Live data from Hacker News

After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

phys.org

11–20 of 255 posts

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#11
post #5
post #2

Congress should take action, and install a watchdog that continuously monitors these companies; e.g. by verifying that data placed online cannot be bought through different channels.

That isnt going to happen under the current deregulatory administration.

it's unlikely to happen in any administration. proactive monitoring is cost prohibitive compared to reactive punishment and a legal framework for doing so. as you said, the latter is unlikely to be meaningfully strengthened.

fines and enforcement must present a significantly larger liability than profit opportunity for any real changes to ever take place. else it's just written down as another expense of doing business as usual.

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#12
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That isnt going to happen under the current deregulatory administration.

it's unlikely to happen in any administration. proactive monitoring is cost prohibitive compared to reactive punishment and a legal framework for doing so. as you said, the latter is unlikely to be meaningfully strengthened. fines and enforcement must present a significantly larger liability than profit opportunity for any real changes to ever take place. else it's just written down as another expense of doing busine…

On the other side, it sounds like a job that needs to be done 24/7 and could be done remotely. Precisely the sort of thing that could employ rural America with suitable infrastructure build-out.

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#13
post #2

Congress should take action, and install a watchdog that continuously monitors these companies; e.g. by verifying that data placed online cannot be bought through different channels.

That is wrong way to approach the issue. These companies should not be gathering personal information worse than NSA. Personal information is personal, and free people in a free society should not be followed by multinational corporations.

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#14
post #13
post #2

Congress should take action, and install a watchdog that continuously monitors these companies; e.g. by verifying that data placed online cannot be bought through different channels.

That is wrong way to approach the issue. These companies should not be gathering personal information worse than NSA. Personal information is personal, and free people in a free society should not be followed by multinational corporations.

I like your sentiment but we’re talking serious company breakups in order to force it. Pretty much most industries could use some trust-busting but the political imperative (outrage) isn’t directed that way.

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#15
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That isnt going to happen under the current deregulatory administration.

it's unlikely to happen in any administration. proactive monitoring is cost prohibitive compared to reactive punishment and a legal framework for doing so. as you said, the latter is unlikely to be meaningfully strengthened. fines and enforcement must present a significantly larger liability than profit opportunity for any real changes to ever take place. else it's just written down as another expense of doing busine…

> proactive monitoring is cost prohibitive compared to reactive punishment and a legal framework for doing so

Counterfactual: finance, another high-margin industry with a penchant for bad decision making, funds a proactive and multi-pronged regulatory apparatus. We are all safer for it.

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#16
I trust Google, but it's only because I have to. Their tools are 10x better than anything else for many cases, so you're simply doing yourself a disservice to not use them. It's not like Facebook where I can just email my friends or whatever. Google search is a fundamentally life changing technology that is untouched by any competitor.

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#17
post #8

Next is passing laws to avoid those kind of problems (like GDPR). It's not sufficient to go after each shady company that sells your data.

Exactly. There has to be a framework that everyone has to follow. Imagine we had no laws against theft and you would get into trouble only if you overdid it by some undefined standard

No, it’s more like people leaving shit all over your property and when you go pick it up they come back and want to charge you with theft.

Re: After Facebook scrutiny, is Google next?

#19
What would happen to Google? Nothing happened to Facebook except a slap on the wrist. They'll continue doing everything they do and only a few of us nerds on the internet will really care.

Americans have the attention span of fruit flies, which is why none of this actually matters long term.

Post reply on HN