Live data from Hacker News

YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

techcrunch.com

41–50 of 61 posts

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#42
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

http://ytinstant.com/

Yeah, couldn't find the about page. Is it just an AJAX-based Youtube search autocomplete that pulls up the results and then makes am autoplaying playlist?

yeah, and google instant is just a google search that pulls up results as you type them.

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#43
post #39
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Facebook cannot because it happened in California, and California has strong protections. See http://law.justia.com/california/codes/2009/lab/2870-2872.ht... for details. I'm firmly of the belief that this is very good for Silicon Valley. How many people do you know who work at a job and a startup on the side? In California that generally won't get you in trouble. Elsewhere?

While I was working at IBM (in California), I tried to get clearance for one of my personal projects [1], the IBM lawyer had this to say: "No, according to California Labor Code 2870, even if you use your own time/equipment, your project still belongs to IBM if your project relates to IBM's business, or actual or demonstrably anticipated research or development. So if you think that your project is not close to anyth…

Note, this was IBM's lawyer talking, not your own. IBM's interests were represented there, not yours.

Lawyers are in the business of convincing people that the law says what they want it to say. However in the case of a dispute it doesn't matter what IBM's lawyer says, it matters what a judge thinks. So of course if you ask IBM's lawyers, they'll represent IBM's interests by making the broadest possible claims for what is IBM's. That doesn't make them right, nor does it mean that they would actually pursue it. But as long as they leave you convinced, they've accomplished their goal.

That said, they are correct that the statute gives them that way to claim your work. And the larger the company you're in, the broader that claim can become. And when you listen to their lawyers, the claim will become broader still. Putting that all together, I wouldn't take their word for anything without consulting your own lawyer who represents your interests.

Alternately, if it is important to you, you always have the option of telling your manager that this issue is important to you, and you're willing to leave your job if that is what is needed so you can work on your own project. In that situation it is amazing what miracles can happen once it is made clear to the lawyers that giving you the freedom you want is actually in IBM's interest. (Advice from lawyers is very frequently penny wise and pound foolish. The smarter the business, the more strongly they realize that.)

Depending on the current job market at the time, it may be advisable to line up another job option before attempting such drastic action.

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#45

just playing devil's advocate here, but why is slapping together an API with some javascript worthy of a job offer? what's so exciting about YT instant? from hurley's twitter message, it sounds like he asked this kid to drop out of stanford to join youtube, which sounds a little crazy. maybe I just have no imagination. (congrats to the kid in any case)

The kid's innovative and imaginative, can clearly build and design product quickly, and has a Facebook and Stanford pedigree. That sounds like a winner to me.

Also, by encouraging him to drop out of Stanford, they obtain an employee with a somewhat lower market value if he ever feels like leaving youtube.

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#46

just playing devil's advocate here, but why is slapping together an API with some javascript worthy of a job offer? what's so exciting about YT instant? from hurley's twitter message, it sounds like he asked this kid to drop out of stanford to join youtube, which sounds a little crazy. maybe I just have no imagination. (congrats to the kid in any case)

2nd Sentence from the Article: "Aboukhadijeh will continue to attend Stanford while he works at the company."

He get's a job YouTube while finishing his education at Stanford. Sounds like a good deal. I don't see the downside.

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

woah... and I always thought Google was THE place to be.

I am amazed he left Facebook.

Why not? Surely a combination of Google and Facebook experience is more valuable than an equal amount of experience at just one or the other.

I can see how you'd choose FB over Google coming in from the outside but if you get the chance to work with both it seems like a smart choice.

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#48

"Interestingly enough, the ambitious Aboukhadijeh was a software engineer intern at Facebook when he created Youtube Instant." Hm, I was under the impression Facebook didn't allow side projects. I suppose this doesn't apply to interns?

Facebook doesn't have a 20%-time /program/. That doesn't mean people don't have side-projects on their own time, or even multiple things they're doing at work. Plus they have regular hackathons which sometimes develop into full projects.

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#49

just playing devil's advocate here, but why is slapping together an API with some javascript worthy of a job offer? what's so exciting about YT instant? from hurley's twitter message, it sounds like he asked this kid to drop out of stanford to join youtube, which sounds a little crazy. maybe I just have no imagination. (congrats to the kid in any case)

>but why is slapping together an API with some javascript worthy of a job offer?

I was equally leery for the same reason. I've made tons of apps that bound events and pulled/updated data from cache layers I had setup.

Apparently I didn't have the good sense to be a shameless self-promoter.

This is frankly exemplary of the one thing I don't like about HN, even though I dearly love the community here.

The emphasis on typical business values, rather than on true productivity and hard work agonizes my conscience on a regular basis.

It makes me nauseous to think he got such publicity and a job offer for that.

I hate to be sour about it, but damn.

S'like hiring a B-school kid because he completed a rudimentary business plan, rendered it into PDF, and put it online and it happened to go viral for some absurd reason.

Re: YouTube Instant Creator Accepts Job At YouTube

#50
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, couldn't find the about page. Is it just an AJAX-based Youtube search autocomplete that pulls up the results and then makes am autoplaying playlist?

yeah, and google instant is just a google search that pulls up results as you type them.

Are you trying to get a rise out of me, sir?
Post reply on HN