Live data from Hacker News

A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

neh.gov

11–20 of 35 posts

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#11
post #4

Cavendish is a veritable metropolis compared to some of the villages in that area (Amsden, Downers Corner, Ascutney). If you're ever in the area, be sure to check out the Brewfest Brewing Corp. in Ludlow for an incredible selection of local VT beer.

Should also check out Singleton's in Proctorsville. Guns, booze, Carhartts, smoked meat ... it's a classic.

Stemwinder & Homestyle Hostel are good dinner/drinks spots in Ludlow.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#12
post #4

Cavendish is a veritable metropolis compared to some of the villages in that area (Amsden, Downers Corner, Ascutney). If you're ever in the area, be sure to check out the Brewfest Brewing Corp. in Ludlow for an incredible selection of local VT beer.

It's weird that whenever talking about a remote place with nothing to do, people always recommend a brewery as the highlight.

Why do you hate beer?

;)

Breweries are God's/Cosmos' gift to us mortal, fallible, sinful men.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#13
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In fact, Solzhenitsyn's views can be described as Chernosotenstvo (Black Hundred) - a form of ultra-nationalism and xenophobia similar to that practiced by members of KKK. I never understood his appeal to people who thought of themselves as liberals and humanists.

The way I understand it, is that the Cold War was actually a War, although we forget about it, but the propaganda arms of the governments did not allow anyone to be a human being, you must be either a heroic figure or a villain. Maybe it is human nature to idealize, and in conflict to hyper-idealize. The thing we also don't hear about, is his book "Two hundred years together", which IIRC was never even translated bec…

Minor correction - "Two Hundred Years Together" was never (edit: officially) translated into English; but was translated into French and German at the least.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The way I understand it, is that the Cold War was actually a War, although we forget about it, but the propaganda arms of the governments did not allow anyone to be a human being, you must be either a heroic figure or a villain. Maybe it is human nature to idealize, and in conflict to hyper-idealize. The thing we also don't hear about, is his book "Two hundred years together", which IIRC was never even translated bec…

Minor correction - "Two Hundred Years Together" was never (edit: officially) translated into English; but was translated into French and German at the least.

I have come across a PDF that purports to be an English translation though I haven't had the time to read it yet. Nor is my Russian or French good enough to determine if it's legitimate, however it seems to be.

There is no attribution on the translation, either.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#16

I am sure I was not the only person here who chuckled at the last bit from this article: > While there, he completed three volumes of The Red Wheel, and prepared his famous commencement address, given at Harvard in 1978. In it, he excoriated the West, and, in particular, America, for its godlessness, materialism, and weakness of spirit. One hopes that after his time in Cavendish, Solzhenitsyn would have changed that…

Thought experiment. Would S. be supportive of Russia and Putin in 2018?

I would say yes. Most Russians want to see Russia succeed. For historical reasons a strongman or strongwoman have been necessary to keep the country together.

Many/most Russians would make that bargain, those that would not, have left. Some of those who left would still have Russia ruled by a semi-dictator than see it fall apart at the hands of a caring but ineffective leader.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#17
post #4

Cavendish is a veritable metropolis compared to some of the villages in that area (Amsden, Downers Corner, Ascutney). If you're ever in the area, be sure to check out the Brewfest Brewing Corp. in Ludlow for an incredible selection of local VT beer.

It's weird that whenever talking about a remote place with nothing to do, people always recommend a brewery as the highlight.

Maybe it's because you can make it from mostly local ingredients and requires some skill to ensure it's made well. They also tend to exhibit an area's "soil characteristics imparted into flavor". It's more plebeian than snobbish wine so it exudes, in American vernacular, heartlandness.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#18
I find this article a reminder to me: there are people from Russia, China, ; who don't agree with all of the politics, policies, actions of their country's government (just like I don't agree with all of politics/policies/actions of my government).

Its a reminder to focus on individuals and ideas and how we treat them and avoid defaulting to guilt by ostensible association.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#19
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thought experiment. Would S. be supportive of Russia and Putin in 2018?

I would say yes. Most Russians want to see Russia succeed. For historical reasons a strongman or strongwoman have been necessary to keep the country together. Many/most Russians would make that bargain, those that would not, have left. Some of those who left would still have Russia ruled by a semi-dictator than see it fall apart at the hands of a caring but ineffective leader.

Of course the real alternative would be a strong government with rule of law where the personal proclivities of the guy in charge doesn't dictate the entire character of the state. It can be easier to survive a weak leader when you're not a one-person autocracy.

Re: A Tiny Village in Vermont Was the Perfect Spot to Hide Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn

#20
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thought experiment. Would S. be supportive of Russia and Putin in 2018?

I would say yes. Most Russians want to see Russia succeed. For historical reasons a strongman or strongwoman have been necessary to keep the country together. Many/most Russians would make that bargain, those that would not, have left. Some of those who left would still have Russia ruled by a semi-dictator than see it fall apart at the hands of a caring but ineffective leader.

>Many/most Russians would make that bargain

At the very least I think we can say that many HAVE made that bargain. They know.

Post reply on HN