Live data from Hacker News

Review my app for making server stacks social

stackfu.com

21–24 of 24 posts

Re: Review my app for making server stacks social

#21
post #18

I notice that the web site doesn't tell me what StackFu is. I don't want to have to watch a video just to find out if the concept is interesting enough to warrant the time it takes to watch a video. Anyway, it looks like a cool idea and I wish you the best of luck. And I've signed up for the beta. I still haven't watched the video.

Agreed. We'll be addressing that and improving the text communication on the website. Thank you!

Re: Review my app for making server stacks social

#22

Did the idea for this come from Linode's Stackscripts?

thegyppo, no. this idea came from Webbynode's Readystack system which we developed about 2 years before linode decided to launch their version (they launched it February 9, 2010, we did 2008). (Yes, we're the guys behind Webbynode)

This is our original concept, back from 2008, they launched theirs in 2009.

Check this out http://www.linode.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=4459&highli... and also our original 'readystack' idea post http://blog.webbynode.com/2008/10/29/webbystacks/

This is our original concept, back from 2008.

Re: Review my app for making server stacks social

#23
I would never in my life allow an external machine to run arbitrary commands on my server. This is like giving root to some person I don't know.

Even if I could read all these scripts the service is going to execute, nobody tells me that the script I'm seeing on the web service is the script that actually gets executed.

Now. I don't insinuate that the OP is trying to take over servers, but we all know about bugs and/or the famous disgruntled employee.

If I could install this service in my own network, having full control over the scripts and the service itself, this could be useful, but giving root to some server not under my control?

This actually begins at the very first start of your video.

You want me to execute a script that I download using wget from a non-https-site. As root.

shudder

Re: Review my app for making server stacks social

#24
post #23

I would never in my life allow an external machine to run arbitrary commands on my server. This is like giving root to some person I don't know. Even if I could read all these scripts the service is going to execute, nobody tells me that the script I'm seeing on the web service is the script that actually gets executed. Now. I don't insinuate that the OP is trying to take over servers, but we all know about bugs and/…

It will be an HTTPS site, and maybe even if you wouldn't run the scripts, would you consider contributing on the other end, writing them and sharing with less experienced users?
Post reply on HN