Live data from Hacker News

$11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

adsensepublishersettlement.com

11–20 of 137 posts

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#11

I get the "We think your business is a scam and so we are terminating our relationship" but I don't understand why "... and we'll keep the money." doesn't result in criminal charges.

My business lost around $90k for a perfectly legitimate website that actually did amazing CTR too.

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#12
This was years ago for me, but as bad as it is losing the amount earned, it was just the lack of response when trying to understand why you were terminated. I had no idea why I was banned. I didn't employ any shady tricks. The only thing I noticed in the few weeks prior to the account banned was a higher CTR.

I actually emailed Adsense support at that time to let them know that it was out of the ordinary for my site.

Additionally, I also had an account on the CPA affiliate side of things with the same account that was banned because it was tied with the Adsense email account.

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#13

I get the "We think your business is a scam and so we are terminating our relationship" but I don't understand why "... and we'll keep the money." doesn't result in criminal charges.

All ad networks take money away from publishers all of the time. For example, it takes a while to compute the quality score of ad clicks and realize that a site's traffic is full of bots that click on ads and never buy anything. The publisher will see income that gets subtracted back out, sometimes a month or two later. The advertiser (presumably) gets a refund.

It appears that Google did something different this time, I don't know what.

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#14

I get the "We think your business is a scam and so we are terminating our relationship" but I don't understand why "... and we'll keep the money." doesn't result in criminal charges.

All ad networks take money away from publishers all of the time. For example, it takes a while to compute the quality score of ad clicks and realize that a site's traffic is full of bots that click on ads and never buy anything. The publisher will see income that gets subtracted back out, sometimes a month or two later. The advertiser (presumably) gets a refund. It appears that Google did something different this tim…

Maybe they didn't return the money back to customers.

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#15
post #10

I've had friends that have lost $100k+ due to Adsense terminations on legitimate sites. I've personally lost about $10k. We'll see how much I actually get paid out from this class action (I think I read that they cap it at $5k)

Yes: "... Payments to each of the Class Representatives, not to exceed $5,000 each, as compensation for their active participation in the case on behalf of the Settlement Class ..."

EDIT: see below for correction

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#17

I get the "We think your business is a scam and so we are terminating our relationship" but I don't understand why "... and we'll keep the money." doesn't result in criminal charges.

Coinhive works that way as well. I believe it is justified to call both a scam by themselves. Why? Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat (innocent until proven guilty).

The problem lies with our justice system though. If it were more efficient we'd have less things like self-censorship and self-moderation.

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#18
This one still stings, even though it was years ago. I built and ran a mobile sports news application, we amassed millions of users and were written up in several publications.

One day our AdSense account was disabled, no warning, no nothing. We had never resorted to a single 'trick' or 'hack'. Nobody at Google could even tell us what exactly we were supposedly accused of.

After months of escalation, the final word was "we cannot tell you what you have allegedly done, we will not re-instate your account, you may not appeal any further".

Re: $11M settlement reached with Google regarding terminated AdSense accounts

#19

I worked in advertising and I saw how scared AdSense publishers constantly were of getting banned by Google. I understand that Google has to defend their business, but some times they were really harsh on things that were debatable grey areas. I always thought that Google was just needlessly giving itself a bad reputation as a business partner. $11M is about 1 hr of Google's revenue (365 x 24 x 11/100000 = 0.96) EDIT…

Hi, could you reference me to your edit article? Would love to read it!
Post reply on HN