Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
quantamagazine.org
Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
1–10 of 77 posts
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#2I was really hoping this was about weather forecasting.
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#3>when the powerful algorithm known as “deep learning”
Quanta is normally better than this (and the rest of the article is decent). But still :(
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#4I was really hoping this was about weather forecasting.
It can be!
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#5Very cool! This looks like a very promising way to improve weather forecasts, predict wildfire movements (maybe?), and can maybe be used in control for chaotic systems? (Among other uses of course).
It feels like every day I'm seeing deep learning make more mathematical tools obsolete. It's amazing how useful this tool has been.
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#6Don't be too seduced by the enticing ideas at the end of the article. The disconnect here is that success in learning how to predict the results of an algorithmic simulation is not really indicative of how it would perform with the decidedly non-algorithmic natural behavior of weather or earthquakes, phenomena which don't operate in a closed system with predefined limits and parameters. It sounds like the next step, but even if weather were reducible to machine-discoverable patterns, you first must face the need to collect an immense amount of high-resolution condition data from around the globe on an ongoing basis. I'm guessing our current mesh of satellites and weather stations, as impressive as it is, comes nowhere close to enough raw data to sufficiently feed the beast in this case. And even that assumes that we _know about_ and can measure all of the factors that go into weather patterns. I sincerely doubt that's the case.
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#7Isn't deterministic-chaos an oxymoron?
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#8Can we have more publishing like Quanta magazine? It's just perfect in terms of reporting from the frontier, being easy to unsetstand, and not talking down to you.
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#9Isn't deterministic-chaos an oxymoron?
No. Chaotic dynamical system can be completely deterministic.
Re: Machine Learning’s ‘Amazing’ Ability to Predict Chaos
#10Isn't deterministic-chaos an oxymoron?
The fact that the answer to this is "no" has fed entire subfields of mathematics for a generation.