Live data from Hacker News

Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

jeffgeerling.com

151–160 of 396 posts

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#151
post #13

I'm pretty disappointed with the compromises I have to make to use a Mac these days. I'm planning on getting one of the new XPS 15s with an i-9 - so excited!

What you don’t like exchanging all your ports for dongles? And the crappy keyboard? Or my favorite “Remind me again later” Because who would ever want the ability to say “no”

> Or my favorite “Remind me again later” Because who would ever want the ability to say “no”

Can't you just change your settings on preferences?

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#153

Good summary, I share most of the points provided in the post. Also, I think a few more things worth to mention. Pros: - XPS has a decent hardware (I got 16GB, i8Gen, 500GB SSD and forgot about having a few docker containers running on the background which was an issue with my MacBook Pro 15 (8GB, 2.5Gh) - It is really 1k$ cheaper than the same config MacBook model. Apple's Retina and Touchbar are really cool, howeve…

>"WiFi is super shitty in XPS series. If you have not had any issues yet - than you have not bought one yet. It is better to replace with 30$ adapter to not have issues with differently configured routers;" This is really surprising. Can you say what specific replacement worked for you on that laptop?

The 9343 model shipped with a Broadcom wifi card, which was a PITA to get working on Linux. I swapped mine out for an Intel 7265, which has kernel support, so, any distro I throw on there works instantly without having to download a bunch of drivers.

More recent models have switched to the "Killer" brand wifi card, and I'm not sure whether those have in-kernel support or if it's another akmod thing.

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#155
> Windows 10 spends about 5 minutes (literally!) identifying a bunch of new devices and adding them to the system, with a notification popping up for each thing

Really, does anybody knows why Windows needs all this time to identify USB devices? The same PC does it instantaneously when running Linux.

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#156
post #141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So it's not approved for military use? Ok, point given.

That's what a consumer-grade product is: when you get a substantially lower build quality for what otherwise is exactly the same machine.

So most everything out there including everything Apple is consumer grade? Ok. Some people (including me) see military grade as enhanced build of the regular product but whatever. Potato, tomato.

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#157

I'd really like to buy an XPS, but I'm after a US keyboard layout, and I'm in the UK. You seemingly can't request a layout that is not your locale. This has been my experience with every laptop I've been interested. Damn shame; I have a Happy Hacking Keyboard Pro2, and it's the best keyboard I've ever used, I want as much of that experience as I can get on my laptop. Being a touch typist, its (not infuriating but sli…

I'm in exactly the same position, it didn't even occur to me that the layout might be different. What's the difference between the US and UK layouts?

A few things. The " and @ are swapped, I think, and some stuff about backslash. I can see that would be annoying for American users.

But the main pro for UK users is that the UK layout has a double-height Return key. It's fab.

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#158

I'd really like to buy an XPS, but I'm after a US keyboard layout, and I'm in the UK. You seemingly can't request a layout that is not your locale. This has been my experience with every laptop I've been interested. Damn shame; I have a Happy Hacking Keyboard Pro2, and it's the best keyboard I've ever used, I want as much of that experience as I can get on my laptop. Being a touch typist, its (not infuriating but sli…

I'm in exactly the same position, it didn't even occur to me that the layout might be different. What's the difference between the US and UK layouts?

On the US keyboard, the enter key is only one key height and longer, and the left shift key is longer. This moves a couple of keys around (`\). The most notable (especially from a programming point of view) is that the " and @ keys are switched. I use strings way more than I do anything else, so the US way is preferable here as its on the home row. The pound sign disappears, but I don't think I've ever actually needed it, while I need $ all the time.

Perhaps minor, but as I say, noticeable when I switch keyboards that its an annoyance.

Edit: added some text

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#159

I'd really like to buy an XPS, but I'm after a US keyboard layout, and I'm in the UK. You seemingly can't request a layout that is not your locale. This has been my experience with every laptop I've been interested. Damn shame; I have a Happy Hacking Keyboard Pro2, and it's the best keyboard I've ever used, I want as much of that experience as I can get on my laptop. Being a touch typist, its (not infuriating but sli…

I'm with ya, but that's because I'm an American who finds himself in the UK! Every UK keyboard I use is ever so slightly different, which drives me a bit crazy.

Re: Dell XPS 13 Review from a lifelong Mac user

#160

Good summary, I share most of the points provided in the post. Also, I think a few more things worth to mention. Pros: - XPS has a decent hardware (I got 16GB, i8Gen, 500GB SSD and forgot about having a few docker containers running on the background which was an issue with my MacBook Pro 15 (8GB, 2.5Gh) - It is really 1k$ cheaper than the same config MacBook model. Apple's Retina and Touchbar are really cool, howeve…

> WiFi is super shitty in XPS series.

Holy cow, yes. My wife's XPS 13 had the crappiest Killer WiFi card, and Dell would not acknolwedge that it was the source of all of our issues no matter what I tried, no matter what evidence I presented. The WiFi card was causing all sorts of issues from slow browsing, to the entire computer freezing on restart/shutdown, to no WiFi after wake up from sleep... the list goes on.

I finally rage quit after a session with Dell support had me run hours of meaningless diagnostics tools and then said everything was ok and to check my router. I told them right from the get go that I suspected the Killer WiFi card was faulty, but the technicians always ignored that piece of info.

I bought an Intel 8265 to replace the Killer WiFi card, and when I went to replace it, the antenna ball broke off of the Killer card and was stuck inside the little socket! There was a tiny flake of solder I was able to grab with my finest pliers and pull it out, allowing me to install the Intel card. After installing the Intel card EVERY SINGLE PROBLEM described earlier went away.

https://www.amazon.com/Intel-8265-Generic-2230-8265NGWMG/dp/...

$30 was all it would have taken to make the XPS 13 from a piece of garbage to an awesome laptop. I'm already paying $1000+, why not $1030+? But now, I will never buy another XPS again because it required 10+ hours of my time to troubleshoot and fix all by myself.

Post reply on HN