Live data from Hacker News

Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

inthemesh.com

61–70 of 356 posts

Re: Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

#61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ironic words from a HN user with over 10k karma.

This isn't a social network. Do you see me posting picture of my bathroom/kids/furniture/food?

Forums are typically considered social networks, although I suppose the definition is debatable. Whether users discuss their daily lives is not the standard, though. On Twitter everyone just kvetches about the news, and it's still a social network.

Re: Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

#62
post #10

If I may, a decentralized alternative to facebook would be community-based, allow people to do group chats, discover and post events, see attendees, meet each other, add each other to contacts, maybe even drive each other to the events, date, book group reservations at local businesses etc. Like this: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI Yes that’s my project. Would love to get feedback. (The things I mentioned…

FWIW, I did a survey of people asking which features from Facebook that absolutely must have to consider switching to a replacement. As much as people say the events, chats, and local community features are important... exactly zero people checked those boxes in my survey results. Pretty much the only thing people checked was 'connect with friends'

[deleted]

Re: Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

#63
post #10

If I may, a decentralized alternative to facebook would be community-based, allow people to do group chats, discover and post events, see attendees, meet each other, add each other to contacts, maybe even drive each other to the events, date, book group reservations at local businesses etc. Like this: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI Yes that’s my project. Would love to get feedback. (The things I mentioned…

FWIW, I did a survey of people asking which features from Facebook that absolutely must have to consider switching to a replacement. As much as people say the events, chats, and local community features are important... exactly zero people checked those boxes in my survey results. Pretty much the only thing people checked was 'connect with friends'

Worth noting that what users say they will do and what they actually end up doing frequently diverge.

Re: Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

#64
post #32

Not to be too meta, but the magazine this was published in is all about decentralization — I'm biased because I was involved in it, but if you're on this thread, you may want to check it out. Just launched: https://inthemesh.com

Nice, no RSS feed?

When in doubt, add /feed and it probably works: https://inthemesh.com/feed/

Re: Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

#66

I think it's fascinating to see distributed social networks from a tech perspective. From what I've seen so far they exacerbate the problems that Facebook has been seeing so much backlash against. 1. The whole Cambridge Analytica issue was caused by APIs that are too open. For distributed systems there are more ways to exploit the APIs and gather data on users. 2. There is a clear issue with Facebook's accountability…

The whole issue with facebook is that they: 1. Follow you from site to site, scooping up all the data they can on you. 2. Allowed all of that data to be accessible not just by you opening up to a bad actor app, but by any of your friends opening up to a bad actor app. Calling it "overly open APIs" is misleading at best. The point of an A P I is that it is a public interface. If Scuttlebut has proper permissions contr…

Minor nitpick: API stands for "Application Programming Interface". There are plenty of private APIs in use right now all over the world.

Re: Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

#68

It isn't an alternative to Facebook unless my grandma can use it, and she couldn't set this up for herself. The idea that centralized storage is the problem masks the actual concern. There is nothing inherently wrong with centrally stored data. There is a problem is when it is locked down by a 3rd party, and/or you don't control how it is used.

>It isn't an alternative to Facebook unless my grandma can use it, and she couldn't set this up for herself. Facebook isn't an alternative to email if my grandma can't use it. Computers aren't an alternative to telephones if my grandma can't use it. Telephones aren't an alternative to mail if my grandma can't use it. etc. --- It'll get easier and simpler, I promise.

My Grandma definitely skipped from a corded phone to an iPad with Facebook and right over email. It's still too complicated for her.

Re: Scuttlebutt, a Decentralized Alternative to Facebook

#70
post #32

Not to be too meta, but the magazine this was published in is all about decentralization — I'm biased because I was involved in it, but if you're on this thread, you may want to check it out. Just launched: https://inthemesh.com

I've added it to my TTRSS instance, their initial articles look interesting. Will yet be seen if the content holds up on a regular publishing basis.
Post reply on HN