Live data from Hacker News

Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?

nytimes.com

1–10 of 73 posts

Re: Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?

#6
Actual title: "Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?"

To further quote the article: “My personal opinion is that exercise is probably much more important” than mental stimulation for altering brains and gene expression and potentially even the aptitudes of one’s offspring, Dr. Fischer says.

If the author of the article specifically phrased it as a question, let's not jump to making a definitive statement by changing the title.

Re: Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?

#7
post #6

Actual title: "Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?" To further quote the article: “My personal opinion is that exercise is probably much more important” than mental stimulation for altering brains and gene expression and potentially even the aptitudes of one’s offspring, Dr. Fischer says. If the author of the article specifically phrased it as a question, let's not jump to making a definitive statement by ch…

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...

Re: Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?

#9
post #6

Actual title: "Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?" To further quote the article: “My personal opinion is that exercise is probably much more important” than mental stimulation for altering brains and gene expression and potentially even the aptitudes of one’s offspring, Dr. Fischer says. If the author of the article specifically phrased it as a question, let's not jump to making a definitive statement by ch…

I used the title from the NY Times homepage, which at the time of submission had the more definitive version of the title.

Re: Do Fathers Who Exercise Have Smarter Babies?

#10
Correlation implied as causation.

Here is another correlation into causation article linking cardiovascular fitness to IQ[0]

Another way to look at it can be from the per-capita relation of economic class to fitness[1]. It is entirely possible that, because people higher up the economic ladder are more likely to be fit, and because they are more likely to receive better prenatal care, generally have better nutrition, and give their children more educational opportunities, that the actual cause may be economic status.

[0] https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/quilted-science/2009...

[1] https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/06/10/the-correla...

Post reply on HN