Live data from Hacker News

Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

twitter.com

41–50 of 83 posts

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#41
post #25

>ssl.cdn.turner.com Obviously bullshit. That's CNNs CDN, not a "banner ad". This guy did not put in the least bit of effort to verify his claims. The script is included in https://edition.cnn.com/.a/2.103.4/js/cnn-header-second.min....

It appears to be used to set up multi-key hotkeys for debugging. Pressing 'd o h' on the page requests some adfuel console resources.

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#42
post #13

Sites bemoan ad blockers but then take no responsibility for the ads that are shown. That needs to change - it’s not like print advertising.

Google's monopoly status means it fulfills 90+% of the ads. I can guarantee you that CNN has no control. There is no competition. So, erm, maybe the onus is on Google?

Do you have any proof that the ad was served by Google or are you just guessing? I was under the impression they had checks to prevent this.

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#43

I’ve noticed CNN has had a crap ton of redirect ads recently...

They come in waves and go away when ad exchanges figure out how to block them. It isn't usually tied to a single publisher, as they are bought and sold across ad exchanges that reach most of the ad funded web. They are extremely difficult for even manual reviewers to spot and reproduce, so the whole industry works to stop them together. Then new ones pop up.

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#45
post #12

Dearest Ad Industry, This is why we run ad blockers. Since you won't regulate your industry, we're fixing the problem for you. Love, The Rest of the World.

PS: and please burn in hell, asap. Sincerely, Concerned users of the Internet.

takers of the internet?

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#46
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google's monopoly status means it fulfills 90+% of the ads. I can guarantee you that CNN has no control. There is no competition. So, erm, maybe the onus is on Google?

Is this confirmed to be Google ads? Because otherwise the comment is needlessly misleading.

According to a comment below the JavaScript originated from CNN and was likely used for debugging.

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#47
post #13

Sites bemoan ad blockers but then take no responsibility for the ads that are shown. That needs to change - it’s not like print advertising.

Change or not, I think the trend is not to trust ads anymore. I question whether or not it’s feasible in the long term to sustain a model based on tracking people, selling their data, and calling that “advertising.” Oh and if you want to see what CNN is crapping out without the cruft, lite.cnn.io works well.

Surveillance is not advertising.

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google's monopoly status means it fulfills 90+% of the ads. I can guarantee you that CNN has no control. There is no competition. So, erm, maybe the onus is on Google?

Do you have any proof that the ad was served by Google or are you just guessing? I was under the impression they had checks to prevent this.

Tons of malvertising comes through Google. When one company owns the whole space, finding just one vulnerability is enormously economically attractive.

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#49
It's not CNN. It's ads.

Advertising has ruined every medium it has ever touched. It will ruin the web. It is only a matter of time. It did not destroy ancient network television overnight. It did not destroy cable tv overnight.

The last time I saw cable tv a few years back, it had become so bad that after a long run of ads, they would then put bugs and walk on people right over the content of the show you were watching. Sometimes obscuring important content within that show.

Re: Banner ads on CNN.com contain keyloggers

#50
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google's monopoly status means it fulfills 90+% of the ads. I can guarantee you that CNN has no control. There is no competition. So, erm, maybe the onus is on Google?

CNN absolutely has control. CNN could vote with their dollars and use a different ad platform.

Which other ad server and ad intermediation service would you recommend?
Post reply on HN