Live data from Hacker News

I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

bloomberg.com

31–40 of 67 posts

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#31

The narrative that it’s marketing or cult thinking that got Apple here always ignores this elephant in the room: what if consumers put a premium on their privacy? Privacy is itself valuable. Until SV can see this obvious, self-evident truth, the ad-driven models will rule and shrivel with a predictable boom-bust cadence.

I prefer most things Google, but stick with Apple for the privacy. I'll put up with lower quality services, buggy Apple TV, and an expensive phone that arguably not much better than a $200 cheaper Google alternative, just to know some creepy corporation isn't collecting mounds of data on me which will be used who knows how in the future.

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#32
"complex and expensive cashierless stores that won’t deliver much of an improvement to our shopping experience but may cost underprivileged people their jobs" Cashierless stores are simple and amazing. I won't even comment the part about "underprivileged people", this is straight up dumb.

This is a time when an entire driverless car industry is trying to convince the world that its products are safe before it can even come up with convincing stats - Nearly 1.3 million people die in road crashes each year, on average 3,287 deaths a day. An additional 20-50 million are injured or disabled. More than half of all road traffic deaths occur among young adults ages 15-44. THAT is not convincing enough? Autonomous cars are the future and will allow us to focus on other activities during the daily commute or long distance travels. Will decrease deaths, will optimize energy consumption by intelligently setting the right route and speed. Humans are inferior to computers on the road, that's a fact.

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#33
While I applaud Apple for some of their practices, I still hate their heavy handed approach toward hardware/software control:

- OSX must run on Apple-approved hardware

- iOS apps must come from the official app store

- iOS apps must be developed on an Apple-approved device

- Extremely difficult to repair your own devices

- etc.

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#34
post #11

I'm not sure if it's okay to call the entire Silicon Valley has gone rogue. Satya Nadella's Microsoft is still one company that's not part of these controversies and yet trying to innovate at the same time. What's disheartening is how Apple has become like IBM rather than Amazon. Probably, Always listening on Speaker that can steal couple's conversation wasn't their thing but they failed to capitalize on the love Sir…

Microsoft is no angel, it's just dwarfed by the egregiousness of Facebook, Google, and Amazon. It still does some sketchy data-collecting in Windows unless you opt-out (though it's backed off a bit since that came to light). Microsoft can afford to not fully partake in the skeeviness because a) it's not in the ad business, and b) it is in the enterprise business. Enterprise customers won't put up with that stuff, and they have the money to pay for that privilege. So when Microsoft makes most of their money that way, their business model isn't centered around the other stuff, and customers get partially spared from it by proximity.

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#35
My secret hope for Apple is that they buy an ISP / Telecom like Comcast.

It curdles my blood that ISPs are not only logging so-called advertising data, but are permissibly collecting and storing http requests, building full browser profiles etc, and of course are not being transparent with any of it.

Apple's message around privacy as a Human Right, along with the natural business model fit around content, wireless, telecom, etc gives me some hope that they could pull this off.

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#36

my mind is being blown that this is getting upvoted. this article can be summarized as "other companies are making dumb products, so good for apple for not doing that". what? what the what? is this vapid apple propaganda really worth the read? to me the salient trajectory of apple of the last 10 years has been the absolute decline of their software. people who upvoted this article- why? genuinely curious

[deleted]

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#37
post #3

If only we could praise the actual product (iPhone, Macbook Pro, Mac Pro, iMac, etc...) for being amazing an great and not something they dont do (collect user personal data and sell it). It's great Apple takes privacy seriously (as all companies should) it seems like lately Apple is using that all the cherry for the company versus turning out great innovative products that just work (like they used to). If they did…

As both a mobile developer and a consumer, I'll praise the iPhone over other smartphones all day long as an amazing and great product that just works.

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#38

my mind is being blown that this is getting upvoted. this article can be summarized as "other companies are making dumb products, so good for apple for not doing that". what? what the what? is this vapid apple propaganda really worth the read? to me the salient trajectory of apple of the last 10 years has been the absolute decline of their software. people who upvoted this article- why? genuinely curious

This article is a mea culpa. He spent the last however many years bashing Apple for not doing what everyone else does.

Now he finally sees there is value and merit to the way Apple has chosen to do things.

That’s more than ‘everybody sucks so go Apple!’

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#39
post #19

Replacing my 3 year old Moto G3 with a 3 year old 6S Plus was one of the best calls I've made in years. It's a weird feeling being current on an older phone, and knowing that it's got at least one more OS update coming. I know it's flagship vs. budget, but the way the Android phone began decaying before it even got here was still inexcusable. I'd never really used an Apple device before, so it was easy to knock them…

Two big reasons why I might switch from Android to Apple: - My Bluetooth audio has been broken for years. There's a discussion forum topic about this, but Google doesn't listen. - Starting the camera app takes about 3-5 seconds. In most cases, this is enough time to spoil the entire photo-moment. Edit: it's also the fact that Google allowed these problems to exist in the first place.

I take more photos now that I can just pick the thing up to a powered-on screen--I guess it uses some gyroscope and accelerometer magic--and swipe from the right.

Re: I’m Sorry I Criticized You, Apple. You Win

#40

Replacing my 3 year old Moto G3 with a 3 year old 6S Plus was one of the best calls I've made in years. It's a weird feeling being current on an older phone, and knowing that it's got at least one more OS update coming. I know it's flagship vs. budget, but the way the Android phone began decaying before it even got here was still inexcusable. I'd never really used an Apple device before, so it was easy to knock them…

Plus, iOS 12 is going to significantly improve performance on all devices as far back as the iPhone 5S.

When was the last time a major Android update made five-year-old devices faster?

https://www.apple.com/ios/ios-12-preview/features/

Post reply on HN