Live data from Hacker News

Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

github.com

131–140 of 253 posts

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#131

I feel like the first rule of youtube-dl is not to talk about youtube-dl. I keep expecting Google (and all the other sites it works on) to start taking active measures to disable it. At some point YouTube is going to require an EME module to play even "free" videos.

Not everyone has fast enough bandwidth to watch live videos. Many people rely on downloaders to actually watch the video.

But they don't download the ads, so I doubt they matter very much as far as google is concerned

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#132
post #117

Please stop talking about this, I love how it is now!

But if people didn’t talk about this, I would have have known that I could use it to watch BBC iPlayer without going through the annoying login-wall!

Wow that’s really useful to know.

It also works for YouTube vids which are blocked in your country. :-)

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#133

I feel like the first rule of youtube-dl is not to talk about youtube-dl. I keep expecting Google (and all the other sites it works on) to start taking active measures to disable it. At some point YouTube is going to require an EME module to play even "free" videos.

I think command line utilities will usually be the last to receive active counter measures as they are generally considered to be used only by geeks which constitute a negligible percent of consumers.

Youtube-dl has lots of GUI frontends and is embedded in easy to use Android apps.

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is the classic cat-and-mouse game. We are pretty good at it by now.

I don't know. Netflix is doing a pretty good job shutting down VPN proxying. Yes, I know there are some providers that still work... Shhhh! However, it's a lot easier for Netflix to blacklist an IP (or an entire IP range) than it is for a provider to setup a whole new proxy - likely connected via a residential ISP.

But they're not doing a good job in blacklisting debit card providers (providers that let you generate your own unique debit card number and start a free trial on this new card, resulting in using the service for free) or banning shared accounts (i.e. 4 people meet on the internet only for the purposes of buying one account).

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like JDownloader, but it comes with adware and other things in its installer.

Run it on docker, I use jlesage/jdownloader-2

How does the problem of running some untrustworthy code get better by adding even more binaries?

Is the goal just to use the kernel's process isolation features that you can access with `unshare`?

Or do you mean to just bypass the installation step (because that purportedly contains adware)?

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#136

A very useful and "secret" feature: you can give youtube-dl the URL of a playlist instead of a single video and it will download all of them.

...and specify to only grab the videos as mp3's to download that perfect song/mix playlist!

Aspiring DJs do this, then play out the files they got from youtube-dl via Serato or whatever, then every other minimally competent DJ in the room immediately knows what’s happening based on how obviously shit it sounds. Practice mixing in headphones and playing room scale PA are two different ballgames, and when amplified, any youtube-dl format is as obvious to me as a file being ripped from source vinyl. YouTube does more processing than people realize, and it doesn’t take much ear for me to identify a pirated crate (even beyond YouTube specifically).

If you spin and use youtube-dl to build a crate, we all know, and we don’t respect you. You might win the crowd, but the people who actually bought into their profession and contributed to the community are also in attendance, and are very aware of your intrusion. You will quietly lose gigs without any explanation, and assume promoters simply can’t see your genius until you’re furiously working on 100 precious listens on SoundCloud. Fair use sampling? Go nuts and clean it up after youtube-dl. Five minute record? Make a Beatport account and get it overwith.

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I agree with you in principle (and have used a very similar setup for many years), I don't think HN is pro-DRM/IP enough to worry. At some point YouTube is going to require an EME module to play even "free" videos. ...which will be cracked within days if not hours.

> which will be cracked within days if not hours. Netflix requires an EME module since quite some time, and I'm not aware of any successful cracks.

All Netflix-exclusive shows are available up to 4K on torrent networks:

https://thepiratebay.org/search/house%20of%20cards%202160p/0...

https://thepiratebay.org/search/orange%20is%20the%20new%20bl...

https://1337x.to/search/ozark+2160p/1/

What’s left to steal?

Meanwhile the majority of Netflix customers is limited to 720p video like it’s 2001. [1]

[1] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/55763

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#139

One thing I wonder is how dependant other YouTube creators are in being able to download YouTube videos so they can use it for commentary and parody. If YouTube made that significantly harder, would some creators suffer?

I bet most would start doing it with screen capture software/cards. I think many already are.

Re: Youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos

#140

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While I agree with you in principle (and have used a very similar setup for many years), I don't think HN is pro-DRM/IP enough to worry. At some point YouTube is going to require an EME module to play even "free" videos. ...which will be cracked within days if not hours.

> which will be cracked within days if not hours. Netflix requires an EME module since quite some time, and I'm not aware of any successful cracks.

Well Netflix's content is pirated just as much as any other content, so I guess it was cracked in some way?
Post reply on HN