Live data from Hacker News

Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

getstream.io

41–50 of 303 posts

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#41
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Any recommendations for cross-platform, light RSS readers? PDF export would be _great_, but not necessary

Tiny tiny rss, all the way, you have great web based desktop ui and good mobile apps

Yes, agree, this is my choice of reader too.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#42
Is there an app/service that does the following?:

* Has a feed a la RSS readers

* Allows items on that feed (from all the sources) to be earmarked

* At the end of reviewing the unread items of the feed, summarise a 'checkout' of earmarked items

* Sends a payment to each of the publications for the content earmarked

* Compiles the content into a consumable format such as kindle, PDF or download for mobile

I can only think of instapaper/pocket type services that don't allow for payment, or for browsers like Brave that use blockchainy things that seem new and scary. Or are just RSS readers.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#43
post #11

Why is this a downloadable app instead of a web app? It's built entirely using web technology. I think RSS belongs in my browser, so I can easily access it from whatever computer I might be using.

This is a great point; however, we wanted to bring the user experience to the desktop. You are more than welcome to submit a PR to make this application web compatible.

Why do you require users to make an account? I personally would rather have all my settings stored locally, and export them if I needed to. An option for this would be great.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#44
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, 3 downvotes in 60 seconds. Totally not brigading here.

Your comment broke the HN guidelines, so it was properly downvoted. This one too. Could you please (re-)read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and post civilly and substantively, or not at all? We're hoping for something a bit better here.

Well yeah, ofcourse. I dont see where my inital post broke anything.

It was esentially as meaningfull as OPs reply.

Ofcourse, the point of "this app should run in a browser" is very valid. The reply, he can just code it himself is in my eyes a passive aggressive way of saying "no, i said your point is valid, but actually think it isn't and therefore ill ignore it anyway."

Its obvioulsy, that a well developed web app should be runable in a browser and the developers could have thought about it earlier. They know their project better than anyone, so the afford of understanding how this piece of software works for an outsider is way to high.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#45

It won't ever come back because there's no monetary incentive for people to share content. Just the opposite in fact.

I've never used an RSS reader so correct me if I'm wrong, but RSS can basically allow you to read the content without advertising? Sharing is fine, but I think they would prefer sharing in a way that can make money.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#46
post #21

> I love using RSS to follow the programming and tech news I care about. Unfortunately, the number of sites supporting RSS has been in rapid decline over the last few years. The reader ecosystem is slowly degrading as well. After that introduction I was hoping Winds would be some kind of proxy that creates an RSS for sites that don't have one. But well, it's just another RSS reader. Those have actually never gone way…

For reasons I don't understand, it remains incredibly difficult to scrape a well-organized blog and turn it into something I can consume like RSS or a kindle book. Note that many/most WordPress RSS feeds aren't that useful because they only show a snippet rather than the entire post. This dreary state of affairs is due in part to the fact that "checking" an RSS just means downloading the entire file containing all po…

Is the problem really that RSS needs replacement, or can it simply be improved. I think there is quite a bit of room for extension to address some of the concerns that are expressed here too, including accurate meta tagging for educational resource discovery purposes.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#47
post #39
post #21

> I love using RSS to follow the programming and tech news I care about. Unfortunately, the number of sites supporting RSS has been in rapid decline over the last few years. The reader ecosystem is slowly degrading as well. After that introduction I was hoping Winds would be some kind of proxy that creates an RSS for sites that don't have one. But well, it's just another RSS reader. Those have actually never gone way…

There are a few of those: http://www.feedsapi.com/ and http://createfeed.fivefilters.org/

If I may add mine: https://www.pipes.digital/. It allows creating feeds for sites if the site is structured enough, and the feed can then manipulated with other blocks, similar to how Yahoo Pipes worked.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#48
post #21

> I love using RSS to follow the programming and tech news I care about. Unfortunately, the number of sites supporting RSS has been in rapid decline over the last few years. The reader ecosystem is slowly degrading as well. After that introduction I was hoping Winds would be some kind of proxy that creates an RSS for sites that don't have one. But well, it's just another RSS reader. Those have actually never gone way…

For reasons I don't understand, it remains incredibly difficult to scrape a well-organized blog and turn it into something I can consume like RSS or a kindle book. Note that many/most WordPress RSS feeds aren't that useful because they only show a snippet rather than the entire post. This dreary state of affairs is due in part to the fact that "checking" an RSS just means downloading the entire file containing all po…

Sortof, if you are reading via a web based reader, the service itself only reads the feed once, and the users view the cached version.

Re: Winds 2.0: It’s Time to Revive RSS

#50
post #40
post #21

> I love using RSS to follow the programming and tech news I care about. Unfortunately, the number of sites supporting RSS has been in rapid decline over the last few years. The reader ecosystem is slowly degrading as well. After that introduction I was hoping Winds would be some kind of proxy that creates an RSS for sites that don't have one. But well, it's just another RSS reader. Those have actually never gone way…

I was hoping for the same. Still see no answer on how this does anything to support their claim that "It’s time to turn the tide"

Marketing is a powerful force. It's true that RSS has existed for many years, but also consider how many people have grown up without learning about it.
Post reply on HN