Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

techcrunch.com

21–30 of 100 posts

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#21

Unless FB are considering making it impossible for others to access it's API, building a phone seems like a better deal for Facebook than it does for it's users.

It's the twitter problem all over again; they want their data and network/platform to be ubiquitous but while reaping all the eyeball revenue from being the frontend of choice and making every other client second-class.

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#22
post #15

I don't understand where they're coming from. Android's Facebook integration is a little rough, but all the problems are with the Facebook application. When it comes to the article's touted benefits of deep integration in the OS - calling a friend, deep syncing contacts, etc, Android does it all already. I have it set to only sync contacts that are already in my phone, but if a friend texts me who has their number on…

They're thinking about revenue growth, not user happiness. Obviously they could just roll their own interface/dialer/contact list/etc for android if they wanted to just make a "fully integrated" experience.

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#23
post #18

Awesome. Microsoft does search, Google does mobile OS, Apple does social networks, now Facebook does phones. Its an all out tech war.

This is what happens when you staff a company with brilliant "generalist" engineers.

Heed the warning folks, hire specialists or your startup will be making phones before you know it!

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#25
post #7

> Or rather, they’re building the software for the phone and working with a third party to actually build the hardware. Which is exactly what Apple and everyone else does, too. What? Apples and oranges. Apple designed the hardware, they're a hardware company. What TechCrunch?

But they outsource the actual manufacturing to FoxConn.

Right, like everyone else.

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#26
Mobile-device-as-a-service? Why not, half-billion users is enough to try.

Like a Kindle just for one kind of activity - reading, it could something like an iPad with only one big app.

Seems line the history repeats itself and we're heading back to the future from an era of general web sites in a universal browser to a closed world of connected devices. ^_^

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#27
I finally opened a Facebook account years ago when I became convinced they kept private info private, now they are making private info public by default, and I no longer trust them. I certainly won't be buying a phone from them.

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#28
post #7

> Or rather, they’re building the software for the phone and working with a third party to actually build the hardware. Which is exactly what Apple and everyone else does, too. What? Apples and oranges. Apple designed the hardware, they're a hardware company. What TechCrunch?

Bless techcrunch's heart, they do not understand the difference between outsourcing design and manufacturing, that is what happened to the crunchpad!

Re: Facebook Is Secretly Building A Phone

#30

The thing is, everyone I know uses Facebook the website but hates Facebook the company. I don't see the Facebook brand selling phones (I recall they rated on the bottom of brands in some study).

People hate everything. The big banks and airlines all rate at the bottom of customer satisfaction surveys, and yet they're big because everyone does a lot of business with them. People complain, but they don't change who they do business with.

I think a Facebook phone will be massively successful on name alone.

Post reply on HN