Live data from Hacker News

Scrum disempowers developers

lambdacambridge.com

381–382 of 382 posts

Re: Scrum disempowers developers

#381

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, I agree; that's why I've always thought of it as an amplifier for management. If you have good management that buys in, then everyone is more productive. If you have crappy management that doesn't, then they're given a tool to amplify the micromanaging and dispiriting aspects of the job.

Man. ^ This is a brutal revelation right now. Totally just opened my eyes to exactly why things have been going badly at work, despite formal process.

Conway's Law deserves a management corollary.

Re: Scrum disempowers developers

#382
Robin, most of what you mentioned in your article are true and I agree with them. I had very similar situations (conversatons may end up with "alright, this is Product Owner’s call") and I understand most of developers get frustrated about this. I had been there and I was the developer who got frustrated, but I managed to change it (yep I also agree Scrum does not teach us how and we had to figure it out ourselves) by understanding PO, influencing them about what we proposed by describing value and making a plan for win-win. It is not a fun journey to be honest, but once you are there (we are not completely there yet) your team will trust each other and work more collaboratively. I am really happy to know I am not alone and I have so much to say and share, if you are interested in it, saw my experience at https://medium.com/@ericjwhuang/how-scrum-fails-and-what-you...
Post reply on HN