Live data from Hacker News

Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

huckmag.com

31–40 of 130 posts

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#31
post #25

Reading this with no clue what punk is. The article doesn't do a good job of explaining it or answering the question the title poses to someone not already part of it.

Old joke.

First kid asks, "What's punk?" Second kid kicks over a trash can, points at it, and says, "That's punk." First kid kicks over another trash can and asks, "Is that punk?" Second kid says, "No, that's trendy."

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#32
post #25

Reading this with no clue what punk is. The article doesn't do a good job of explaining it or answering the question the title poses to someone not already part of it.

Old joke. First kid asks, "What's punk?" Second kid kicks over a trash can, points at it, and says, "That's punk." First kid kicks over another trash can and asks, "Is that punk?" Second kid says, "No, that's trendy."

Another old joke: "What's punk? Punk's dead, man."

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#33
post #27
post #25

Reading this with no clue what punk is. The article doesn't do a good job of explaining it or answering the question the title poses to someone not already part of it.

Well, it has a lot of definitions. I still think of it as a reaction to overproduced rock and disco from the 70s, but it has evolved a lot since then. Surely someone has put together an introductory listening list that is searchable. No idea if there's a scene anywhere these days. I rather doubt it, but you never know.

Spotify has a couple of playlists that might help OP learn a bit more about the genre:

The Road to Punk Rock: https://open.spotify.com/user/spotify/playlist/37i9dQZF1DWU0...

Complete Chaos: https://open.spotify.com/user/spotify/playlist/37i9dQZF1DX1f...

Punk Unleashed: https://open.spotify.com/user/spotify/playlist/37i9dQZF1DXdJ...

Skatepark Punks: https://open.spotify.com/user/spotify/playlist/37i9dQZF1DX3M...

New Punk Tracks: https://open.spotify.com/user/spotify/playlist/37i9dQZF1DX0K...

These playlists are not really definitive of the genre but can at least give a broad range of styles, plus, they're fun to listen to.

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#34
post #25

Reading this with no clue what punk is. The article doesn't do a good job of explaining it or answering the question the title poses to someone not already part of it.

Old joke. First kid asks, "What's punk?" Second kid kicks over a trash can, points at it, and says, "That's punk." First kid kicks over another trash can and asks, "Is that punk?" Second kid says, "No, that's trendy."

So punk is vandalism?

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#35
post #21
post #19

Vans Warped tour is in its final year after 23 years. Crowds aren't what they used to be.

Vans warped tour hasn't had much to do with punk culture for like 15 years, unless you consider using it as a marketing tool as what punk really is. I saw anti-flag and face to face at a free show in Montreal this summer and punk rock certainly felt alive. The US has punk in drublic fest going on which is probably quite authentic considering it's thrown by fat wreck chords.

The last time I went to warped tour (2004 i think?) Anti-Flag played. Great show - being part of 5000 people chanting lyrics is very much like a religious experience. Such things are actually used to induce religious/trance states among many niche and ethnic religions (see Kecak/Sanghyang, which you may know from the movie Baraka).

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#36

Similarly, check out "Barred for Life" https://www.amazon.com/Barred-Life-Iconic-Became-Handshake/d... about the widely disparate groups of people who sport "The Bars" of Black Flag. (I've got mine next to The Zen Of Python on my arm)

The whole Zen of python? I'd like to see that!

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#37

Similarly, check out "Barred for Life" https://www.amazon.com/Barred-Life-Iconic-Became-Handshake/d... about the widely disparate groups of people who sport "The Bars" of Black Flag. (I've got mine next to The Zen Of Python on my arm)

Quite possibly the most abused punk logo in history. I've seen it used on everything from "Employee's Must Wash Hands" stickers to a t-shirt that read "Beach Boys"

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#38
post #25

Reading this with no clue what punk is. The article doesn't do a good job of explaining it or answering the question the title poses to someone not already part of it.

Back when I first got into the punk scene I ended up asking this semi-infamous old-timer at my local punk dive "Just what the hell is punk, anyway?"

"Something you don't want to be in prison."

Really, it's whatever the fuck you want it to be and fuck anyone who tells you otherwise because they're definitely wrong, and that includes me right now telling you this.

What is punk? Punk isn't.

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#39
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Old joke. First kid asks, "What's punk?" Second kid kicks over a trash can, points at it, and says, "That's punk." First kid kicks over another trash can and asks, "Is that punk?" Second kid says, "No, that's trendy."

Another old joke: "What's punk? Punk's dead, man."

I grew up with a bunch of crusty punks in the late 90s in the texas panhandle. Punk's not dead, it just smells that way.

Re: Why punk keeps connecting people across space and time

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ah , you have many a year on me good sir. Wise words though. i'm just starting on my journey, coming up to 5 years of professional dev work at 1 company. My wife and I definitely connected over our love of punk/alternative musics. There is definitely an 'energy' at these shows that is hard to describe. It is raw and hard to capture on CDs and tapes. backyard/house/underground shows are amazing. The passion, sweat, en…

> At most concerts here in the US the crowd is too busy taking a video of the show instead of getting into the music and moving Where are you going to shows? This seems pretty regional, and also tied to the size of the venue. The more DIY the space, the crazier the shows in my experience. NYC used to have some utterly insane shows at places like DBA (which unfortunately is no longer with us), and Oakland had some pre…

Is Gilman St. still a thing?

edit: aha: http://www.924gilman.org/

Post reply on HN