Live data from Hacker News

Free Music Archive

freemusicarchive.org

11–20 of 32 posts

Re: Free Music Archive

#11
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

While true in general, public radio has quite a quantity of paid-third-party-ads these days. And they don't just say "supported by [corporation, tag line]", they are full ads, just read by the public radio hosts. There's one radio station group that has consistently been fully public interest with neither ads nor corporate nor government conflicts-of-interest: the Pacifica network which has affiliates around the coun…

Thanks for the link. WFMU also runs no ads and has no corporate sponsors. "WFMU’s primary source of support comes from listener contributions made during our annual on-air fundraising marathonand revenue generated from our annual Record Fair. WFMU does not accept underwriting or corporate sponsorships. We receive some support from foundations and government grants, as long as they do not contain conditions that deter…

I remember listening to WFMU's station manager recount one of the times he had to fire a (volunteer) DJ: the DJ was selling ad time on his show. He got away with it for a while because his show was not in English.

It seems that ads were also a motivation for the long-running show JM in the AM to leave the station.

> WFMU, licensed as a non-profit radio station, adheres to the guidelines of charitable and non-commercial radio. With the move of ‘JM in the AM’ exclusively to NSN, the program, its host, its content and its reach will be allowed greater creative flexibility and sponsorship opportunities. [1]

[1] http://www.nachumsegal.com/historic-jm-announcement-made-mor...

Re: Free Music Archive

#12
post #10

It should try to use Flac / Opus, not mp3.

Flac/Opus may have benefits, but I think the Free Music Archive is optimizing for accessibility. Pretty much anybody can play an MP3 out of the box. I don't think one can say the same about Flac/Opus.

Re: Free Music Archive

#13
post #2

The listener-funded radio station that runs the archive, WFMU, is the single greatest radio station in the world.

just discovered it this year; cannot believe i went this long without knowing about it.

also the web 1.5ish site and comments board brings me a lot of joy, reminds me of the spirit of the earlier web, in keeping with the free form nature of the programming itself.

everyone should donate if you listen!

Re: Free Music Archive

#15
post #2

The listener-funded radio station that runs the archive, WFMU, is the single greatest radio station in the world.

I'll make a separate plug for KFJC, a radio station in the bay area. All the DJs have totally unique taste and the station is really good if you're into experimental or electronic music.

My personal favorite radio station, and their donation t shirts are awesome.

Re: Free Music Archive

#16
post #10

It should try to use Flac / Opus, not mp3.

Can my web browser play FLAC or Opus out of the box? Mind, I'm not going to tell you what my web browser is. Because that's why they picked MP3: if you're using MP3 you can confidently say "yes" because it's a computer in 2018.

Re: Free Music Archive

#17
post #16
post #10

It should try to use Flac / Opus, not mp3.

Can my web browser play FLAC or Opus out of the box? Mind, I'm not going to tell you what my web browser is. Because that's why they picked MP3: if you're using MP3 you can confidently say "yes" because it's a computer in 2018 .

> Can my web browser play FLAC or Opus out of the box?

Flac isn't really for browser playback, but for lossless backup. Normal browsers should play Opus fine today. Some crippled ones might not, but for that there are projects like this as fallback:

https://github.com/brion/ogv.js/

So I see no reason not to use Flac and Opus for music services.

Re: Free Music Archive

#18
They seem to kind of hide the licenses for each individual track, which is odd since the licensing is the site's USP. Does seem like a great curated archive of fine music, though.

Re: Free Music Archive

#19
post #17
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can my web browser play FLAC or Opus out of the box? Mind, I'm not going to tell you what my web browser is. Because that's why they picked MP3: if you're using MP3 you can confidently say "yes" because it's a computer in 2018 .

> Can my web browser play FLAC or Opus out of the box? Flac isn't really for browser playback, but for lossless backup. Normal browsers should play Opus fine today. Some crippled ones might not, but for that there are projects like this as fallback: https://github.com/brion/ogv.js/ So I see no reason not to use Flac and Opus for music services.

You just said Flac is for lossless backup. Losslessback is not equal to the user experience.

Kind of selfish of you to think Flac should be a standard where some people wouldn't even know what it is.

Re: Free Music Archive

#20
post #18

They seem to kind of hide the licenses for each individual track, which is odd since the licensing is the site's USP. Does seem like a great curated archive of fine music, though.

The search page is slightly obscure (though semantically obvious): http://freemusicarchive.org/search It allows to search by license criteria, for example use in commercial derivative works.
Post reply on HN