Live data from Hacker News

Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

zeit.co

21–30 of 231 posts

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#21

While it was thinkable all the time, it renders me speechless, that finally somebody has put that stack under a terminal. The next big thing will be electron-based smooth-scroll, mouse-animation and finally: a 70mb beep.

I also don't get it. Why would I want a full web browser to power my terminal? Just because we can, doesn't mean that we should...

You wouldn't. It's pretty much purely a convenience for the author of the software.

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#22

Pop quiz: what's more ridiculous, nodejs based command line utilities that do the same thing as two existing shell utilities and a pipe or a while loop etc; OR, an electron "shell"... which can then run those same nodejs "utilities"... Oh maybe that's the whole point. They want "it's javascript all the way down". I think I'd literally rather use a shell built on actual turtles. A turtle-shell, if you will.

Zeit's generally pretty JavaScript focused so it doesn't surprise me, but another electron app. Man :'(

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#23
I think that electron desperately needs boot loader and own kernel, then they will be able to reimplement whole operating system in js.

...god of bloated software and goddess of complex solutions of simple non problems got their blood sacrifice and the sun will rise again.

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#24

While it was thinkable all the time, it renders me speechless, that finally somebody has put that stack under a terminal. The next big thing will be electron-based smooth-scroll, mouse-animation and finally: a 70mb beep.

I'm just waiting for an electron based web browser.

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#25

Pop quiz: what's more ridiculous, nodejs based command line utilities that do the same thing as two existing shell utilities and a pipe or a while loop etc; OR, an electron "shell"... which can then run those same nodejs "utilities"... Oh maybe that's the whole point. They want "it's javascript all the way down". I think I'd literally rather use a shell built on actual turtles. A turtle-shell, if you will.

The whole electron stack disgusts me. Mainly because of battery usage on my laptop and my phone!

Its a clear example of "We can do it but should we do we?" The answer is NO!

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#26
post #24

While it was thinkable all the time, it renders me speechless, that finally somebody has put that stack under a terminal. The next big thing will be electron-based smooth-scroll, mouse-animation and finally: a 70mb beep.

I'm just waiting for an electron based web browser.

That has already been done [0].

[0] https://github.com/brave/browser-laptop

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#27

Maybe I'm missing something... is there a benefit to this over a normal terminal/terminal emulator? (eg xterm, mac terminal etc)? As far as I can tell, putting it in electron would mean that you could embed arbitrary HTML structures inside the terminal (like web page previews or something), but from what I've read, it doesn't look like that's the goal.

The benefit is for the authors' CVs

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#28
post #25

Pop quiz: what's more ridiculous, nodejs based command line utilities that do the same thing as two existing shell utilities and a pipe or a while loop etc; OR, an electron "shell"... which can then run those same nodejs "utilities"... Oh maybe that's the whole point. They want "it's javascript all the way down". I think I'd literally rather use a shell built on actual turtles. A turtle-shell, if you will.

The whole electron stack disgusts me. Mainly because of battery usage on my laptop and my phone! Its a clear example of "We can do it but should we do we?" The answer is NO!

hey, how else can I change the transparency of my shell with css ?

Re: Hyper 2, Electron based terminal

#30

Pop quiz: what's more ridiculous, nodejs based command line utilities that do the same thing as two existing shell utilities and a pipe or a while loop etc; OR, an electron "shell"... which can then run those same nodejs "utilities"... Oh maybe that's the whole point. They want "it's javascript all the way down". I think I'd literally rather use a shell built on actual turtles. A turtle-shell, if you will.

To really get into the 'JS all the way down' you could run it on JSLinux [1] or a similar JS-based full system emulator.

[1] https://bellard.org/jslinux/

Post reply on HN