Live data from Hacker News

Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

quora.com

21–30 of 44 posts

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#21

Quora sure does take in a lot of data.

What’s this comment getting at? I don’t follow.

Quora compels users to hand over sensitive personal data, combines that with any other data it can, makes mental health diagnoses on its users, and generally offers creepy content.

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#22
post #3

Not covered in first answer: you could leave at 6, but if you stay till 7 there's a roast dinner. I suspect people who still work at Google are sometimes a little blind to their own behaviour.

Twitter had dinner at the SF office but they discontinued it after they realized that the amount of people that used it didn't justify the cost of operating the kitchen that late. They replaced it with a take-out option, prepared by the kitchen. I really like this since it still allows a useful perk but gives people the option of where/how the take advantage of it.

Edit: it's not free but highly subsidized.

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#23
post #20

I feel as I would hate to work there. They are creating all these things to make it a 2nd home for people. They want people to be there a LONG time. I'm happy with 40hrs with some days remote and I don't think I could switch to googles approach.

But you have no idea that you wouldn't be able to continue with your 40hrs and some days remote if you had a job at Google. There are lots of people who have a positive work/life balance at Google. Some take advantage of some perks, some others, and some don't use very many at all, but the fact is that there are many perks available catering to a huge spectrum of desires, whether that means fitness, food, social, cultural, technology, or financial.

Just because Google offers onsite laundry and serves three meals a day doesn't mean employees have to participate. But having them makes it a more appealing place to a broader range of potential candidates, and a friendlier place for employees, too.

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#24
Does anyone else thinks this question is not well defined? Because, 1. How do you define employee productivity? 2. How do you know that Google employees have more productivity as opposed to other companies?

The analysis becomes even more convoluted when "employees" encompasses everyone from engineer to janitor to executive.

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#25
post #23
post #20

I feel as I would hate to work there. They are creating all these things to make it a 2nd home for people. They want people to be there a LONG time. I'm happy with 40hrs with some days remote and I don't think I could switch to googles approach.

But you have no idea that you wouldn't be able to continue with your 40hrs and some days remote if you had a job at Google. There are lots of people who have a positive work/life balance at Google. Some take advantage of some perks, some others, and some don't use very many at all, but the fact is that there are many perks available catering to a huge spectrum of desires, whether that means fitness, food, social, cul…

Do people who work 40 hours a week get promoted?

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#26
Some of the comments here suggest that the Google's perks are bad because they corrode work/life balance and encourage employees to stay longer.

Having worked at some of the FANGs, I can say that this effect of these perks on work/life decisions is very very small. Most people enjoy the perks and do what they were going to do anyway. Most of my teammates won't stay for free dinner because they'd rather spend time with their friends and families. Most people work from home all the ~once/week.

When work/life balance is bad, it's because of a desire to perform or managerial pressure; not because you get free food and an on-site dentist. Generally the perks are conveniences and genuinely nice to have, and if they are part of a sinister plot to exploit workers, they are pretty bad at it.

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#27
post #3

Not covered in first answer: you could leave at 6, but if you stay till 7 there's a roast dinner. I suspect people who still work at Google are sometimes a little blind to their own behaviour.

Young, brilliant programmers but still totally dependent on the approval of their peers - to the degree that they not only work very late to get food, they stay even longer to avoid someone judging them. I bet they even make excuses before leaving at 8 pm... Its really very sad that smart human beings act like that due purely to social pressure.

The last couple companies I worked at offered a dinner at ~8:00. There was no pressure to attend and as far as I know hardly anyone did.

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#28
I don't work at Google, but I think their productivity comes from not wasting time. I had some interactions over the years so here is what I have noticed (might not be true, might not be all, might depend on the teams I interacted with).

There seems to be a lot of effort to remove day to day time wasters in small things.

Then, if you think about it, having subpar teammates is also a waste of time. They are not only wasting their own time but also everybody elses. So making sure you don't let people with IQ less than certain threshold is also important for everybodys productivity.

Solving a problem once is extremely important. Instead of reinventing infrastructure for each and every project at the company as many companies do (mine, one of the largest banks in the world, in my team there are still people who are devoted to maintaining a handful of servers running Windows -- including completely custom everything from project structure, to build, to configuration mechanisms, everything reinvented for the project). Solving a problem once also means you can focus on a single problem because you are solving this problem for an entire company.

If you do Agile right you get to the part at the core of the process where you mercilessly optimize your process. I think most companies talk about Agile where Google is one of the very few that actually do it.

Re: Are Google employees more productive because of company perks?

#30
post #26

Some of the comments here suggest that the Google's perks are bad because they corrode work/life balance and encourage employees to stay longer. Having worked at some of the FANGs, I can say that this effect of these perks on work/life decisions is very very small. Most people enjoy the perks and do what they were going to do anyway. Most of my teammates won't stay for free dinner because they'd rather spend time wit…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN