Live data from Hacker News

(2016) Technology destroys people and places. I’m rejecting it

theguardian.com

71–74 of 74 posts

Re: (2016) Technology destroys people and places. I’m rejecting it

#71
post #22
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We can unquestionably say that communism has destroyed people and places.

We can also unquestionably say that communism is not the only alternative. For the record I am not an authoritarian communist and I don't think it's a good alternative. I was very specific. I said "state corporatist capitalism" because there are even capitalist alternatives to that such as voluntarist libertarian capitalism and communitarian/co-op oriented capitalism. Our system is one of state-backed corporate capit…

You wondered about the USSR. I was replying to that.

Re: (2016) Technology destroys people and places. I’m rejecting it

#72
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We can also unquestionably say that communism is not the only alternative. For the record I am not an authoritarian communist and I don't think it's a good alternative. I was very specific. I said "state corporatist capitalism" because there are even capitalist alternatives to that such as voluntarist libertarian capitalism and communitarian/co-op oriented capitalism. Our system is one of state-backed corporate capit…

You wondered about the USSR. I was replying to that.

My point about the USSR was about how people will often be in denial when the dominant socioeconomic system is displaying severe problems and may be on the brink of failure.

Re: (2016) Technology destroys people and places. I’m rejecting it

#73
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It sounds like our variant of capitalism is the system that's destroying people, not technology.

Bingo! I feel like you get this type of article from Americans as a cowardly way to avoid criticising unchecked capitalism or dealing with and engaging with their politics as a means to build a better government. Easier to blame a nebulous concept and the individual, then advocate for any sort of group cooperatism - even though as a species cooperating is what we've always done.

I don't think it's capitalism per se that's at issue, rather its execution: unethical capitalism is bad. Making money is not.

Re: (2016) Technology destroys people and places. I’m rejecting it

#74
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You wondered about the USSR. I was replying to that.

My point about the USSR was about how people will often be in denial when the dominant socioeconomic system is displaying severe problems and may be on the brink of failure.

I see, I misunderstood then.
Post reply on HN