Live data from Hacker News

4D toys

4dtoys.com

101–110 of 112 posts

Re: 4D toys

#101
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you play with only one eye open, or just one contact lens? I have worse vision than you (-8.0, -7.50), and I know that I can still function with just one lens in of needed. You definitely still have stereo vision even if one input is blurred. Your brain does quite a bit of compensation, and I can imagine if you operated this way for months that your brain would be even better at assimilating the noisy information…

Sulam is basically correct. I was born with strabismus (my eyes don't focus on the same point). To avoid perpetual double vision, my brain compensates by basically only using one eye at a time. It switches automatically when I'm looking to the side, and I can also switch consciously. (My color perception is very slightly different in each eye, it's weird.) It turns out that stereovision is the least important of seve…

> (My color perception is very slightly different in each eye, it's weird.)

I have comparatively uninteresting/normal vision (biggest issue shortsightedness) but I have this too. My left eye sees more blue, my right eye more red. Looks like the cone distribution wasn't perfect.

I'm not sure, but I think the sun's rays don't have much of a blue component: my left eye gets fractionally less sore from bright sunlight, so if it's really bright out I'll generally be closing my right eye.

Re: 4D toys

#102
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For your question about 3D being hard coded or learned, I think I remember reading that it’s learned. This is an old philosophy debate about wheather if I blind person could suddenly see if they’d understand that a sphere is round just by looking at it. When some people that had had cataracts for 50 years were treated they not only couldn’t tell that a sphere was round, they couldn’t understand shadows or depth of fi…

The article describing blind people getting vision again: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.newyorker.com/tech/elements...

Yeah this is the one I was thinking about! Thanks for finding/linking.

Re: 4D toys

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Could we teach our brain to "think in 4D" and interpret these cues differently? To a certain extent probably, maybe if you spent hours and hours and hours in a VR simulation with 4D objects you'd starting getting a feel for it. I doubt you'd ever get as good as with 3D objects since we've been exposed to these literally every waking moment since we're born.* Good lord! Has anyone tried? This reminds me of the backw…

In the YouTube video he says: "So here's why I did. It was a personal challenge. I stayed out here in this driveway and I practiced about 5 minutes every day. ... after 8 month it happened ... in two weeks he (the son) did something that took me 8 months to do". Well, if you were serious about learning a skill you wouldn't just do one 5 minute session per day for eight months. A more appropriate training regime would…

> As an aside, he says his son is the closest person to him genetically, but aren't his parents both equally as close to him genetically as his son?

And any siblings.

Re: 4D toys

#104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sulam is basically correct. I was born with strabismus (my eyes don't focus on the same point). To avoid perpetual double vision, my brain compensates by basically only using one eye at a time. It switches automatically when I'm looking to the side, and I can also switch consciously. (My color perception is very slightly different in each eye, it's weird.) It turns out that stereovision is the least important of seve…

> (My color perception is very slightly different in each eye, it's weird.) I have comparatively uninteresting/normal vision (biggest issue shortsightedness) but I have this too. My left eye sees more blue, my right eye more red. Looks like the cone distribution wasn't perfect. I'm not sure, but I think the sun's rays don't have much of a blue component: my left eye gets fractionally less sore from bright sunlight, s…

The sun emits black body radiation with a 5800K temperature, which means its emissions peaks at yellow-greenish, but it still emits around 90% of blue compared to green

Re: 4D toys

#105
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sad thing is that what we sense (see) is in fact just a poor projection into 2D (aka perspective) with some largely learnt concept of depth. If only we could sense space entirely with nothing "behind", not just from single point...

i think it's great that you represent it as a projection because that is exactly what it is: a representation of another, perhaps more "objective" (though I'm not sure at that level that attributes like that apply) data set. I think it's super easy for us to assume what we visually perceive has a 1:1 correspondence with the intrinsic nature of the data it is constructed from. and i think it's also important to realiz…

Perhaps it is determined by the fact senses are bound to body and body is limitary. Our 2d vision could grasp entire Flatland (if it fitted into single view), but sight of similarly finite Flatland inhabitant could grasp just his immediate surroundings, i.e. the sum of closest opaque objects in his 1D sight.

Re: 4D toys

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Could we teach our brain to "think in 4D" and interpret these cues differently? To a certain extent probably, maybe if you spent hours and hours and hours in a VR simulation with 4D objects you'd starting getting a feel for it. I doubt you'd ever get as good as with 3D objects since we've been exposed to these literally every waking moment since we're born.* Good lord! Has anyone tried? This reminds me of the backw…

In the YouTube video he says: "So here's why I did. It was a personal challenge. I stayed out here in this driveway and I practiced about 5 minutes every day. ... after 8 month it happened ... in two weeks he (the son) did something that took me 8 months to do". Well, if you were serious about learning a skill you wouldn't just do one 5 minute session per day for eight months. A more appropriate training regime would…

Yeap, https://youtu.be/oI2aMKwXXnE this guy took a more serious attempt at learning to ride the backwards and it seems it didn't take him that much time.

Re: 4D toys

#107

Here's a thought I had watching the bit with 2D man: Actually, the 3D view that 2D man does not understand but which we do understand is... still 2D. My screen is flat. You can use a 2D viewport to render a 3D scene in a way that is natural and easy to understand for us humans: A human watching the 2D scene can very quickly surmise from a glance at the viewport: Which objects are in the scene, and where are they loca…

Has anybody tried any of the 4d maze games?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_four-dimensional_gam...

I've tried a maze game and a 4D space shooter before and I could never wrap my head around them. I don't know if it was just poor representations or if it was just because my brain is incapable of understanding.

Re: 4D toys

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the YouTube video he says: "So here's why I did. It was a personal challenge. I stayed out here in this driveway and I practiced about 5 minutes every day. ... after 8 month it happened ... in two weeks he (the son) did something that took me 8 months to do". Well, if you were serious about learning a skill you wouldn't just do one 5 minute session per day for eight months. A more appropriate training regime would…

Yeap, https://youtu.be/oI2aMKwXXnE this guy took a more serious attempt at learning to ride the backwards and it seems it didn't take him that much time.

Thanks for finding that.

So it only took him about an hour, over three days, to get it worked out well enough to not immediately fall off, and an hour and a half over four days to get to 50 meters.

There's a comment in on the YT video from Destin saying "the RC helicopter pilot was able to learn it in about an hour but I don't think his brain is normal" - good point, the RC helicopter pilot has more experience understanding reversed input while the helicopter is flying toward him, also he had the opportunity to watch Mike learn first.

I reckon the learning process could be sped up even more by taking the pedals of, turning it in to a balance bike, learning how to ride it down slight inclines, get that sorted then putting the pedals back on.

Re: 4D toys

#109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> (My color perception is very slightly different in each eye, it's weird.) I have comparatively uninteresting/normal vision (biggest issue shortsightedness) but I have this too. My left eye sees more blue, my right eye more red. Looks like the cone distribution wasn't perfect. I'm not sure, but I think the sun's rays don't have much of a blue component: my left eye gets fractionally less sore from bright sunlight, s…

The sun emits black body radiation with a 5800K temperature, which means its emissions peaks at yellow-greenish, but it still emits around 90% of blue compared to green

How about compared to red? That might suggest whether exikyut's experience (red-seeing eye more light-sensitive than blue-seeing eye) is coincidence or related.

Re: 4D toys

#110

How curious. What would a haptic VR experience be like? Does a 4D object still exert mass in the other 3Ds? Could you _intuit_ the other 3Ds even if they were not visible?

The VR version has haptics. It's kinda interesting. I think there is a little bit of intuition to be gained.
Post reply on HN