Live data from Hacker News

What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

jacquesmattheij.com

191–200 of 228 posts

Re: What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

#191

I myself am optimistic but some few questrions popped up: Microsoft is very proactive removing things from azure and shutting down sites as soon as they receive DMCA complaint or abuse complaint. Are they going to remove important github repos like these if they get DMCA or other complaints? https://github.com/Roy47Zhang/CSGO-Aimbot-Project (cheat for Counter strike) https://github.com/rg3/youtube-dl (download from v…

Keep an eye on this one, then:

https://github.com/Wind4/vlmcsd

Re: What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

#192
post #83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Like iOS yes, and some, but not all, Android manufacturers/phones. "Others do it too" is not a very good justification in my mind.

"Others do it too" is not a good justification of course. But his comment also fails to to explain how Microsoft is somehow more evil than the industry standard.

Bootloader lockdown was practically unheard of for the PC/laptop form factor before Microsoft started doing it for ARM laptops. And and it's not even really standard for phones. Plenty of Android phones have unlockable bootloaders (see LineageOS).

I don't think whether one is more evil than Apple/iOS in this regard is a good benchmark.

Re: What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I knew that to be the end-game and if I knew it to be an informed choice on the part of consumers, yes, I'd be OK with that. My two reservations: 1. I think such a lockdown is a kind of hidden anti-competitive "dark pattern" that benefits the seller much more than it benefits the consumer by significantly lowering the the reuse/resale value of the device. One could argue it makes the device cheaper to begin with,…

I see a benefit to lockdown, which is improved safety/security for non-technical end users. Security is a difficult topic, even for IT professionals, and it is easier to secure a locked down environment for non-technical users than an open one. If you look at mobile platforms as an example, the prevalence of malware on Android compared to iOS is significant. Now for many I'm sure that trade-off is worth it, but I als…

If a significant number of Android security breaches indeed happen through misleading a user into unlocking their bootloader, that would be a convincing statistic to me.

But I'm under the impression that that is exceedingly rare and that Android has many way more pressing security concerns (e.g. the lack of driver security updates to even slightly old devices).

Re: What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

#194
How much Microsoft loves open source is also proofed by the case of MeeGo. Their agent, a certain Mr. Elop, hugged it to death.

> The first MeeGo device came out in 2011 and won all kinds of awards and is to this date the only flagship consistently ranked better than its contemporary iPhone, while MeeGo is the only OS ever launched in smartphones to be ranked as good as - or in some reviews even better than - Apple's iPhone iOS operating system. THAT was Nokia's strategy in January 2011. Only a delusional idiot would change this.

http://communities-dominate.blogs.com/brands/2016/05/the-nok...

Re: What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

#195
Microsoft’s brute force approache has never worked and will never work. It really doesn’t matter who heads it. As indicate by RMS, and proven time and again, these ethical questions at the heart of the free software movement are important and there for a reason. You can slap “open source” on anything these days, and it has been the case for a while, but it’s missing the point. And dangerous for the free software movement.

Re: What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

#196
post #106

Microsoft is not a company that ever contributed my life as a Linux user and open source contributor for years. In fact, it always made life harder for me. Here is a recent example; because Microsoft made a deal with Lenovo, now new Thinkpads are designed for just Windows. If you're a Linux user, good luck in your new adventure. People say "isn't it like IOS or Android?"; it's not. We had this freedom of using Linux,…

Linux runs on my ThinkPad just fine.

It runs on mine ok as well, but the fingerprint scanner doesn't work

Re: What is wrong with Microsoft buying GitHub

#197

I agree with this article on the basis that if Microsoft's incentives haven't changed, then there's no reason Microsoft should be expected to behave any differently to the nineties. Arguing that they're a different company I think should require arguments that their incentives are different, and I don't see that they are.

I think for them today selling Azure is a bigger incentive than selling Windows and Office.

Let me clarify: Selling Azure is absolutely a bigger incentive than selling Windows and Office. And more generally, selling solutions instead of technology.

Their #1 competitor is AWS. They don't even mention Oracle, Apple, or really even Google.

Post reply on HN