Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Do we still need native apps?

news.ycombinator.com

41–46 of 46 posts

Re: Ask HN: Do we still need native apps?

#41
post #11

Do we still need web apps? There's notorious sites like reddit who try to push you to visit their web page, so they can serve you ADS.

In visiting a mobile webpage, an adblocker suffices. native apps can utilize advertising APIs, of which there's no way to turn off unless you install their $3.99 "Premium" app.

sounds like a very bad excuse to push native apps which can be much greater security hazards than web pages

Re: Ask HN: Do we still need native apps?

#42
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> People moan about how it's slow No, I moan about how it's an abuse of my privacy, an abuse of my security & an abuse of the web itself. Web pages which use JavaScript enable all sorts of malicious nastiness which plain websites do not. They are impossible to properly secure (in that I get a new version every time I open it up). They are not what the WWW was meant to be. No thank you.

OK so how is a native application different? You can do the exact same things in a native app.

Because it's possible for a native app to be secure. I can audit it, pay someone else to audit it for me or rely on someone's free audit. I download the code once, and run it many times, rather than downloading a fresh version each time, and hoping the provider hasn't tampered with it. I can even run it offline, on an airgapped computer.

And a native app is using the APIs of its platform as intended, rather than violating its entire raison d'être, like single page apps violate the Web.

Post reply on HN