Live data from Hacker News

Censorship of the Internet Takes Center Stage in "Online Infringement" Bill

eff.org

1–10 of 21 posts

Re: Censorship of the Internet Takes Center Stage in "Online Infringement" Bill

#7
post #2

The EFF's description of this makes it sound functionally equivalent to the Chinese system. This seems like a very bad idea especially because it would legitimize internet censorship globally. Am I missing something?

If by "legitimize internet censorship globally" you mean the US would set an example of censorship for other countries to follow, I guess that makes sense. Remember, Hillary Clinton took Google's side in criticizing China's internet censorship. China will go into full US-bashing mode when this bill gets passed, not to mention all those blackberry-censoring countries. I'm glad I live in neither country, but my government loves to follow the US's example so I'm concerned. Time to start routing my traffic through Sweden!

Re: Censorship of the Internet Takes Center Stage in "Online Infringement" Bill

#8

DNS is long overdue for a replacement anyway.

So HN downvoters prefer the current centralized model of Internet name services which are vulnerable to a denial of service attack from technologically illiterate politicians?

I just don't understand the world anymore.

Takes all kinds I tell you.

Re: Censorship of the Internet Takes Center Stage in "Online Infringement" Bill

#9

DNS is long overdue for a replacement anyway.

So HN downvoters prefer the current centralized model of Internet name services which are vulnerable to a denial of service attack from technologically illiterate politicians? I just don't understand the world anymore. Takes all kinds I tell you.

They're downvoting you because you're not only missing the point of the article with your first comment, but because allowing this to happen would make DNS even less likely to be replaced any time soon. Once the government is involved in attempting to control the flow of traffic to different websites, any backbone essential to their method of control will stagnate and remain in place almost indefinitely. These people still use IE6 out of misplaced fears for security and a general laziness when it comes to updating, remember?

Re: Censorship of the Internet Takes Center Stage in "Online Infringement" Bill

#10

Become a member here! https://secure.eff.org/site/Donation2?idb=1197241400&df_... $5/month. You can afford it! ;)

If you're willing to become a member, you might as well take the extra step and contact your congressmen (https://writerep.house.gov/writerep/welcome.shtml) and senator (http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_c...) as well.
Post reply on HN