Live data from Hacker News

Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

cloudplatform.googleblog.com

21–30 of 108 posts

Re: Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

#21

We actually just migrated off yesterday... we went with an independent vendor like Aiven instead of the clouds because they move too slowly and don't have enough features.

Like aiven or aiven? :) I’m not aware of too much competition in this space. We’re happy with aiven so far, but they’re quite unknown / under the radar it seems...

They're the best we've found as well, but there are lots of managed database providers of all kinds. https://www.compose.com is another big one.

Re: Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

#22
post #13

How do you deal with custom extensions (for example plv8)? I started off with heroku and they don't support the same subset: https://cloud.google.com/sql/docs/postgres/extensions https://devcenter.heroku.com/articles/heroku-postgres-extens...

https://cloud.google.com/sql/docs/postgres/extensions

Looks like a preset list of extensions. I'd assume custom extensions would be very difficult to support in managed postgres.

Re: Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

#23
post #13

How do you deal with custom extensions (for example plv8)? I started off with heroku and they don't support the same subset: https://cloud.google.com/sql/docs/postgres/extensions https://devcenter.heroku.com/articles/heroku-postgres-extens...

They don't have a great story around extensions - the ones they do have are unsupported/buggy. For example, PostGIS is missing "ST_FromGeoJSON" because it was compiled with the wrong flag - and has been this way for over a year despite hundreds of user complaints.

Re: Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

#25
Does anyone have insight or experience using this in production? We're currently running PostgreSQL 10 w/ pg_partman on our own hardware but looking at a several options for cloud migration. Unfortunately, Citus Cloud on GCP doesn't appear to be an option (yet?)

- Google Cloud SQL (PostgreSQL)

- Citus Cloud (AWS Only)

- Citus (managed ourselves) on GCP

Re: Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

#26
post #25

Does anyone have insight or experience using this in production? We're currently running PostgreSQL 10 w/ pg_partman on our own hardware but looking at a several options for cloud migration. Unfortunately, Citus Cloud on GCP doesn't appear to be an option (yet?) - Google Cloud SQL (PostgreSQL) - Citus Cloud (AWS Only) - Citus (managed ourselves) on GCP

citus isn't simply postgresql. It has many tradeoffs

Re: Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

#27
post #25

Does anyone have insight or experience using this in production? We're currently running PostgreSQL 10 w/ pg_partman on our own hardware but looking at a several options for cloud migration. Unfortunately, Citus Cloud on GCP doesn't appear to be an option (yet?) - Google Cloud SQL (PostgreSQL) - Citus Cloud (AWS Only) - Citus (managed ourselves) on GCP

citus isn't simply postgresql. It has many tradeoffs

We get that, but I left off (for brevity) the reasons why Citus would be a net positive for our use case.

Re: Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL now generally available

#29
post #13

How do you deal with custom extensions (for example plv8)? I started off with heroku and they don't support the same subset: https://cloud.google.com/sql/docs/postgres/extensions https://devcenter.heroku.com/articles/heroku-postgres-extens...

They don't have a great story around extensions - the ones they do have are unsupported/buggy. For example, PostGIS is missing "ST_FromGeoJSON" because it was compiled with the wrong flag - and has been this way for over a year despite hundreds of user complaints.

This is what I expect from Google. They are not customer-centric and no-one is really prioritising or cares about customer feedback.
Post reply on HN