Live data from Hacker News

L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

wsj.com

31–40 of 79 posts

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#31

Wait, the US finally comes up with some new cool mass-transit technology and we're not even building it here? Shame.

We are building a new, cool mass-transit system here, there's going to be a small-bore tunnel with electric skates between downtown Chicago and the airport.

Edit: clarified what "it" is.

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#32
post #5
post #2

Does anyone know why they are building it in a seemingly less populated/ prosperous province?

Since the capacity of a Hyperloop system is close to zero (less than 1000 passengers per hour, much less than a lane of highway and two orders of magnitude less than an ordinary railroad), it doesn't really matter where you put it.

[deleted]

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#33
post #4

Paywall work-around: https://t.co/jZyOpZbbtD

Completely serious question given the downvotes: Is this discouraged or banned on HN?

Whenever I hit a paywall from an HN link, I immediately go to the comments to see if somebody has linked to the full article. Thought I'd help folks out since nobody had done that for this article yet, but if I'm out of line I won't do it again.

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#34
post #13
post #3

Hacker News has assured me repeatedly that this is an imaginary technology that cannot possibly work, so I assume this must be fake news.

I think the criticism isn't that it couldn't possibly work, but rather that it was impractical and expensive. Basically, its the modern monorail.

"impractical and expensive" are invalid criticisms in the face of no other alternatives other than more cars and freeways.

The monorail at Disneyland works great and so does the one in Seattle.

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#35
post #6
post #2

Does anyone know why they are building it in a seemingly less populated/ prosperous province?

Looks like the eventual plan is to link the airport to a tourist spot and the city is just the first stop on the way through. Might also be cheaper/easier to do in a less populated area.

Are they tunneling? That area is really rocky and mountainous, unless it is going on a viaduct I don’t see how this will work out.

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#36
post #3

Hacker News has assured me repeatedly that this is an imaginary technology that cannot possibly work, so I assume this must be fake news.

No dude. It's super real. This partnership makes sense because the next step is a Hyper loop between China and Los Angeles. Very good ideas. Real science. You just move the 99% over INTO the 1%. Now we are all the 1%, or the 199%. I haven't done the maths.

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#37
post #33
post #4

Paywall work-around: https://t.co/jZyOpZbbtD

Completely serious question given the downvotes: Is this discouraged or banned on HN? Whenever I hit a paywall from an HN link, I immediately go to the comments to see if somebody has linked to the full article. Thought I'd help folks out since nobody had done that for this article yet, but if I'm out of line I won't do it again.

You might be being downvoted because your link doesn’t avoid the paywall.

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#38

Wait, the US finally comes up with some new cool mass-transit technology and we're not even building it here? Shame.

We can't build any public infrastructure in the US anymore. Too complicated between environmental regs, NIMBYism, and corruption.

We only got things done in the past when a Big Power From Above forced it into being so

Re: L.A. Company Wins China Hyperloop Deal

#40

Wait, the US finally comes up with some new cool mass-transit technology and we're not even building it here? Shame.

We are building a new, cool mass-transit system here, there's going to be a small-bore tunnel with electric skates between downtown Chicago and the airport. Edit: clarified what "it" is.

That is just a regular type tunnel built by the Boring Company and using electric vehicles in it. Not an evacuated tunnel with very fast vehicles. Spending extra for Hyperloop speeds really only make sense for longer distances. Not sure why this Chinese project is so short unless it is just a bigger type demo for the company and China hopes to acquire the technology like it has for so many other advanced systems invented in the west.
Post reply on HN