Live data from Hacker News

Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

indiewire.com

161–170 of 180 posts

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I can only watch shows they recommend though! You get stuck in a local maxima with no way to escape. God help you if you watch a WWII documentary. I so rarely find a title I search for that I don't bother with that anymore.

Sometimes I search for a genre, minor actor, or just a random word. I almost always find something I'd like to watch.

Really? Because today, August 19th 2018, I search for Sci-Fi films and get like 20 totals results. Moon is not even in the Sci-Fi Genres for f*s sake. None of the greaty Sci-Fi indie films I used to get recommended to me 4 years ago even show up in a Sci-Fi search. Netflix has truly succumbed to their hiring/firing practices IMHO.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For me personally, if I lose half an hour, I lose as much money as I get for half an hour of work. That's why I love content recommendation systems which actually work. Though the downside is, that today's systems (looking at you, Spotify) close you in kind of a bubble. The best I've met was Google play music, the recommendations were great and at the same time you got to know a lot of great content unlike anything y…

I keep seeing people equate every hour they spend on X as the same amount of opportunity cost of they were working. Do you measure how much time you sleep, spend with your family, eating etc. in the same way? I work 40-45 hours a week. Even when I am doing contract work, I limit the time I’m working. I don’t equate the 8 hours I spend working out to lost wages either.

Nah, this way I count 1. Wasted hours 2. How much my vacation is actually worth.

This seems like it would make you a workaholic / crazy, but in fact at least for me, it makes me value the time more and make a bigger effort to spend it well.

It also makes it easy to decide if buying something that's meant to save me time is worth it, cause it's a simple "time saved" vs cost calculation.

Time spent sleeping is special, because I know how bad I function and unhappy I am if I sleep too short for an extended period of time and it actually equates to days wasted.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Declining use" is a result of Netflix's own decisions to downplay reviews because they were helping people decide not to watch movies they wouldn't like.

Why should Netflix care if you watch or don’t watch a given movie? What they should care about is whether you stay a subscriber or not. If they try to push too much garbage, and not provide good tools to filter out the crappy content, they’re just wasting people’s time. Users will get frustrated and leave. I did!

You'd think, but the people running Netflix are human. They do not always put business success first. There have been a number of highly political things produced by Netflix that were heavily promoted. People slammed them hard in the reviews and comments.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Kind of. I run Streama https://github.com/streamaserver/streama Combined with ripped dvds and/or pirate bay, can make for a refreshing video streaming service you own and host.

Chinese here. How do you guys reconcile your own torrenting, usage of sci-hub etc with the tendency to portray us as monsters for "theft of American intellectual property"? I'm granting that we did (and on a large enough scale) for the sake of argument. Is the idea that it's okay to steal so long as it's stealing from the rich and powerful (netflix, disney, record labels whatever)? If so, do you see how that argument…

I don't think normal Americans would portray you as monsters for this. Of course, the MPAA and RIAA would complain, since it is their business.

There are other types of intellectual property that are much more likely to upset normal Americans. This includes trade secrets, trademarks, and possibly patents. Trade secrets are stolen by hacking, by forcing American companies to give them up in exchange for market access, and by employees who fail to abide by non-disclosure agreements. Trademarks are stolen by simply making clones, or sometimes by unauthorized operation of a legitimate factory in China. For example, I have a USB power adapter marked "SAMSUNG" that clearly isn't made by Samsung. This is very common, and these devices often catch fire or damage the electronics that are attached. Patents can sometimes be an issue, with Chinese companies able to evade enforcement.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#165
post #121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Why do they go through so much effort to have me binge watch Netflix. "Focus Area #1: Engagement Engagement is, hands down, the #1 area that you should be concerned with on social media. It is the catalyst for improvement in all of the other social media KPIs we'll discuss." https://www.impactbnd.com/blog/social-media-kpis This is just an example. Everybody wants to become Facebook for some reason.

That doesn’t make any sense, getting rid of user reviews makes Netflix streaming less social. Netflix is not social media. Trying to have people watch just enough to keep subscribing is too hard a needle to thread, it’s easier to encourage as much streaming as possible so people feel like they’re getting something for their money. I’m sure bandwidth is a minor cost compared to licensing and producing content.

Seems to me that licensing and production cost should also go down withe less watching.

It shouldn’t be that hard though. Just keep a reasonably diverse catalog and give people tools to browse it.

Speaking of diverse, now a days I turn to YouTube when I want to watch something interesting. I wonder how much of that type of content they could add to their catalog.

Not specifically the random user generated content, way to much hassle, or “be amazed” crap, they have plenty of that already, but there are a lot high quality channels targeting some niche on the long tail.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why take someone's word for what they like or don't like when you know what they actually watch?

How do you know a user liked a movie or TV show after watching it? I think a movie has to be really really bad for people to actually stop halfway through. For TV shows it might be more likely that people drop out after a couple episodes but if it's just "meh" or the show's finale was disappointing, how do your algorithms know?

When I find a TV show "meh", I usually jump from episode 3-4 to season finale to get closure. I wonder if others do this.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I keep seeing people equate every hour they spend on X as the same amount of opportunity cost of they were working. Do you measure how much time you sleep, spend with your family, eating etc. in the same way? I work 40-45 hours a week. Even when I am doing contract work, I limit the time I’m working. I don’t equate the 8 hours I spend working out to lost wages either.

Nah, this way I count 1. Wasted hours 2. How much my vacation is actually worth. This seems like it would make you a workaholic / crazy, but in fact at least for me, it makes me value the time more and make a bigger effort to spend it well. It also makes it easy to decide if buying something that's meant to save me time is worth it, cause it's a simple "time saved" vs cost calculation. Time spent sleeping is special,…

It’s not that complicated for me. There are certain things I just don’t want to do and gladly pay money to have someone else do the work.

I don’t like doing yard work and I will happily pay the going rate for someone else to do it. I don’t like going to the gym or working out outside - By the time it is all said and done, I’ll spend way more than the accumulated hours I’m saving by not driving to and from the local gym.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That doesn’t make any sense, getting rid of user reviews makes Netflix streaming less social. Netflix is not social media. Trying to have people watch just enough to keep subscribing is too hard a needle to thread, it’s easier to encourage as much streaming as possible so people feel like they’re getting something for their money. I’m sure bandwidth is a minor cost compared to licensing and producing content.

Seems to me that licensing and production cost should also go down withe less watching. It shouldn’t be that hard though. Just keep a reasonably diverse catalog and give people tools to browse it. Speaking of diverse, now a days I turn to YouTube when I want to watch something interesting. I wonder how much of that type of content they could add to their catalog. Not specifically the random user generated content, wa…

What specifically do you watch on YouTube that’s comparable to the movies and scripted series on Netflix? I know YouTube Red has shows like ‘Cobra Kai’ but you seem to be referring to regular YouTube.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#169
post #121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Why do they go through so much effort to have me binge watch Netflix. "Focus Area #1: Engagement Engagement is, hands down, the #1 area that you should be concerned with on social media. It is the catalyst for improvement in all of the other social media KPIs we'll discuss." https://www.impactbnd.com/blog/social-media-kpis This is just an example. Everybody wants to become Facebook for some reason.

That doesn’t make any sense, getting rid of user reviews makes Netflix streaming less social. Netflix is not social media. Trying to have people watch just enough to keep subscribing is too hard a needle to thread, it’s easier to encourage as much streaming as possible so people feel like they’re getting something for their money. I’m sure bandwidth is a minor cost compared to licensing and producing content.

> That doesn’t make any sense, getting rid of user reviews makes Netflix streaming less social. Netflix is not social media.

Yes. You are right. If they are just looking for more engagement removing the reviews will go against that policy.

Re: Netflix Has Deleted Every User Review Ever Posted to Its Website

#170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Kind of. I run Streama https://github.com/streamaserver/streama Combined with ripped dvds and/or pirate bay, can make for a refreshing video streaming service you own and host.

Chinese here. How do you guys reconcile your own torrenting, usage of sci-hub etc with the tendency to portray us as monsters for "theft of American intellectual property"? I'm granting that we did (and on a large enough scale) for the sake of argument. Is the idea that it's okay to steal so long as it's stealing from the rich and powerful (netflix, disney, record labels whatever)? If so, do you see how that argument…

I think of it like this...

When USA was new, we were a bastion of creativity. We didn't acknowledge the Old Country's laws on intellectual property, and we were the better for it. Things were crazy; you did stuff and you didn't let someone else that the thing in your head had ownership by someone else. There was a long period in which our goods were beneath European quality.

Not much time passes, and new and unique things were made here. The regime for patent/copyright protection got just as authoritarian and wicked in protecting 'stuff'. Hollywood was one such case - in which the devices to make movies was patented and the company that made them wanted their cut. The escape to California was to avoid those fees.

Again, China's been playing the same long game. "Rip off others' IP, allow extreme growth by being very liberal with copyright/patent, and eventually playing very protectionist once the economy is stable and advanced". This isn't anything unique with China, or the US, or anyone else.

> How do you guys reconcile your own torrenting,

Because once a country hits the protectionist point, they usually go way overboard and stifle all sorts of things. It pisses people off - is it really piracy if you buy a blu-ray and download it? Is it really piracy if you download a turd film and delete it? There's a lot of edge cases that are called piracy which in reality aren't. It's just called that cause Disney et al have lobbied to call it that.

Also, as I have gotten more money, I have been more willing to pay for media. When I was poorer, I was spending perhaps $10 for a ticket per every 6 months to a movie.

> usage of sci-hub etc

Sci-hup and "academic piracy" is a whole different ballgame. Predatory firms have put paywalls in place that alienate the creators of the papers, the reviewers of the papers, and the academics who use the papers, for $37 a paper. These predatory firms add nothing, and deserve to die. But again, this is completely different than movie/tv/music media.

> with the tendency to portray us as monsters

Humans have a bad tendency to 'otherize' people. See, you're Chinese, and not in my peer group, so my decisions have little effect on you. I can also have a poor opinion of you (having not even know you!) and people in my peer group don't care too much.

And it happens the other way around. Americans (USA) are horrible aggressors and evil empire and bad. Lots of places agree with that. But they don't know me, my friends, or my social groups. And in the end, other people 'otherize' the US, knowing what happens in DC isn't what we're like where we live.

It's best to think of this as "out of sight, out of mind, out of emotion". Because it is all too easy to consider someone else on a different point on this planet as "monsters". Eventually, we'll change that; although I think the internet like here is doing the ground work.

Post reply on HN