Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Container for Firefox

mozilla.org

121–130 of 406 posts

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#121
post #82

Can't this be easily bypassed by Facebook? Given the amount of information usable to fingerprint browsers with JS enabled can't FB do some basic tricks like IP + WebRTC local IP + WebGL fingerprint + Canvas Fingerprint , etc...?

If users need to go through so many hoops to avoid facebook tracking, Best use privacy badger + don't use facebook at all.

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#122
post #62

I would like to isolate every website I visit into a container, such that cookies or other tracking mechanisms are unable to be effective while on other pages.

it is linked elsewhere on this page, but this will do that https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/temporary-con...

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#123
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This would let Google know these accounts are affiliated with the same person on your network, whereas containers won't necessarily provide that assumption. Right?

If they wanted to they could associate them other ways by just looking at the IP address and/or browser fingerprinting.

My thought is that they can certainly find good indicators that they're related, but that signing into them at the same time directly in their website confirms the relationship. Bear in mind, everything coming from say, a corporate network, won't be distinguishable by IP, and browser fingerprinting is likely less helpful in an environment with a hundred PCs running identical system images.

Your home device may not live in such a family, but it's hard for Google to determine that.

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#124
post #31

We're going from cold war to all-in. Not just a privacy question. Reddit nags me every time I hit the front page, even returning from a story, asking me to log in. For most sites I need to create ublock filters to prevent pop-ups with useless "we use cookies", subscription requests, ads or social media bars that fills half the screen, etc. etc. etc. Every newspaper I read has decided that autostarting video and strea…

> Every newspaper I read has decided that autostarting video and streaming is a good idea.

If you're using Firefox, go to about:config and set media.autoplay.enabled to false.

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn't Privacy Badger do about the same, but more granular and breaking fewer things?

By not breaking things, Privacy Badger will essentially let some cookies and trackers pass through which aren't cross tracking but these could leave behind a trail. Some will stay dormant until activated. CAD or any similar cookie deleting add-on will essentially kill any cookie that isn't required for your active tabs. This way nothing is left behind to track or trail you.

What about browser fingerprinting (https://panopticlick.eff.org/)? Unless you are using the Tor browser, this appears "uncontainable" especially for folks not using Chrome over Windows 10 or another super generic combination.

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#128
post #93
post #83

can someone explain why this is necessary? shouldn't anything that happens outside of any site stay outside that site, why a special extension just for facebook?

Let’s say you go to example.com and they’re using a Facebook Pixel for analytics - so example.com can continue marketing that widget to you after you’ve left their site. Well, when you visit example.com/shop/widget1 you essentially load a 1x1 pixel image from the url ads.facebook.com/pixel?metadata=goes-here and you web browser sends your Facebook cookie along side the request (as it does for every request to .facebo…

Can't the websites share that information with facebook by proxying that information? It'd be the same workaround as for ads if you host them it's very hard for someone else to block them, especially if you use dynamically named divs, image sizes etc.

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#129
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's smart – my only complaint when seeing this is "how come nobody's focusing on Google?"

Mozilla is paid by Google. WHy would they antagonize their own parent company?

Mozilla and Google have a business contract with a well-defined scope. Google has a similar contract with Apple. Google isn't Mozilla's parent company just as it isn't Apple's.

Re: Facebook Container for Firefox

#130
post #31

We're going from cold war to all-in. Not just a privacy question. Reddit nags me every time I hit the front page, even returning from a story, asking me to log in. For most sites I need to create ublock filters to prevent pop-ups with useless "we use cookies", subscription requests, ads or social media bars that fills half the screen, etc. etc. etc. Every newspaper I read has decided that autostarting video and strea…

When you mentioned reddit I thought you were talking about their "install the app" pop up. They have by far the worst mobile experience out of any site I've use more than once in the last 2 years.

Twitter mobile. Scroll down for a screen, full page "Log in/Sign up" popup. Every single page.
Post reply on HN