Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft acquires Github

blogs.microsoft.com

481–490 of 840 posts

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#481

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The idea is that stuff like issues and PR comments (the added value a social coding site like GitHub provides) are the extend around pure git source management.

Fair point, but none of that is Microsoft's doing. Why are we only talking about this now?

Because Github wouldn't have been able to do the extinguish phase. Microsoft can, and will.

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#483

People keep mentioning how "Microsoft changed" due to VS Code, the Linux subsystem, .NET Core. I say that they are the same company, only with different cash cows. Haven't they spied on Windows 10 users? Do they not engage in patents racketeering? Haven't they killed Nokia and ruined Skype? " But Mom, some of the other companies are doing it too ", well yeah, but some of us don't have double standards, in spite of wh…

Proprietary software used to be Microsoft's cash cow. That it is turning to different cash cows is actually a good thing for open source.

Companies have to make money, and originally, Microsoft made money just by selling proprietary software licenses. In these conditions, open source is their enemy, and they have to fight it. Now they do a bit of spying, a bit of cloud, a bit of hardware, etc... which mean they can cut open source some slack and focus on other evils.

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#484
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nokia was struggling long before Microsoft came along though. They saved it for a little bit, but there isn't much you can do with a company that got so far behind it's competitors. Samsung, HTC, Apple, Motorola, etc were all light years ahead of Nokia even before Microsoft got involved. Funny that the things you mention all happened under Steve Ballmer too...

Ahead in what sense? Apart from Apple and Google, everyone was behind. The fact that HTC and Motorola adopted Android didn't do much good for them in the end, and in hardware and market share Nokia still had the lead at that time.

>>Ahead in what sense?

Refusing to move on to Android?

There was no real chance Symbian had in the post iPhone world.

Nokia forgot its USP, which was basically durable rugged hardware. Instead they tried to compete with the iPhone in the software department, it didn't work out too well.

Motorola is doing quite good with Android.

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#485
I don't understand why everyone is so against this, this means Github is going to become more useful and tools will be extended. Microsoft knows developers better than many of the other companies. Perhaps it would have made more sense to be a joint venture company between Google/Microsoft/Apple/Linux Foundation? I don't know? I think this is the second best alternative to that.

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#486

People keep mentioning how "Microsoft changed" due to VS Code, the Linux subsystem, .NET Core. I say that they are the same company, only with different cash cows. Haven't they spied on Windows 10 users? Do they not engage in patents racketeering? Haven't they killed Nokia and ruined Skype? " But Mom, some of the other companies are doing it too ", well yeah, but some of us don't have double standards, in spite of wh…

These are giant companies with 1000s of employees and more politics than small countries... it doesn’t work to just generalize it all together. The developer side of Microsoft has definitely changed for the better over the last several years. And even if github fails, so what? It’s the most easily replaceable part of the stack.

You haven’t been using GitHub for open source then.

The best part of GitHub is the social part and that’s not currently replaceable. Also good luck migrating issues and their history of comments and PRs.

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#487
Microsoft the cash cow, please milk in your own yard and stop messing up with FOSS land, you have been evil, and that's hard to change, just leave FOSS alone.

You lost the OS war, from cloud to the phone, just get over with it.

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#488

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Haven't they spied on Windows 10 users? How is it spying when they present you with a full screen detailing data collection with the option to turn it off, and have several blog posts providing details. > Do they not engage in patents racketeering? It's not much of an excuse, but all tech companies do this. > Haven't they killed Nokia and ruined Skype? Didn't they give Windows Mobile one hell of a run? Like they tr…

You actually can’t turn it off, and they still refuse to publish the complete list of what is collected. You need an enterprise version to disable as much as they will let you, and even then, they still force quite a bit of collection.

>> they still refuse to publish the complete list of what is collected

Seems like refusing to disclose what is collected would run afoul of GDPR. The law requires that "categories of personal data" be disclosed, and also that Microsoft's European customers have a right to a copy of their personal data. Are you claiming that Microsoft is not or does not intend to comply with GDPR? Or perhaps there is some other qualification implied; such as this only applies to non-European customers? If so what is your basis?

Re: Microsoft acquires Github

#489

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Haven't they spied on Windows 10 users? How is it spying when they present you with a full screen detailing data collection with the option to turn it off, and have several blog posts providing details. > Do they not engage in patents racketeering? It's not much of an excuse, but all tech companies do this. > Haven't they killed Nokia and ruined Skype? Didn't they give Windows Mobile one hell of a run? Like they tr…

>> And Skype, I don't know. I use it in a daily basis. It doesn't seem to be that bad. Likewise. I know they neglected the Linux client (which I used to use) for years and then replaced it with some new browser based thing. This 'ruined Skype' claim has been made several times with each Microsoft buys GitHub story. What exactly do people have in mind when they claim Skype was ruined?

People have fuzzy memories, and think Skype was a gold standard before Microsoft bought it...which is far from the truth.
Post reply on HN