Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

bloomberg.com

71–80 of 362 posts

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#71
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are plenty of older college students. There were lots of grey hairs in my night classes.

Not in the places where top tech companies are willing to go to.

I don't think this is true -- most of the Ivys have entire schools dedicated to older 'nontraditional' students (see, for example, the Columbia University School of General Studies), and Google/Facebook/etc recruit quite heavily from the Ivys.

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#72

As a 53-year-old Facebook employee, I find the part about Facebook doing this for their own hiring a bit odd. To the extent that anyone has ever reacted to my age with anything other than mild surprise, people generally seem quite glad to see something besides another fresh 20-something face and to hear the voice of long experience. Then again, I didn't come in via a Facebook ad. Maybe companies use different methods…

The facebook CEO is very famous for his quote by the way. https://www.cnet.com/news/say-what-young-people-are-just-sma...

He'll get around. He's still young. Let's see what tune he sings when he's 45-50.

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#73
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Become an expert on the Cobol/PL1 of 2050, maybe?

> Cobol/PL1 of 2050 It's already here and it's called Java :)

Cobol is the new Cobol

https://increment.com/programming-languages/cobol-all-the-wa...

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#74

As a 53-year-old Facebook employee, I find the part about Facebook doing this for their own hiring a bit odd. To the extent that anyone has ever reacted to my age with anything other than mild surprise, people generally seem quite glad to see something besides another fresh 20-something face and to hear the voice of long experience. Then again, I didn't come in via a Facebook ad. Maybe companies use different methods…

The facebook CEO is very famous for his quote by the way. https://www.cnet.com/news/say-what-young-people-are-just-sma...

Yeah, Zuck was a jerk in 2007. I suspect even he would admit that. To be fair, though, I was an even bigger jerk at that age and still am.

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not saying you're this person, but a lot of people making this claim are also the people that seem argue with literally everything. They always claim they know better. "Oh your team of 8 has spent the last 12 months building this complex webapp with React? Gosh darn millennial hipsters and their FRAMEWORKS. I could have built it with jQuery in a week, and still had a nickel leftover for the trolley!" Yes I've exa…

This is such a big hyperbole that I'm just gonna call bullshit on this.

No hyperbole. Seriously, I was as shocked as you are. It was a very humiliating experience.

A few interesting things that I’ve experienced:

- Companies tend to like me enough that they keep asking me back to “meet more people” - a very time-wasting process that often ends with silence (and no returned emails or calls)

- When rejected from a particularly interesting company, I will sometimes offer to work for free or a discounted rate initially, just so I can prove what I can do. No one has ever taken that offer.

- I have even offered to work at a very discounted salary, on par with a new grad salary. My rational is that I’ll still make more than I would at Whole Foods, and I’m confident that they’ll be impressed enough to bump me to my normal salary. No takers. Although one company did say that by hiring me, I would “cause more harm than good”. WTF?

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#76

I know almost nothing about the law here, but I imagine intent could be a big part of it. I'm surprised the Bloomberg article seems to make no mention of it. I was also surprised to see this: > Goldman wrote that, “Used responsibly, age-based targeting for employment purposes is an accepted industry practice and for good reason: it helps employers recruit and people of all ages find work.” Why would it ever be accept…

What if they were targeting older workers as part of a diversity program?

That is discrimination against younger workers.

Diversity programs are a double edged sword, there are groups that are under represented. However every time you target them you lose the larger group that you didn't target, and that group has great people.

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#77

As a 53-year-old Facebook employee, I find the part about Facebook doing this for their own hiring a bit odd. To the extent that anyone has ever reacted to my age with anything other than mild surprise, people generally seem quite glad to see something besides another fresh 20-something face and to hear the voice of long experience. Then again, I didn't come in via a Facebook ad. Maybe companies use different methods…

I don't know. I was recommended to a specific domain-specialized role in Facebook by someone with a long tenure inside the company, and after the recommendation, I was just auto-routed into the standard, crappy candidate pipeline like everyone else, told I'd have to do whatever 6-month rotation bootcamp, asked why I didn't have a bunch of Javascript experience. It certainly felt like they make an effort to pedantical…

> exactly to enforce various uniformity and policy standards.

Wouldn't that be the exact opposite of the "disparate treatment" the lawsuit alleges?

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think I get your point. Are you implying that trashtalking hip design trends is grounds for age discrimination? Or that older employees give an amount of pushback on design decisions that makes them literally unhirable? I can trashtalk the design on everything I've directly worked on more accurately and damningly than things I read about online that seem like bad ideas. And I do. Do you think because I find f…

The fact that everyone who's offended by the post is claiming that React is a "hip design trend" kind of reinforces the point, doesn't it?

No, I'm under 30 and React is probably a hip design trend, just like Angular and Bootstrap were. Perspective is valuable.

People are offended because the post you're replying to literally only said, "I've gotten less job offers since I turned 40."

Your response was, "well, that's probably your fault."

To rephrase one of your earlier comments, "I'm really not saying you're ageist. I'm just saying I've experienced a non-trivial amount of victim blaming that looks like this, and it's a possibility worth considering if you want other people to take you seriously."

Re: Facebook Tools Are Used to Screen Out Older Job Seekers, Lawsuit Claims

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Age discrimination in tech is dumb. I've got a dev 30 years my senior sitting across from me and I guarantee he will code circles around 90% of the devs on HN, and 100% of the new grads getting jobs at big tech (and will until he dies). He's got a huge amount of knowledge in programming, our domain (NLP), he's fast, thorough, and thoughtful. Honestly I don't get the obsession with recent grads. They are basically use…

Some of reasons I’ve seen for ageism in startups are cost and “not a culture fit”. Cost I understand, but I believe more experienced people end up being cheaper in the long run when you account for speed, correctness, and long term maintainability. The culture piece stems from the “would I get a beer with this person” and will he/she work as “hard” as a younger candidate with less responsibilities. Startups need to s…

> when you account for speed, correctness, and long term maintainability

And insight gained from a world of experience that a junior or intermediate devs doesn't have.

Post reply on HN