Live data from Hacker News

Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

nature.com

21–30 of 97 posts

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#22

Not saying we shouldn't pay attention when some estimates are wrong, but perhaps it's not the best idea to take an alarmist's attitude: https://motls.blogspot.com/2018/06/hansens-testimony-30th-an...

Also much more on methane in particular: https://motls.blogspot.com/search?q=methane

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#23
post #4

In case you're wondering, burning natural gas does produce ~half the CO2 you would release from burning various types of coal, [0] the dirtiest (yes, much worse than all of the nuclear power accidents combined[1]) of all methods of electricity production. But it still produces CO2! And at the rate at which natural gas is taking over a greater share of the energy production of the world economy, we are still looking a…

In a five year period Methane traps ~100 times more energy than the equivalent quantity of CO2, so not burning Methane because it escapes is far worse than burning it!

http://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/methane-vs-ca...

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#24

This is so sad. Any ideas on how stuff like this could realistically be fixed? Are there any incentives that could be put in place? What would be the incentive for the people that have that power to make those changes?

Fracking ban.

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#25
post #4

In case you're wondering, burning natural gas does produce ~half the CO2 you would release from burning various types of coal, [0] the dirtiest (yes, much worse than all of the nuclear power accidents combined[1]) of all methods of electricity production. But it still produces CO2! And at the rate at which natural gas is taking over a greater share of the energy production of the world economy, we are still looking a…

In a five year period Methane traps ~100 times more energy than the equivalent quantity of CO2, so not burning Methane because it escapes is far worse than burning it! http://www.onegreenplanet.org/animalsandnature/methane-vs-ca...

Which brings us around to the subject of the article ;)

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#26

Not saying we shouldn't pay attention when some estimates are wrong, but perhaps it's not the best idea to take an alarmist's attitude: https://motls.blogspot.com/2018/06/hansens-testimony-30th-an...

That blog is much more propagandist than anything James Hansen ever did.

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#27
post #6

This is so sad. Any ideas on how stuff like this could realistically be fixed? Are there any incentives that could be put in place? What would be the incentive for the people that have that power to make those changes?

Removing lobbyists, removing buyable politicians, electing politicians that believe in science

Remove the mandatory bribe quota first and the politicians will follow.

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#28
post #12

This is so sad. Any ideas on how stuff like this could realistically be fixed? Are there any incentives that could be put in place? What would be the incentive for the people that have that power to make those changes?

Carbon tax

Methane tax.

Re: Methane leaks from US gas fields dwarf government estimates

#29
post #7

This is so sad. Any ideas on how stuff like this could realistically be fixed? Are there any incentives that could be put in place? What would be the incentive for the people that have that power to make those changes?

There is already incentive for the private operators to not lose these gases during production or transmission as it cuts into their margins. This is like leaving money on the table.

Then why are they letting it continue to escape? Proof is in the pudding.
Post reply on HN