Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Lumberyard: A Scream of Anguish

viva64.com

1–10 of 58 posts

Re: Amazon Lumberyard: A Scream of Anguish

#4
post #3

If it wasn't obvious from the URL, OP is more about a code analyzer product than Amazon Lumber, mentioned in passing as an example usage.

Yeah. I think the analyzer is pretty neat. It's cool to focus on human mistakes writing code rather than validity of code itself. I see a bunch of errors I've made before, especially when copying and pasting. Time to find something like this for vscode to do realtime linting of human errors.

That being said, I think this article really overstates the dire state of Lumberyard. Yep, it has bugs. I don't think this convinces me that the sky is falling if the devs don't change their ways.

Re: Amazon Lumberyard: A Scream of Anguish

#5

One thing that puzzles is me is why some of these checks aren't just part of the warnings that a compiler emits. I get that you wouldn't want to enable them all the time, but usually comparing a variable to itself is not what you want.

You're right, but just a fun edge-case to think about (in JS):

  NaN === NaN // -> false
This check is sometimes used to check if a number is NaN.

Re: Amazon Lumberyard: A Scream of Anguish

#6
One of the best blog-ads for a product I've seen in a long time.

It effectively shows value of their software while being interesting enough and relevant to something popular that already has (some) following. Perfect.

Makes me wish they had something similar for JS or Python. I know I've made these mistakes all too often.

Re: Amazon Lumberyard: A Scream of Anguish

#8

One of the best blog-ads for a product I've seen in a long time. It effectively shows value of their software while being interesting enough and relevant to something popular that already has (some) following. Perfect. Makes me wish they had something similar for JS or Python. I know I've made these mistakes all too often.

One of the best comment-ads for a blog-ad for a product I've seen in a long time.

It effectively paints the blog-spam as being a good article.

Re: Amazon Lumberyard: A Scream of Anguish

#10
post #7

Why would anyone choose Lumberyard over CryEngine directly? I would think that ones core product will always be better maintained then just some side project that was bought in.

E.g. because Amazon might still be around next week? This hasn't been a given regarding Crytec for quite a while now.
Post reply on HN