Live data from Hacker News

Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

npr.org

121–130 of 186 posts

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#121
post #101
post #86

You can be in an "underslept state" even if you get 8 hrs a night. I usually am. I snore. Most of the time and very loudly. So do maybe a billion other people. It negatively impacts the quality and quantity of your sleep (and that of the people around you). It can greatly increase the risk of a whole slew of nasty diseases. And yet there is no cure and no effective treatment. As near as I can tell, no one is working…

I suffered from obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) and snoring, and the two things that helped were sleeping on my side and weight loss. The latter was difficult to achieve but was the most high-leverage thing I ever did. I had no idea at the time, but my OSA was contributing to a slew of health problems like hypertension etc., and when I removed the cause, my overall health got better.

Exactly. The need for a CPAP is almost always mitigated by weight loss.

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#122
post #23

Apart from quantity, quality of sleep is also important. I just realized how much a little light can disturb sleep. My blinds are opaque but hung 1-2 cm from the window frame, letting in just a few unwanted photons. I temporarily taped the blinds to the frame, leaving the room in almost complete darkness. I haven't felt this rested in years. Do try this at home!

Easier yet, use any opaque dark cloth (bath towel, handkerchief, etc.) and drape it over your eyes so that all light is extinguished. I take a nap every afternoon preferably at 1:15 p.m.. I waken 20 minutes later, refreshed and ready for the rest of the day.

Buff headwear (http://www.buffwear.co.uk/) is great for this as it’s a really soft material, much more comfortable than an eye mask I find, and will stay in place unlike a towel or whatever. Blocks out a pretty good amount of light too.

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#124
post #117

Has no one mentioned parenthood forcing sleep deprivation for 1-3+ years?

Oh I wanted to ask this but then I was thinking that it is just my situation (child less than 1 year who wakes up sometimes once per hour). Actually I am almost scared to read the book. I am afraid that I will agree with the book and then be left with the feeling that the only logical conclusion is that there is no solution and my health will just vanish forever.

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#125
post #3

> Sleep is not like the bank, so you can't accumulate a debt and then try and pay it off at a later point in time. And the reason is this: We know that if I were to deprive you of sleep for an entire night — take away eight hours — and then in the subsequent night I give you all of the sleep that you want, however much you wish to consume, you never get back all that you lost. You will sleep longer, but you will neve…

Yeah this quote sounds like something that someone would say when they don’t actually understand the underlying system. It doesn’t follow that if you miss eight hours of sleep you’d need 16 to catch up - maybe some processes take a standard amount of time and don’t need to be repeated, it might be more efficient when you’re already asleep to fix things in an extra two hours than an entire extra eight. Something is fi…

I'm glad other people are talking about this, because this part of the article really irritated me as well.

Building off what you said:

>It doesn’t follow that if you miss eight hours of sleep you’d need 16 to catch up

It might also be that if you miss eight hours, you can never catch up 100%, you can never fully pay off the lost sleep. It would still stand to reason that you'll be better off with X amount of "catch-up" hours, such as the extra 2 a night you were suggesting, following lost sleep than if you didn't have any catch-up hours.

So knocking down the straw man of "you can't fully repay your sleep balance" seems to be an equivocation that's just wasting everyone's time. I don't know that people necessarily think that exact thing. It's still probably better to sleep more after going without it, even if you don't literally gain 100% of the benefits back, and that's probably what most people mean.

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#127
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Of course they are. You'll learn less in your sleep deprived states, Which are days you aren't going to get back. Your sleep deprived self will also be better at creating tech debt, which takes away time from the future.

That is an odd perspective. That's like saying that the damage from a twisted ankle is permanent, since you'll never get back the two days of lost activity. From that point of view, all injuries are permanent.

You generally don't recover fully from twisted ankles. Most injuries are in fact permanent in a certain sense. You heal, but not 100%.

I saw this analogy upthread, and it's changed how I consider sleep deprivation. Brain injuries may not be different from physical injuries.

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#128

I don’t doubt that hat the people don’t get enough sleep, but the biggest health problem in the western world is Obesity. It has huge health, environmental, and social costs.

Might obesity be related to lack of sleep?

Lack of sleep can definitely contribute to weight gain. Probably in more than one way, but I know specifically of studies that found lack of sleep makes you crave more unhealthy high calorie foods.

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#129

In the UK we have a fantastic service called Radio 4 which has remarkable sleep-inducing powers. Much better than any narcotic sleep aid, in my experience. Podcasts also work well, in my experience.

I like podcasts a lot for this purpose. My mind tends to race a lot when I get in bed and it would take me at least an hour to fall asleep usually. Podcasts my brain just that little bit of focus and engagement that I need to drift off.

I usually set a sleep timer and drift off. The thing that I haven't found a solution for yet though with it is needing to use my phone right before I fall asleep. I inevitably fall into the trap of checking email or looking up something.

Re: Sleep Scientist Warns Against Walking Through Life 'In an Underslept State'

#130

Articles like this scares me greatly. About 2 years ago, I went about 3 weeks with maybe less than 3 hours of sleep. I am sure it is hard to believe, even I can't believe it myself, it was a crazy experience, where my mind was just passed the point of exhaustion that I could not feel tiredness at all. After that my sleeping have never been the same, went through almost a 2 years of waking up every 3 hours or so. It's…

What caused the initial deprivation?
Post reply on HN