Live data from Hacker News

How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

nytimes.com

31–40 of 166 posts

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#31
I loved this format so much. It feels like some of the people who are complaining are acting as if this is going to replace text somehow, which I hardly think will be the case. There is plenty of room for both formats. I thought this was the perfect middleground between a documentary and an article. Documentaries often feel biased or like they're trying to manipulate the audience or something. Articles, at least to me (though it's a function of how good your imagination is), can sometimes feel a bit too distant from reality. Language is too abstract, too manipulable, and some phrases are too loaded to not be distracting. Short videos with scenes from everyday life, coupled with a slight bit of interactivity (the "next" button) makes it much harder to zone out of (unlike a long-form movie), and to me at least made it much more somehow connected to reality. I definitely feel like I have a much closer and personal understanding of the situation, much more so than I would have gotten with a documentary or an article.

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Trump != capitalism Capitalism is: - freedom to own property - freedom to use or trade property you own - freedom to trade services for property or other services Of course that's not enough to create a viable society. Whatever else you add to the sauce is not capitalism, it's something else.

> Capitalism is

The items listed have nothing to do with capitalism. More like "things you often find" or "things you wish were true", or more aptly, "things you are told are true, but are misleading". "freedom" to own things is not a freedom nor is it guaranteed in a capitalism economy nor is it true when faced with anything other than a nascent capitalist economy where other actors make the decision of who owns what, beyond your own agency.

I'm not sure you know what capitalism is now.

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#33
This is not an article, it's a movie with subtitles. (It should have a [video] tag.) And it doesn't address how to survive when money is worthless, it just shows some vignettes from Venezuela that illustrate how hard it is to survive when money is worthless.

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Trump != capitalism Capitalism is: - freedom to own property - freedom to use or trade property you own - freedom to trade services for property or other services Of course that's not enough to create a viable society. Whatever else you add to the sauce is not capitalism, it's something else.

> Capitalism is The items listed have nothing to do with capitalism. More like "things you often find" or "things you wish were true", or more aptly, "things you are told are true, but are misleading". "freedom" to own things is not a freedom nor is it guaranteed in a capitalism economy nor is it true when faced with anything other than a nascent capitalist economy where other actors make the decision of who owns wha…

Capitalism as a label only began to exist in order to draw a distinction between "capitalist" societies and societies where those particular freedoms are denied.

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#36
post #12

For all the negative comments about the presentation, which I might normally agree with, I liked this format this time. It took a while to load (thank you multi-threading). I got through it because I treated it like an interactive video with subtitles, which is better than a video. I liked the sound - which, in my iPhone, was muted at the started as my phone was muted, so I didn't even realise there was audio. I like…

I actually found this to be worth the time. I haven't paid much attention to the situation down there, and seeing it was enlightening. Onto the content... I wonder, can someone tell me why there are so many obese people in these video clips, if food is so hard to come by? Why does there seem to be so many people sitting around? Surely with so much manpower available, there are way to make them productive on a large s…

> Why does there seem to be so many people sitting around?

The fundamental problem with corruption, and the reason that corrupt dictatorships do not work in practice is that people need to be able to keep the things they produce. If, say, you are hungry, you might start a community garden to feed yourself and your neighbors. However, you can only feed yourself if men with guns don't decide that the garden is actually theirs. If you expand this system out to every facet of society, then there's no point in anyone helping anyone else because any public good is sucked up by corrupt people who claim it for themselves. Everyone must get by on less than is worth stealing, or they have to do it in secret.

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#37
post #12

For all the negative comments about the presentation, which I might normally agree with, I liked this format this time. It took a while to load (thank you multi-threading). I got through it because I treated it like an interactive video with subtitles, which is better than a video. I liked the sound - which, in my iPhone, was muted at the started as my phone was muted, so I didn't even realise there was audio. I like…

I actually found this to be worth the time. I haven't paid much attention to the situation down there, and seeing it was enlightening. Onto the content... I wonder, can someone tell me why there are so many obese people in these video clips, if food is so hard to come by? Why does there seem to be so many people sitting around? Surely with so much manpower available, there are way to make them productive on a large s…

According to The Economist, the average Venezuelan has lost 19lbs; more than half of children are either malnourished or at risk of malnutrition.

https://www.economist.com/the-americas/2017/03/31/venezuela-...

Univision reports that 57% of Venezuelans have gone hungry to feed their children.

https://www.univision.com/univision-news/latin-america/hungr...

The situation in Venezuela is clearly grave.

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#38

Is there a text version? The "multimedia" presentation is pretty annoying.

Reader view in safari or firefox is what you want. I have it turned on for all websites and haven't looked back. I honestly don't know how chrome users can use the web nowadays with how bad things have gotten.

Reader view doesn't seem very useful for this particular article, which is primarily visual.

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#39
post #12

For all the negative comments about the presentation, which I might normally agree with, I liked this format this time. It took a while to load (thank you multi-threading). I got through it because I treated it like an interactive video with subtitles, which is better than a video. I liked the sound - which, in my iPhone, was muted at the started as my phone was muted, so I didn't even realise there was audio. I like…

I actually found this to be worth the time. I haven't paid much attention to the situation down there, and seeing it was enlightening. Onto the content... I wonder, can someone tell me why there are so many obese people in these video clips, if food is so hard to come by? Why does there seem to be so many people sitting around? Surely with so much manpower available, there are way to make them productive on a large s…

What do you propose to "make them productive"?

Re: How to Survive When Money Is Worthless [video]

#40
post #12

For all the negative comments about the presentation, which I might normally agree with, I liked this format this time. It took a while to load (thank you multi-threading). I got through it because I treated it like an interactive video with subtitles, which is better than a video. I liked the sound - which, in my iPhone, was muted at the started as my phone was muted, so I didn't even realise there was audio. I like…

Sure, but the risk of this presentation is technology.

The audio cut out for several of the stories halfway through, then I was just reading the subtitles as they showed up.

I eventually refreshed the page.

Another story had the audio continue, but the video stopped and froze.

Post reply on HN