Live data from Hacker News

Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

help.twitter.com

31–40 of 119 posts

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#31
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I haven't tried to, but I think you'll need a software that can interpret js to interact with FB. Like webdriver, or headless chrome.

You could use https://mbasic.facebook.com/ which doesn't use any JavaScript (there is actually no script tags in the page source).

I wonder how soon they'll try to plug that hole with something like requiring 2FA for each login.

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#33

I may be swimming in the opposite direction, but I like to see that go. I left Twitter (well, abandoned my account) years ago, tired of the excessive noise and progressive loss of relevance to me. Seeing tweets on the FB feed always makes the author seem lazy and desperate to have a presence in every social media site, just because. I know that the change won't stop all of that but will certainly reduce it. FB isn't…

I mostly agree. I use different social media for mostly different purposes and I'm not a huge fan of indiscriminately spewing every thought and post across every connected network. I cross-post some things when I think it makes sense to do so but it's a small percentage of the total.

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#34

I'm surprised at the almost universal outrage over this. I assumed this was in response to the whole election interference campaign and related issues, i.e. preventing bots from blasting out content and predetermined times or in response to specific keywords in the news, things like that. So this seems like a step in the direction of ensuring actual humans are doing these things (or at least make it slightly more dif…

It's more likely a move to try to keep people within the walled garden of facebook - people can't easily move to competitors (like blogs, other social media), if those competitors can't share to facebook too automatically to ease the transition.

It also means they can more easily charge companies for posting (who are the ones most likely to want to post to several services).

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#35

I'm surprised at the almost universal outrage over this. I assumed this was in response to the whole election interference campaign and related issues, i.e. preventing bots from blasting out content and predetermined times or in response to specific keywords in the news, things like that. So this seems like a step in the direction of ensuring actual humans are doing these things (or at least make it slightly more dif…

I'm surprised at the outrage too. Your personal profile on Facebook is supposed to be a place to post your holiday photos, pictures of your kids, updates about events in your life etc, not mindless automated stuff like this. Part of the reason Instagram has surged in popularity lately is because it's generally real humans posting the content rather than endless automated shitposts (I'm not saying they don't exist, but it's certainly more difficult to implement than it is on Facebook).

You'd think the posters in this thread have some kind of business interest in this functionality based on the way they're reacting.

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#36
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apparently it's part of further locking down their API ( https://techcrunch.com/2018/08/01/psa-cross-posting-tweets-t... ) so that random apps that have been given permission to post by default can no longer do so. The way I read it, people who deliberately want to cross-post tweets are essentially collateral damage.

Why couldn't they blanket-deauth all Facebook apps (or maybe just ones authed before this year, or sth.) instead? People would fix the apps they still use. And really, publishing apps on FB is not a real problem; apps exfiltrating data is.

Apps exfiltrating is one problem. Bots posing as real people to rile up racial/political/etc. tensions is another, and this approach helps a bit there.

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good! This means more open distribution methods (email) will be given priority again. I don't want Facebook, nor Twitter. Just take my email address and send me your content, or offer an RSS feed. EDIT: Anyone know if this kills Buffer and other social feed managers?

Good - if you don't like/use Facebook. For people who like/use it (and there are many), this is a very sad day.

What the walled garden giveth, it taketh away. Build on someone's platform? Depend on it exclusively? Gonna have a bad time. You would think folks would learn by now.

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#38

I'm surprised at the almost universal outrage over this. I assumed this was in response to the whole election interference campaign and related issues, i.e. preventing bots from blasting out content and predetermined times or in response to specific keywords in the news, things like that. So this seems like a step in the direction of ensuring actual humans are doing these things (or at least make it slightly more dif…

I don't really get the hate, either - but then again, I was one of the people who was generally annoyed by friends filling their profiles and feeds with all kinds of auto-shared stuff from every other service... I like to imagine everybody would curate a little bit more on their own. Important stuff will still get shared, and if it isn't worth sharing if you have to do it manually instead of using an app or checkbox to "always share to Facebook", well, maybe it wasn't worth sharing to the world in the first place.

(I think in reality, my view of Facebook as a tool for messaging and looking at photos is probably fundamentally different than a lot of the upset people posting here who seemed to use Facebook for promoting their blogs or personal twitter brand or whatever)

Re: Facebook has ended the ability to automatically post Tweets to profiles or pages

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good! This means more open distribution methods (email) will be given priority again. I don't want Facebook, nor Twitter. Just take my email address and send me your content, or offer an RSS feed. EDIT: Anyone know if this kills Buffer and other social feed managers?

Good - if you don't like/use Facebook. For people who like/use it (and there are many), this is a very sad day.

Presumably people wanting to post links to their personal blog can still open up Facebook in a new tab and Ctrl-V the link in themselves, which will take them all of about 10 seconds. Seems a small price to pay if it cuts down the ridiculous amount of botspam on the platform.
Post reply on HN