Live data from Hacker News

Farewell for Now

seekingalpha.com

11–20 of 29 posts

Re: Farewell for Now

#11

Its really a shame this has been flagged off of the front page, seems kind of important that Musk is personally calling bloggers employers to threaten them with litigation.

Allegedly. I personally find the story somewhat unconvincing, but there may be some precedence here that gives the account more credence.

Re: Farewell for Now

#12
Wow. So only positive hype about a company can be published.

What's next? Suing shareholders who sell stocks instead of buying them?

Re: Farewell for Now

#13
Earlier, I use to admire Elon and companies like Google, FB, etc. But as I learn more and as their behaviors are being exposed, I feel they are modern villains of society. Elon particularly has been very disappointing. Anyone willing to buy a pre-owned Tesla?

Re: Farewell for Now

#14
post #3

Looks interesting, wish i could read it on mobile without registering.

In summary: * Author wrote a number of articles analyzing Tesla from a financial perspective. Some of them critical of Tesla. * Elon Musk contacted author's employer, threatening to sue if author continued to write. * Author announces in response to this threat he will no longer write. Not just "no longer write about Tesla", no longer write, period. * Author indicates this is in some ways a relief, as he has had poor…

Noted elsewhere: [0]

* Author is director at company heavily invested in oil industry

* Author has published false stories regarding Tesla.

* Author has incited social media attacks on Tesla advocates, bulls, and fans.

Basically, the author was using pseudonymity and relative anonymity to manipulate the market in which he and his employer are heavily invested.

I am not a lawyer. Given his company's position and his own personal position, what he was doing is at least unethical and may even be illegal, exposing him and possibly his employer to liability once his employer became aware of his editorial moonlighting.

[0] https://electrek.co/2018/07/24/tesla-troll-short-doxxed-oil-...

EDIT: formatting

Re: Farewell for Now

#15

Its really a shame this has been flagged off of the front page, seems kind of important that Musk is personally calling bloggers employers to threaten them with litigation.

How can we substantiate this claim that Elon indeed called? I am very skeptical. There seems to be more and more fake news and flat out lying propagated on what used to be well respected forums.

Re: Farewell for Now

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In summary: * Author wrote a number of articles analyzing Tesla from a financial perspective. Some of them critical of Tesla. * Elon Musk contacted author's employer, threatening to sue if author continued to write. * Author announces in response to this threat he will no longer write. Not just "no longer write about Tesla", no longer write, period. * Author indicates this is in some ways a relief, as he has had poor…

Noted elsewhere: [0] * Author is director at company heavily invested in oil industry * Author has published false stories regarding Tesla. * Author has incited social media attacks on Tesla advocates, bulls, and fans. Basically, the author was using pseudonymity and relative anonymity to manipulate the market in which he and his employer are heavily invested. I am not a lawyer. Given his company's position and his o…

electrek is a tesla propaganda site. they literally posted montana skeptic’s identity in their article. since when is that acceptable behavior?

Montana skeptic wasn’t a troll, he wrote extremely insightful articles. I’m actually shocked how many people are trashing the dude

Re: Farewell for Now

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In summary: * Author wrote a number of articles analyzing Tesla from a financial perspective. Some of them critical of Tesla. * Elon Musk contacted author's employer, threatening to sue if author continued to write. * Author announces in response to this threat he will no longer write. Not just "no longer write about Tesla", no longer write, period. * Author indicates this is in some ways a relief, as he has had poor…

Noted elsewhere: [0] * Author is director at company heavily invested in oil industry * Author has published false stories regarding Tesla. * Author has incited social media attacks on Tesla advocates, bulls, and fans. Basically, the author was using pseudonymity and relative anonymity to manipulate the market in which he and his employer are heavily invested. I am not a lawyer. Given his company's position and his o…

Whether you like what he says or not, he's got freedom of speech and shouldn't be bullied into silence.

I think the standard response here is "the cure for bad speech is more speech", yes?

Re: Farewell for Now

#18
post #11

Its really a shame this has been flagged off of the front page, seems kind of important that Musk is personally calling bloggers employers to threaten them with litigation.

Allegedly. I personally find the story somewhat unconvincing, but there may be some precedence here that gives the account more credence.

Musk does seem to be exhibiting increasingly insecure, threatening, and chaotic behavior (e.g. Thailand).

Admittedly I know nothing about the conduct or credibility of the blogger, but to me, “a guy on the Internet” is more credible than EM at the moment.

Re: Farewell for Now

#19

This is good news. I despise having my SA feed filled to the brim with TSLA because of folks with an agenda like this guy. A sample of his latest headlines: - Why are all these Tesla cars baking in the sun? - I believe Musk is bluffing about Q3 profits - Munro's teardown spells big trouble - 'Hey, maybe the government will bail out Tesla' - I don't believe tesla's delivery report A lot of drivel (and maybe libel?), m…

This looks like clickbait crap you’d expect on a badly curated site. It’s a site about stock price speculation. I could imagine them as headlines on The Motley Fool for example.

What if EM threatened to ruin you for reading them?

Re: Farewell for Now

#20

This is good news. I despise having my SA feed filled to the brim with TSLA because of folks with an agenda like this guy. A sample of his latest headlines: - Why are all these Tesla cars baking in the sun? - I believe Musk is bluffing about Q3 profits - Munro's teardown spells big trouble - 'Hey, maybe the government will bail out Tesla' - I don't believe tesla's delivery report A lot of drivel (and maybe libel?), m…

It’s good news that because you don’t like what this guy has to say, Musk threatened him through his employer to shut him up? Jesus.

If he doesn’t believe Tesla’s official financial reports, I think it’s fair for me to not believe this episode - there is no evidence of this profile being a person.

I’m just glad to have less noise regardless, don’t have enough invested in TSLA to really care.

Post reply on HN