Live data from Hacker News

What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

techcrunch.com

21–30 of 201 posts

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#21
post #15

They’re not chatbots - the replies are too specific and organic in some of the tweets I read. I’m guessing Amazon told these workers that someone would convey their general sentiments on their behalf. That or this is satire, I hope.

i'm with satire, or counter marketeering

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#22
These accounts certainly seem like they are being directed or encouraged by corporate. I know quite a few of the ambassadors at the warehouse where I work and I don't think any of them would post these kind of responses on Twitter without some kind of direction from above.

Also, in case there is confusion with the term "ambassador", from my understanding this is mostly an internal title for associates who lead some training sessions for new hires. It doesn't come with any pay or benefit increases, it's just a nice thing to do if you like training new hires and want an occasional break from your normal duties. These aren't really meant to be outward facing brand ambassadors, at least that's been my understanding.

Disclosure: I work at an Amazon warehouse.

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#23

This is standard social media PR - fail to see what the issue is. Brand ambassadors that promote the business have been common for a very long time. Nothing to see here.

You're probably right. Maybe the distinction is that Amazon has gotten a lot of bad press about its warehouses so the cognitive dissonance felt by the observer is more pronounced.

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#24

I'm not even disturbed. I'm just very puzzled that there are people who would think these messages were anything but pure PR propaganda. It's so blatantly obvious to me. ...and it might just be my unfamiliarity, but "FC Ambassador" just reminds me of football more than anything else. That part of their branding isn't working, if they're trying to get into the minds of people who aren't familiar with the company.

You’d be surprised what people will believe. I once commanded 11m Facebook fans. It was surprisingly easy to convince a certain percentage of people to do whatever you tell them to do. Some people are so gullible blind and stupid that it makes you lose some faith in humanity when you see how easily manipulated they can be.

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#25
I don't think the ground workers at Amazon:

1. Care about tweeting about their company.

2. Talk like that.

However, I think this could be real if:

1. Amazon has some incentive program that basically allows workers to take on a "marketing assignment" for some sort of bonus. If so, how is this different than contriving good reviews about your restaurant on Yelp?

2. Amazon has developed or is paying for third party software that lets their PR people quickly manage and create activity on multiple Twitter accounts from a central interface.

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#26

I don't think the ground workers at Amazon: 1. Care about tweeting about their company. 2. Talk like that. However, I think this could be real if: 1. Amazon has some incentive program that basically allows workers to take on a "marketing assignment" for some sort of bonus. If so, how is this different than contriving good reviews about your restaurant on Yelp? 2. Amazon has developed or is paying for third party soft…

1. Care about tweeting about their company.

I feel the same way. I know a lot of warehouse associates are active on some of the Amazon Instagram pages, but that's mostly just silly pictures and activities. I don't think anyone would post such detailed responses on their own when they aren't being paid.

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#27
post #2

Well that's not creepy at all. Tweets read like they're written by a PR agency. Never known a near-minimum-wage warehouse worker who answers tweets with turns of phrase like "On the contrary..."

How could any professional in this day and age think that this could possibly work?

You should see the scale of similar manipulation efforts that exist on Reddit. Hundreds, sometimes thousands of accounts that completely overtake a sub to drive a certain viewpoint. Any decently intelligent person can see what’s going on but I’m afraid there is a large number of people who are non the wiser. I’ve seen this sort of social manipulation on a grand scale across numerous large online publications with yahoo news being the worst offender.

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#29
I'm fairly certain these are satire and not actually affiliated with Amazon at all.

Just the bio alone seems to give it away:

https://twitter.com/fc_ambassador/with_replies

Maybe only this one is satire? Hard to tell which level of galaxy brain this is.

Re: What is this Twitter army of Amazon drones cheerfully defending warehouse work?

#30

I don't think the ground workers at Amazon: 1. Care about tweeting about their company. 2. Talk like that. However, I think this could be real if: 1. Amazon has some incentive program that basically allows workers to take on a "marketing assignment" for some sort of bonus. If so, how is this different than contriving good reviews about your restaurant on Yelp? 2. Amazon has developed or is paying for third party soft…

>Amazon has some incentive program that basically allows workers to take on a "marketing assignment" for some sort of bonus.

I haven't heard of any such program, but if it existed, I guarantee Amazon wouldn't offer a bonus for it.

Post reply on HN