Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

news.ycombinator.com

71–79 of 79 posts

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#71
Over 20k bookmarks on pinboard.in half of which were migrated over from the original delicious

Started with the $11 forever plan but then actually started paying for archive option on pinboard just in case.

Link rot is a bit of problem I think about 30% are dead.

I trust pinboard more than pretty much any VC backed company.

Only problem is the bus factor of 1.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#72
post #71

Over 20k bookmarks on pinboard.in half of which were migrated over from the original delicious Started with the $11 forever plan but then actually started paying for archive option on pinboard just in case. Link rot is a bit of problem I think about 30% are dead. I trust pinboard more than pretty much any VC backed company. Only problem is the bus factor of 1.

Honest question, not meant to be rude, but what value do you get from having created 20k bookmarks?

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#73
post #72
post #71

Over 20k bookmarks on pinboard.in half of which were migrated over from the original delicious Started with the $11 forever plan but then actually started paying for archive option on pinboard just in case. Link rot is a bit of problem I think about 30% are dead. I trust pinboard more than pretty much any VC backed company. Only problem is the bus factor of 1.

Honest question, not meant to be rude, but what value do you get from having created 20k bookmarks?

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> - Browser integrations for every browser worth mentioning I'm missing the ability to sync with a browser's built-in bookmarks.

that's probably true, but I can't say for sure: I purged all of my local browser bookmarks years ago. Pinboard is ground truth for me for specific links. Feedly has become my repository of bookmarks-of-sites-i-like-to-read-in-general.

Why can't it be ground truth and sync to browsers' bookmarks? - I refuse to use anything that is not integrated with the browser bookmarks. All these numerous web "bookmarks" are just silly.

The above mentioned floccus/nextcloud looked promising but then they mentioned they can't sync different browsers from the same root. Somehow Xmarks doesn't have that problem. I am still looking for comparable replacement. Bookmarks are a way for immediate direct access to things I don't remember than a search tool for me. For search I can just google.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Definitely. Reasonably priced, I'm the customer, and it works with Android and Firefox, which are my everyday tools.

Had an account for a while, just now really starting using it. How do you use it with Android and Firefox? The official plugin says it doesn't work with Firefox Quantum.

I use https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/pinboard-pin/ on Firefox and https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.pindroid&h... on Android.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#77
post #72
post #71

Over 20k bookmarks on pinboard.in half of which were migrated over from the original delicious Started with the $11 forever plan but then actually started paying for archive option on pinboard just in case. Link rot is a bit of problem I think about 30% are dead. I trust pinboard more than pretty much any VC backed company. Only problem is the bus factor of 1.

Honest question, not meant to be rude, but what value do you get from having created 20k bookmarks?

Probably 99% of bookmarks I am not ever going to see again, but finding that 1% is such a lifesaver.

As in I am doing a research on some topic and I already have a whole bunch of links nicely tagged and ready to go.

The problem is that you do not know which 1% are going to be useful again.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#78
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

that's probably true, but I can't say for sure: I purged all of my local browser bookmarks years ago. Pinboard is ground truth for me for specific links. Feedly has become my repository of bookmarks-of-sites-i-like-to-read-in-general.

Why can't it be ground truth and sync to browsers' bookmarks? - I refuse to use anything that is not integrated with the browser bookmarks. All these numerous web "bookmarks" are just silly. The above mentioned floccus/nextcloud looked promising but then they mentioned they can't sync different browsers from the same root. Somehow Xmarks doesn't have that problem. I am still looking for comparable replacement. Bookma…

For those interested I found https://github.com/xBrowserSync to be the most promising. The only thing it doesn't have firefox extension yet.

Re: Ask HN: Where do you store bookmarks?

#79
post #71

Over 20k bookmarks on pinboard.in half of which were migrated over from the original delicious Started with the $11 forever plan but then actually started paying for archive option on pinboard just in case. Link rot is a bit of problem I think about 30% are dead. I trust pinboard more than pretty much any VC backed company. Only problem is the bus factor of 1.

> Link rot is a bit of problem I think about 30% are dead.

It would be nice to have a Firefox addon that would automatically submit your bookmark links for archival at major link archival services..

edit: Looks like at least one such addon exist: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/archiveror/

Post reply on HN