Live data from Hacker News

AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

variety.com

111–120 of 284 posts

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, the DOJ actually tried to stop this but was overruled by the courts.

To be fair, the DOJ's motives were completely tainted by Trump's hostility toward CNN.

Obviously, whatever Trump does is bad, whether busting monopolies or not busting monopolies.

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

To be fair, the DOJ actually tried to stop this but was overruled by the courts.

To be fair, the DOJ's motives were completely tainted by Trump's hostility toward CNN.

I get what you're saying, but that shouldn't matter in a sane world. This merger is bad news for the citizenry.

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#113
post #21

It’s crazy to me how one judge gets to decide the fate of a 100 billion dollar merger. Humans are fallible.

Well, the judge has to base the decision on a whole bunch of laws. It's not like judges get to decide this on their own.

In a perfect world, what you said would be how things are actually decided.

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#114
It's interesting that the Trump administration was eager to block this deal (Trump has made statements in favor of preventing this merger), while enthusiastically repealing net neutrality. Maybe expecting consistency here is reading too much into the tea leaves.

At the same time, AT&T stock is down in after hours trading. Does this mean that investors believe this merger will be bad for AT&T, or at least for short-term profits?

Maybe tomorrow's reaction will be different as the entire market will weigh in on the decision.

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#115
post #56
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can they appeal the case in higher courts?

The merger is set to close next Monday. DOJ can file for a stay, but the judge warned them that would be unwise. I think the DOJ will just take it as a loss.

> DOJ can file for a stay, but the judge warned them that would be unwise.

What would they have to lose?

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#116
post #89

> The judge indicated during the trial that he wasn’t buying Shapiro’s projection. After his testimony, Leon said he was "confused." Further explanation from Shapiro didn’t help. "I’m not sure I got it, but it’s too late and too hot to belabor the point any further," the judge said. Amazing on so many different levels. (Shapiro is the economist whose model the DOJ based their case off of).

Absolutely shameful. AI judges can't come soon enough.

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#117
post #68

The courts seem to be letting telecoms consolidate to a degree that is unprecedented (Bell, at least, had a fairly narrow scope), because they think the internet means these companies have competition. I think they're severely under-estimating the power these companies have and the risk that these mergers create to both consumers and our democracy.

That or they don't care. I'd be very interested to know what kind of positions the friends & families of these judges hold related to the mergers they approve.

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#118
post #9

>to lead the next generation in innovation. Meanwhile I have 300k internet in Pasadena, CA. That's the fastest they offer. My roommate doesn't care and won't upgrade to Spectrum. Why is it whenever I read the above it means the opposite?

They will increase your internet speed if that means they can sell you more entertainment now.

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#119
post #8

Yet more media consolidation. And this one has the inherent conflicts of interest you get when a distributor buys out a producer. And of course the idea of protecting the public interest isn't a thing anymore in DC.

> And this one has the inherent conflicts of interest you get when a distributor buys out a producer.

I'm not sure I understand the conflicts. Isn't Netflix essentially doing the same thing? Consolidating production and distribution?

Re: AT&T Cleared by Judge to Buy Time Warner

#120
post #21

It’s crazy to me how one judge gets to decide the fate of a 100 billion dollar merger. Humans are fallible.

Well, the judge has to base the decision on a whole bunch of laws. It's not like judges get to decide this on their own.

You may enjoy: "The Myth of the Rule of Law".

http://faculty.msb.edu/hasnasj/GTWebSite/MythWeb.htm

Post reply on HN