Live data from Hacker News

Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

neflabs.com

21–30 of 358 posts

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#21
I'm surprised how often RSS is mentioned on Hackernews, and how infrequently some recommends Feedly. It has wonderful features, like saving articles, collection boards, team features, and popularity-based sorting options.

(Full disclosure, I don't work for Feedly nor do I own any of the company. I just like the service!)

http://feedly.com

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://jsonfeed.org/ has had some preliminary traction. Of course, the reason RSS works so well is that everyone uses the same format. So you wouldn't see so much of a "switch" as a bunch of readers accepting either format, for a very, very long time. That being said, I don't see what's "wrong" with XML in this context.

There's nothing "wrong" with XML but with JSON there's no need to add another 5 pounds (2.2 KG) of JavaScript to convert XML to JavaScript objects. For any other language it doesn't matter since you're re-mapping to objects, most likely, but with JavaScript eating the web (even on the server side) I think the question should be "why shouldn't this be JSON" as a default. In the end either way works. I would love to se…

Alternatively, if all you're doing is supporting RSS, you could opt to just use the DOMParser API (native to most browsers) and navigate a DOMTree which is a type of JavaScript Object already...

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#23
> So the very idea of RSS - obtaining content from a website without having to visit the site itself - is due for a comeback. No ads.

RSS content may or may not be free of ads, but that is based on what you subscribe to.

I used Google Reader heavily, now I use theoldreader.

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#24
It’s starting to feel like everyone is jumping on the write-an-article-about-reviving-RSS bandwagon.

Not disagreeing with the premise, but I think I’ve seen at least a half-dozen articles saying the same thing in the last few weeks. Can’t help but wonder if it’s getting click-baity (or perhaps click-hungry) every time I see yet-another-RSS-is-back-baby.

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#25

I'm surprised how often RSS is mentioned on Hackernews, and how infrequently some recommends Feedly. It has wonderful features, like saving articles, collection boards, team features, and popularity-based sorting options. (Full disclosure, I don't work for Feedly nor do I own any of the company. I just like the service!) http://feedly.com

Agreed. But it has been very frustrating that they haven't allowed boards to be public.

Maybe someone knows a service that lets you mark posts from your feed to be shared as a public collection?

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#26

I'm surprised how often RSS is mentioned on Hackernews, and how infrequently some recommends Feedly. It has wonderful features, like saving articles, collection boards, team features, and popularity-based sorting options. (Full disclosure, I don't work for Feedly nor do I own any of the company. I just like the service!) http://feedly.com

I can recommend Inoreader.

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#27
Did anyone else notice how corporations like Twitter and Facebook quietly tried to kill RSS in the past 10 years?

RSS is a wonderful technology with embodies the spirit of the Internet. Facebook and Twitter are, by comparison, cancer.

I often recommend WordPress to folks as an alternative for blogging, because it is free and has RSS functional out of the box.

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#28

I'm surprised how often RSS is mentioned on Hackernews, and how infrequently some recommends Feedly. It has wonderful features, like saving articles, collection boards, team features, and popularity-based sorting options. (Full disclosure, I don't work for Feedly nor do I own any of the company. I just like the service!) http://feedly.com

My use of RSS has fallen (very recently) so I only consume a few feeds every day.

However, I both enjoy and dislike Feedly. Here’s the rundown:

Pros)

- advanced features like highlighting, team management

- pure free offering that just works

- integration with pretty much every feed reader app out there

Cons:

- no ability/willingness to pull full text

- iOS app is honestly kind of clunky

I emailed them that I’d willingly migrate from a different app that I pay a subscription for if only they’d pull the full text, but they told me that is an intentional non-feature. Big bummer.

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#29
If RSS threatens to become mainstream again, expect pushback from content providers. I know a blog where the owner will ban any commenter from the site for even mentioning that there is an RSS feed. He believes that the RSS feed that his CMS provides by default, is somehow important for SEO, but he doesn’t want people getting his content through RSS because his way of monetizing the site requires that people reguarly visit the site itself.

Re: Now Is the Perfect Time for an RSS Renaissance

#30

Is there anything that can turn your email into a secure personal RSS feed? A feed reader that also includes emails would replace quite a bit of what centralized social media provides.

Have you tried Thunderbird (https://www.thunderbird.net)? Combines email, RSS and newsgroups.
Post reply on HN