Live data from Hacker News

Synergy-core: Open source core of Synergy, the keyboard and mouse sharing tool

github.com

81–90 of 99 posts

Re: Synergy-core: Open source core of Synergy, the keyboard and mouse sharing tool

#81
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nick forked a dead project and wanted to keep developing it, but still needed to pay rent and eat (a common problem among programmers). In order to try to both continue paying for necessary life functions and work on Synergy, he began asking for money. This isn't evil. The project was abandoned when he came along. I'm not saying Nick Bolton has done everything right, he clearly had little to no business experience be…

I think you summed it up quite nicely. I developed the original Mac port, I guess about 15 years ago now. I’m pretty conflicted as to what’s happened with Synergy recently, but not because I feel like there’s anything morally wrong in what Nick did. I’m more bummed out because it feels like a market failure, for lack of a better way of explaining it: how could a useful open source project, valued by many and (tbh) no…

I think he just put too many eggs in that basket too quickly. It's a great product, and the cross platform support is killer since Multiplicity from EdgeRunner/Stardock and Mouse without Borders are both Windows only. I think Nick Bolton saw an opportunity, but wasn't necessarily the most qualified person to handle the task. I'm not trying to insult him, but I was around when Synergy was waiting on Chris to release the fabled 2.0 and when Nick Bolton jumped in to try to make a business out of Synergy.

His twist towards a commercial license came from the fact that despite it being used by many people, few ever paid. He obviously felt he had to force the issue but clearly chose poorly. This is an itch many people feel, but clearly few wish to scratch. It's frustrating.

Re: Synergy-core: Open source core of Synergy, the keyboard and mouse sharing tool

#82
I'm a little amazed at all the reports of problems in the comments here on HN. I have been using Synergy for probably 15 years now, and have had very little issue with it. I use it to connect Linux, OSX and Windows. I use what appears to be version 2.0 on Gentoo as the main driver/server (the machine where the keyboard and mouse are connected).

Re: Synergy-core: Open source core of Synergy, the keyboard and mouse sharing tool

#84
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some context, the letter came only after months of the same guy dismissing openly or behind the scenes - e.g. not approving posts on the forum - any reported issues and calls from the users that v2 was of beta quality. So I'd say it was an OK move but for sure a forced one after all the negative feedback.

Yep I left after the v2 beta nonsense. He locked my account out from the forums when he didn’t like my feedback. ShareMouse is by far a better product. I feel sorry for the employees but it’ll be a good day when symless goes out of business. Here’s a fine example of Nick Bolton addressing a longstanding bug: https://github.com/symless/synergy-core/issues/5226 He deleted a bunch of comments, locked the conversation an…

ShareMouse doesn't support Linux so it's not a 1to1 replacement. Plus I'm very satisfied with synergy v1 just commenting on the approach from the symless CEO here

Re: Synergy-core: Open source core of Synergy, the keyboard and mouse sharing tool

#85

I wrote my own replacement for synergy years ago. It's called touchstream[0] -- it's unlikely to be as full features as, but it's TONS lighter, and I've been using between my mac workstation and my linux workstation for a good many years without a single issue. Mileage may very, etc etc -- I implemented the features I needed! [0]: https://github.com/buserror/touchstream

I understand you built this for yourself and your use case.

Did I read this correctly in that it _needs_ a mac (because only that can be the server) though? Came to look if this could replace my linux to linux or - more common here - windows to linux scenarios. The latter is straight out I guess, but the former seems impossible too for now, right?

Re: Synergy-core: Open source core of Synergy, the keyboard and mouse sharing tool

#86

I wrote my own replacement for synergy years ago. It's called touchstream[0] -- it's unlikely to be as full features as, but it's TONS lighter, and I've been using between my mac workstation and my linux workstation for a good many years without a single issue. Mileage may very, etc etc -- I implemented the features I needed! [0]: https://github.com/buserror/touchstream

I understand you built this for yourself and your use case. Did I read this correctly in that it _needs_ a mac (because only that can be the server) though? Came to look if this could replace my linux to linux or - more common here - windows to linux scenarios. The latter is straight out I guess, but the former seems impossible too for now, right?

Hi -- yeah there is no support code for windows; I don't use a windows desktop so I never had a need for it -- however the 'skeleton' is in thre, perhaps you could do it by backporting a few bits and pieces of the old synergy..

Re: Synergy-core: Open source core of Synergy, the keyboard and mouse sharing tool

#89
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except it looks like Nick fired everyone except himself and one customer service person who is 'Rather excitingly, Sarah is also spending some of her time to improve her software engineering skills so she can help with developing Synergy' ( https://symless.com/blog/open-letter-synergy-team )? Seems like a really terrible plan, when you need to retrain CSRs to do your engineering.

Yep, and starting several months ago I was getting weekly emails asking if I'd be interested in moving to England to work for them as a software engineer. Except, I'm not a software engineer (I'm a hardware guy), just a customer of theirs from V1 days. They made it sound like an emergency situation where they had to stall development until they could recruit some more talent. It got so bad I had to unsub from their m…

No software engineers were fired. There were 3 devs at Symless, including myself, and we left of our own accord for various reasons.

This certainly did create a bit of a crisis, because hiring C++ talent in small towns outside of London is hard.

Post reply on HN