Live data from Hacker News

Ajit Pai says you’re going to love the death of net neutrality

arstechnica.com

11–20 of 77 posts

Re: Ajit Pai says you’re going to love the death of net neutrality

#12

Part of me really hopes the internet heads into the crapper within the next couple years. It's time for a reboot anyway, to clear the cruft.

Back in the old days, the internet was run by government agencies and universities. Universities invented the protocols. Companies provided only the hardware.

Nowadays, companies run the internet and own our data.

Let's go back to the old model. Let universities research federated protocols/algorithms and such. Let the government own the fiber. And let companies build the hardware.

Re: Ajit Pai says you’re going to love the death of net neutrality

#16

Part of me really hopes the internet heads into the crapper within the next couple years. It's time for a reboot anyway, to clear the cruft.

What makes you think anything better will emerge from the wreckage?

I don't know. However, I doubt anyone can come along at this point and beat FB, Amazon, Google, Apple and Microsoft, etc. without a major shakeup.

Re: Ajit Pai says you’re going to love the death of net neutrality

#17
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes you think anything better will emerge from the wreckage?

We were just talking about this same thing on /r/seo today. The search results are getting poorer and poorer and pbn’s are eating relevant search results.

What is a pbn?

Re: Ajit Pai says you’re going to love the death of net neutrality

#18
post #13
post #10

Anyone willing to consider that maybe he's right about this issue?

As a European: he’s right. You’ll love zero-rating. I do. :-)

As an European, I don't. How any sensible alternative to Facebook is supposed to out-compete it if Facebook is commonly zero-rated on mobile?

Re: Ajit Pai says you’re going to love the death of net neutrality

#19
There is a city here with a six lane freeway running right through the middle of many previous residential areas.. It might seem obvious that a six lane freeway produces constant noise, heavy particulate matter in the air all year, and a constant blanket of heavy matter downwind on every surface, the soil, your clothes, etc..

The benefit of this heavy motorway is that areas far from the city became the new (wealthy) suburbs and shopping malls.

It is a matter of record that some local politicians made speeches about how the new freeway would benefit the original city it runs through. I think they use the phrase "tortured truth" to express how these statements reflect what actually happened. I expect somewhat similar rise in fortunes, and drop in privileges, associated with the new "un-Net".

Re: Ajit Pai says you’re going to love the death of net neutrality

#20
> ISPs' required disclosures "will allow consumers to make an informed decision about which Internet service provider is best for them

The one that's best for me is literally the only one that's available in my area, so my informed decision is whether to have the internet or not.

Post reply on HN