Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

abyjames.com

21–30 of 128 posts

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#21
Love this, cheers!

For some reason, the design of this is very sweetly nostalgic to me--reminds me of the web from 10y ago (in a good way!).

Web fonts and accessibility concerns with small font size have made good ol 13px Helvetica with blue links on white bg rare.

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#22
post #21

Love this, cheers! For some reason, the design of this is very sweetly nostalgic to me--reminds me of the web from 10y ago (in a good way!). Web fonts and accessibility concerns with small font size have made good ol 13px Helvetica with blue links on white bg rare.

The design is deliberate. I love the old web too : )

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#24

I truly hope it works out well for you. My personal response: * I don't know what is meant by "good" people; I'd choose a different term. * My impression is recommendations from "famous" people, which don't interest me personally. Famous people aren't necessarily smart and unless a topic is in their specific domain, they have no more to contribute that the average person. (Personally, I find the idolization of famous…

All valid points which I too am pondering on but don't have clear answers.

I checked your profile but couldn't find an email to contact you. I'd love to discuss details once I have written down my thoughts.

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#25

Love this idea. I've thought about doing something similar, but as a graph, so we could see books that many people have recommended in common.

I'm working on it. Would love to get feedback once I build the feature. I checked your profile but couldn't find an email to contact you.

Awesome, thanks! dave@davebryand.com

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#26

This is a great start! How do you account for duplicates? i.e. Seveneves The idea (posted elsewhere in this forum) of linking them to smile.amazon.com might be a great suggestion.

That is a feature (in my book). Search for The Mythical Man-Month tells me that the book is recommended by Marc Benioff, Joel Spolsky and Jeff Atwood. That is valuable information for me and tells me that I should read the book as soon as possible : )

I agree on smile.amazon.com.

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#27
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I appreciate the tip and I did consider it, but chose not to.

I tried this for http://wanderkind.org/ and IMO it ended up being more than helpful. Affiliation only seems worth it if you have a lot of traffic. Even then, maybe not--unless you're making serious money, I'd rather build genuine trust.

This is a passion project for me so making money is not the priority.

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm working on it. Would love to get feedback once I build the feature. I checked your profile but couldn't find an email to contact you.

Awesome, thanks! dave@davebryand.com

Email saved. Thanks.

Hack: You can search for a book (The Mythical Man-Month) and see who all recommended it.

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#29

This is a great start! How do you account for duplicates? i.e. Seveneves The idea (posted elsewhere in this forum) of linking them to smile.amazon.com might be a great suggestion.

That is a feature (in my book). Search for The Mythical Man-Month tells me that the book is recommended by Marc Benioff, Joel Spolsky and Jeff Atwood. That is valuable information for me and tells me that I should read the book as soon as possible : ) I agree on smile.amazon.com.

> That is a feature

Agreed

Re: Show HN: Find recommendations from good people

#30
I always find that recommendation websites suffer in the long-term because the incentive to just keep adding more stuff (to keep the site not seem stagnant, thus make people come back) is greater than the incentive to strictly filter only super high quality things. How is this site going to tackle that problem?
Post reply on HN