Live data from Hacker News

Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

wsj.com

81–90 of 174 posts

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is your suggestion for OP where their resume is immediately discard because of no education? Networking and meetups won’t get you passed HR filters and corporate requirements. As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. And you now have experience to put towards your next employer (and your old employer will only verify employment dates, as they don’t want to…

> As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. I fail to see how poisoning your own reputation comes out as "still ahead"; that is absolutely guaranteed to get your résumé silently discarded. The tech community isn't that big, even in the tech hubs, and word does eventually get around both among engineers and recruiters.

I’m not advocating lying, but there’s no way this comes up, at least not at startups. Do you think we sit at the bar and discuss potential hires university degrees? If someone told me “watch out man, Stu lied about his uni education” my response is likely to be, “why would you tell me that and why would you think I cared?”.

The gabber is going to look worse than the candidate by a long shot.

Careful who you gab about and who you gab to.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#82

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Fake it until you make it" is completely different from "lie until you are caught." Speaking from experience, lying is not a good idea. OP is competing against people who have put in work that he/she hasn't. That's just the reality. The best way in is to show the employer that they are a qualitatively superior employee. Networking and filters are _very often_ surpassed by leadership, sometimes even by creating new p…

Your anecdotes aren’t helpful compared to the macro scale at which employers disregard capable candidates due to unnecessary signaling requirements. I don’t suggest lying lightly, but it is sometimes necessary in the current environment.

Here's another anecdote: I'll take four experiential-subjective anecdotes from a professional any day, as compared to macro-scale analytical-subjective theories from an analyzer-theorist.

Dodging around relational morals like "don't lie to others" or "be a good human being to others" is a typical blind spot of a game-analyzer-type logician. "I beat the game, don't I win the prize?" are famous last words in these cases; I suggest you choose your audience very carefully if you wish for your cognitive gifts to be celebrated in the context of such a strongly-recognized developmental target as being an honest person. Perhaps sporting or hostage negotiation or other "bluffing"-oriented domains are better suited for such advice, where some variant of "outright lying" is given a little bit more leeway.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#83
My state has a network of community and technical colleges. There is a program that allows one to get their Associates degree through community colleges, then transfer to a state school and continue paying community college tuition.

10 years ago, this allowed for earning an engineering degree for $2k a year, or $8-10k.

In my experience, community colleges were very much viewed as remedial. I’d guess that many of the classes were taken by students who had failed the equivalent class at university.

I took Physics at both the community college and university (I was afraid that the community college class would not prepare me for later classes). The differences were stark: At university, lecture was 3x a week by the professor (who did not speak English), recitation by a TA (who did not speak English), and lab by another TA. There were 3 sections with 400 students per section. The professor had one hour of office hours for all 400 students in my section. At community college, my professor lectured, ran the lab, ran recitation. He went to a top 5 school, was an American, and was a great teacher. The class had 2 sections of 30 students. He ran weekend reviews for tests, if needed, and had open office hours all day. His tests were very difficult and required mastery of the subject matter.

I dropped the university class after I realized it was of much lower quality than what I had already received, for 1/5th the price, no less.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#84
post #4

This is an interesting reaction to the "bootcamp" trend (and subsequent implosion). I think it has a better chance of succeeding: you might not need four years of university education to become an entry-level developer, but a few weeks of intensive "bootcamp" training isn't enough.

> (and subsequent implosion)

Can you elaborate?

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You won't have a case if you're fired for lying on your resume. Lying about your education is not merely an "inaccuracy".

I’ve seen lesser cases win. You’d be surprised. Your tight knit industry community isn’t the general public.

> I’ve seen lesser cases win. You’d be surprised. Your tight knit industry community isn’t the general public.

[citation needed]

Court cases are a matter of public record and, given your, ahem, open advocacy of falsehoods, it's unclear why we should believe your unsupported assertion.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Fake it until you make it" is completely different from "lie until you are caught." Speaking from experience, lying is not a good idea. OP is competing against people who have put in work that he/she hasn't. That's just the reality. The best way in is to show the employer that they are a qualitatively superior employee. Networking and filters are _very often_ surpassed by leadership, sometimes even by creating new p…

Your anecdotes aren’t helpful compared to the macro scale at which employers disregard capable candidates due to unnecessary signaling requirements. I don’t suggest lying lightly, but it is sometimes necessary in the current environment.

Would you want your doctor to be lying about having obtained his medical degree?

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#87

Community college was one of the smartest moves of my life. The IGETC program ensured that my education was equivalent to what I would have gotten at a UC as a freshmen and sophomore. My teachers were mostly Stanford and Berkeley PHDs. They were dedicated to teaching. Not trying to balance research and teaching. 30 people per class, maximum. Arguably, I got a better education than UC students. And obviously, cost. My…

Congratulations. Seeing this made me really happy.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#88
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. I fail to see how poisoning your own reputation comes out as "still ahead"; that is absolutely guaranteed to get your résumé silently discarded. The tech community isn't that big, even in the tech hubs, and word does eventually get around both among engineers and recruiters.

I’m not advocating lying, but there’s no way this comes up, at least not at startups. Do you think we sit at the bar and discuss potential hires university degrees? If someone told me “watch out man, Stu lied about his uni education” my response is likely to be, “why would you tell me that and why would you think I cared?”. The gabber is going to look worse than the candidate by a long shot. Careful who you gab about…

Startups involve a lot of trust between the members of the initial group. I wouldn't have anything to do with trusting my future to a professional liar.

It's like marrying someone who cheated on their spouse. They'll cheat on you, next.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#89
post #61

If this trend is real it will be really good for social mobility.

I don't think so. Having a degree from CC marks you as from the lower class. Upper level and prestigious positions tend to be filled with people just like those already there. There was a good study on this http://www.asanet.org/journals/ASR/Dec12ASRFeature.pdf

But doest it mean lower class is much higher than it'd have been otherwise? That's still a win.

Re: Big Tech’s Hot New Talent Incubator: Community College

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't do this. I have a client who did this, and he now wonders how many interviews he _missed out on_ over a 3-year period because the employer was interested but the college screening came up lie-positive. Many, many employers public & private do verify. And some people will start rumors if you are in a small community, or if they know someone you know. And if the employer later finds out that you lied, the lie wil…

What is your suggestion for OP where their resume is immediately discard because of no education? Networking and meetups won’t get you passed HR filters and corporate requirements. As I mentioned, even if you don’t get the job or lose the job, you’re still ahead of not trying. And you now have experience to put towards your next employer (and your old employer will only verify employment dates, as they don’t want to…

Maybe you think you can get ahead by lying. Don't expect others to congratulate you for it.
Post reply on HN