10 ship?

The thing constantly overrides user-set preferences: fonts, colors, and worst of all - default apps. Reports usage data to Microsoft with no way to turn it off. An update mechanism that lives its own dominating life, interrupting user workflow whenever it wants.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#19
I feel that OneDrive is a piece of $&!+. Not that it's bad, but that it's randomly inconsistent.

We made the decision two years ago to run our company on OneDrive, and we've experienced almost everything covered in this article (except the .pst and one-note file issues because we don't use them).

That being said, I don't really know of a good alternative. It mostly works. Until those really random days when it just chokes on something and you have no idea why. And then you can be effed.

I backup the partition every month or tow just to make sure.

If anyone has ideas (and I've got non-tech users across windows and Mac), I'd love to hear about it. Honestly, if I could run something else covering a few dozen gigs of documents, I would.

Re: OneDrive Leaves a Lot to be Desired

#20
post #6

iCloud doesn’t get a lot of love around here, but it’s been one of the most stable cloud services that I’ve been using for the past couple of years or so. It really lives up to Apple’s motto of “it just works”

I like it but don't use it as much as Dropbox. To be fair, Apple had some disappointing false starts with their services related to syncing.
Post reply on HN